ENGLISH FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
TEACHER'S GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENTS | ||
CONTENTS | PAGE | |
1 | Introduction | 6 |
2 | Aims and Objectives of School-based Assessment | 7 |
3 | Programme of Assessment | 9 |
4 | Assessment Tasks | 10 |
a | Term 1 | |
How to administer a formal listening comprehension task | 8 | |
Task 1 – Exemplar 1: Listening comprehension | 9 | |
Task 1 – Exemplar 2: Listening comprehension | 11 | |
How to administer an essay | 13 | |
Task 2 – Exemplar 1: Writing an essay | 14 | |
Task 2 – Exemplar 2: Writing an essay | 16 | |
Task 2 – Exemplar 3: Writing an essay | 18 | |
How to administer a longer transactional task | 20 | |
Task 3 – Exemplar 1: Writing a longer transactional task | 21 | |
Task 3 – Exemplar 2: Writing a longer transactional task | 23 | |
Task 3 – Exemplar 3: Writing a longer transactional task | 24 | |
b | Term 2 | |
How to teach and assess reading aloud | 26 | |
Task 5 – Exemplar 1: Oral: Prepared reading | 27 | |
Task 5 – Sample reading passages | 28 | |
How to teach and assess a prepared speech | 34 | |
Task 6 – Exemplar 1: Oral: Prepared speech | 35 | |
c | Term 3 | |
How to administer a shorter transactional task …. | 36 | |
Task 9 – Exemplar 1: Writing a shorter transactional task | 37 | |
Task 9 – Exemplar 2: Writing a shorter transactional task | 39 | |
5 | Marking Guidelines | 44 |
Task 1 – Exemplar 1: Listening comprehension | 44 | |
Task 1 – Exemplar 2: Listening comprehension | 45 | |
Task 2 – Essay: General marking guidelines and instructions | 46 | |
Task 2 – Sample: Essay | 47 | |
Task 3 – Longer transactional tasks: General marking guidelines | 48 | |
Task 3 – Exemplar 1: Longer transactional tasks | 49 | |
Task 3 – Exemplar 2: Longer transactional tasks | 51 | |
Task 3 – Exemplar 3: Longer transactional tasks | 53 | |
Task 3 – Sample: Longer transactional task: Restaurant review | 54 | |
Task 9 – Shorter transactional tasks: General marking guidelines | 55 | |
Task 9 – Exemplar 1: Shorter transactional task | 56 | |
Task 9 – Exemplar 2: Shorter transactional task | 57 | |
Task 9 – Sample: Shorter transaction task: Diary entry | 58 | |
6 | Rubrics | 61 |
Essay | 59 | |
Longer Transactional Task | 60 | |
Shorter Transactional Task | 61 | |
Prepared Reading | 62 | |
Prepared Speaking | 63 |
1. Introduction
“School-based assessment is a purposive collection of learners’ work that tells the story of the learners’ efforts, progress or achievement in given area(s).”
This exemplar booklet serves as a guide to schools and subject teachers on how to administer school-based assessment (SBA) for English First Additional Language from 2014.
School-based assessment is an integral part of learners’ preparation for the final examinations. Their school-based assessment mark is formally recorded by you, the teacher, for progression and certification purposes.
These formal assessment tasks provide you with a systematic method of evaluating how well learners are progressing and this guideline includes various assessment tasks such as tests, examinations, writing tasks, oral presentations and listening comprehension.
School-based assessment is compulsory for all learners. If learners cannot comply with the requirements specified according to the policy, they may not be eligible to enter for the subject in the final examination.
Formal assessment tasks form part of a year-long formal programme of assessment. These tasks should not be taken lightly and learners should be encouraged to submit their best possible efforts for final assessment.
Remember to keep your assessment relevant to and suitable for the learners you teach. Adapt the tasks to suit your particular needs, remembering keeping in mind however, that you are guided by the requirements as set out in the CAPS. policy document.
2. Aims and objectives of school-based assessment
The distinctive characteristics of SBA (and its strengths as one relatively small component of a coherent assessment system) have implications for its design and implementation, in particular the nature of the assessment tasks and role of the teachers’ standardisation procedures. These implications are summarised as follows:
Teachers should ensure that students have read and understood the assessment criteria and have extensive experience of using it for self and peer-assessment in informal situations before conducting a planned assessment activity. Teachers should also have used these criteria for informal assessment and teaching purposes before they conduct any formal assessment so that they are familiar with the criteria and the assessment process.
3. Programme of Assessment
Term 1 | Task 1 | Task 2 | Task 3 | Task 4 | ||
Oral: | Writing: | *Writing: | **Test 1: | |||
Total: | 10 | 50 | 30 | 40 | ||
Term 2 | Task 5 | Task 6 | Task 7 | Task 8 | ||
Oral: | Oral: | Literature: | ****Mid-year examinations | |||
Total: | 20 | 20 | 35 | 250 | ||
Term 3 | Task 9 | Task 10 | ||||
***Writing: Shorter transactional writing | ****Preparatory examinations | |||||
Total: | 20 | 250 |
* Friendly/Formal letters (request/complaint/application/business)/formal and informal letters to the press/ curriculum vitae and covering letter/obituary/agenda and minutes of meeting/report/review/newspaper article/magazine article/dialogue/ interview.
** Test 1 should be set out of 40 marks or, if more, should be converted to 40 marks. While the Comprehension, Summary, Language structures and conventions combination is suggested, teachers are urged to design a combination of aspects that fits the character (test programme, time allocation, etc.) of the school. A test in the Programme of Assessment should not be made up of several smaller tests. Each test should cover a substantial amount of content, should be set for 45–60 minutes, and should reflect the different cognitive levels as set out for exam papers.
*** Advertisements/Diary entries/Postcards/Invitation cards/Filling in forms/ Directions/Instructions/Flyers/Posters/ emails.
**** Mid-year and Trial examinations: In Grade 12 one of the tasks in Term 2 and/or Term 3 (Tasks 8 and/or 10) must be an internal examination. In instances where only one of the two internal examinations is written in Grade 12, the other examination could be replaced by a test. A recommendation has been made that the written test, if this option is chosen, should be set out of 80 marks. This test should take the format of the Language structure and conventions, as set in the examinations.
4. Tasks
a. Term 1
Being able to listen well is an important part of communication for everyone. For our students, guided practice by a teacher is one of the best ways to improve this skill. A student with good listening comprehension skills will be able to participate more effectively in communicative situations. Teaching the skill of listening cannot be emphasised enough in a communicative classroom. For First Additional Language learners, developing the skill of listening comprehension is extremely important.
When the learning objective of a language class is explained to students, they can focus better on specific vocabulary acquisition, grammar practice, listening for different purposes, and so on. This clear explanation by the teacher of a lesson’s pedagogic goals will help learners to further develop specific objectives in a shorter amount of time. For instance, by informing students that the lesson will be about giving directions, they can consciously focus on remembering the vocabulary used in that activity.
It is important to maintain an interactive and communicative approach for teaching English as a first additional language. However, it is also important to vary the students’ learning focus by concentrating on the skills needed to become proficient in a second language. Listening comprehension is one such a required skill.
When designing lessons and teaching materials to further develop listening comprehension skills, students need to be motivated and stay motivated. This is best accomplished by determining the suitability of the listening materials, the techniques used in classroom teaching, and the use of authentic materials. Two sample listening comprehension tasks have been developed for your convenience.
How to administer a formal listening comprehension task:
Task 1 – Exemplar 1: Listening Comprehension
UP, UP AND AWAY
Matt Silver-Vallance will be strapping himself to 200 helium-filled party balloons and flying – yes, flying – from Robben Island to the mainland.
Charity and children are two things very close to the hearts of many South Africans. It’s rare, however, that you’ll find an individual willing to risk his or her life for the cause. For Matt Silver-Vallance, the Nelson Mandela Children’s Hospital is worth a daring stunt – a flight from Robben Island to the mainland over shark-infested waters with only a bunch of helium balloons to keep him up in the air.
“Balloons represent a child who is healthy and happy,” Matt explains. “My best friend Steve and I actually had the idea before the movie UP so it’s always a bit of a laugh because people say, ‘Oh, like the movie’ and I want to say, ‘No, we had the idea first.’” While this flight is not as daring as a whole house flying across the skies, there are still some concerns. Matt laughs and says that one of the major worries is the weather. “In April we may get consistent south-easterlies which would take me to the Caribbean.” But the real concern for the light-hearted dad who has a bountiful sense of humour is that they won’t reach enough people and that the stunt won’t be as effective as it has the potential to be.
The first ever cluster-ballooning flight in Africa, Matt’s aim is to raise R10 million for the hospital. He has been planning the stunt for over four years. The Cape Town-born daredevil became familiar with the children’s hospital in his early 20s while working as a volunteer paramedic for the Western Cape Ambulance Service. Although he now lives in the UK and has gone down a different career path, the need for paediatric care in South Africa is an issue he has never forgotten. “I chose the Nelson Mandela Children’s Hospital because a happy child is a wonderful thing and an unhealthy child can be a terrible thing to witness. My experience as a paramedic taking children to the Red Cross Children’s Hospital inspired me.” Oddly enough, he doesn’t consider it a challenge as he says laughing, “It should be very easy. I’ll be relaxing in my harness, floating over Table Bay looking at the beautiful Table Mountain.” (364 words)
[Source: Indwe Magazine, April 2013]
Listening Comprehension
Name: _______________________ Grade: _______________________
Date: _______________________
TOTAL: 10
Task 1 – Exemplar 2: Listening Comprehension
PUT AN END TO BULLYING
(This article appeared in a magazine for teachers called What’s up Teach?)
We all know that children learn best in an environment where they feel safe and secure. Many children don’t learn because they come to school fearful of being bullied. Unfortunately, there’s no single solution that will stop or prevent bullying. What’s Up Teach? interviewed two school principals to find out what they have done to reduce bullying in their schools.
WHAT IS BULLYING? It is the repeated behaviour by an individual or group that intentionally hurts another individual or group either physically or emotionally. Often bullying is motivated by some prejudice or other against particular groups or by actual or perceived differences between children. Emotional bullying can be hard to identify and can be very damaging to children. |
Mrs Moima told us that she had received a number of complaints from parents that their children were being bullied.
“We decided to be proactive,” says Mrs Moima.
“We held a workshop and we spoke about what issues could result in bullying and we developed strategies to prevent bullying. We needed to change the culture to one where pupils treat one another and the school staff with respect.
Not an easy task! We asked Mrs Moima what they did.
WE HELD A POSTER COMPETITION “Groups of learners designed posters on good values in the school, to show the importance of respect for staff and other pupils. The children set up a jury to judge the posters. This actually became an advocacy campaign that helped to permeate the values of respect and care throughout the whole school environment.” |
Mrs Moima tells us they introduced the following school rules specifically to deal with bullying:
They also introduced ways of dealing with aggressive behaviour:
(333 words)
Listening Comprehension
Name: _________________________ Grade: _________________________
Date: _________________________
TOTAL: 10
How to administer an essay
Learners should be familiar with the following types of essays:
General teaching guidelines and instructions
Task 2 – Writing: Essay
In order to write well, you need knowledge of different text types, a wide vocabulary, a good control of English grammar, spelling and punctuation, and a critical understanding of the potential effects of your writing.
An essay is an extended piece of writing, in which a writer expresses his/ her point of view on the topic given. An essay should have an introduction, body and conclusion. A brief explanation of each follows:
Introduction
The introduction should catch the reader’s attention, define the topic and briefly tell the reader what the essay will be addressing.
Body
The body comprises the full content of the essay. The body must be divided into paragraphs, each of which must pursue a specific idea to the end. The writer must address all the ideas he or she wanted to address, keeping to the topic.
Conclusion
The conclusion is the ending, the rounding-off of the presentation. This should tie up all that was presented by the writer, a parting shot that justifies the writer’s point of view. As this is the end, the writer must not bring in new information.
Task 2 – Exemplar 1: Writing: Essay
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
7.1
[Source: Google image]
7.2
[Source: http://www.lifelonghappiness.com]
TOTAL: 50
Task 2 – Writing: Essay
Exemplar 2
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
7.1
[Source: Google image]
7.2
[Source: Google image]
TOTAL: 50
Task 2 – Writing: Essay
Exemplar 3
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
7.1
[Source: Google image]
7.2
[Source: Google image]
TOTAL: 50
How to administer a longer transactional task
Learners should be familiar with all the types of transactional formats as prescribed in the policy documents.
Task 3 – Exemplar 1 : Writing a longer transactional task
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 30
Task 3 – Exemplar 2 : Writing a longer transactional task
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 30
Task 3 – Exemplar 3: Writing a longer transactional task
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
I am writing this letter about dogs being seen in all stores in shopping carts. I understand there are service animals (for blind people) but now people take their animals wherever they please. I put my food items in these carts as well as my 1-year-old granddaughter. I was at my eye doctor yesterday and they had a sign on the door that said NO PETS PLEASE. These signs should be placed in all stores. Mind you, I love animals myself but it is now being blown out of proportion. From: Animals-at-home |
TOTAL: 30
b. Term 2
How to teach and assess reading aloud
Spend some time preparing your learners for this section of the work. It is possible for all learners to achieve good marks in this section as they have the opportunity to prepare themselves ahead of time.
Stress the importance of choosing the passage. They must be at Grade 12 level, but also not too difficult for the learners to manage. They must be passages on topics that capture the learners’ interest, as they will then naturally read better. They must be long enough for the educator to be able to make a fair assessment.
There must be clear evidence of preparation. The learners must have found out the meanings and pronunciation of all the words in the passage.
Encourage learners to enhance the meaning of words through tone, voice projection, pace, eye contact, posture and gestures.
You may wish to add to your conversation assessment by asking the learners’ questions on the passages after the prepared reading has been completed.
Do not force learners who stutter or who experience other speech impediments to perform in the front of the class if they would rather not. Allow them to work alone with you at a pre-arranged time.
Use the rubric in the addendum to assess prepared reading. Discuss the rubric with the learners so that they know how they will be assessed.
Task 5 – Exemplar 1: Oral: Prepared Reading
Date of submission: ____________________________________
Prepare a reading piece for oral assessment. Your reading should be TWO to THREE minutes long. Carefully follow the instructions:
TOTAL: 10
Sample: Reading passages
SAMPLE PASSAGE 1
As I had expected, it turned out to be quite a business. I had to notify the police as well as the health authorities, and answer a lot of tedious questions: How was it I was ignorant of the boy’s presence? If I did not supervise my native quarters, how did I know that that sort of thing didn’t go on all the time? Et cetera, et cetera. And when I flared up and told them that so long as my natives did their work, I didn’t think it my right or concern to poke my nose into their private lives, I got from the coarse, dull-witted police sergeant one of those looks that come not from any thinking process going on in the brain but from that faculty common to all who are possessed by the master-race theory – a look of insanely inane certainty. He grinned at me with a mixture of scorn and delight at my stupidity.
Then I had to explain to Petrus why the health authorities had to take away the body for a post-mortem – and, in fact, what a post-mortem was. When I telephoned the health department some days later to find out the result, I was told that the cause of death was, as we had thought, pneumonia, and that the body had been suitably disposed of. I went out to where Petrus was mixing a mash for the fowls and told him that it was all right, there would be no trouble; his brother had died from that pain in his chest. Petrus put down the paraffin tin and said, ‘When can we go fetch him, baas?’
‘To fetch him?’
‘Will the baas please ask them when we must come?’
I went back inside and called Lerice, all over the house. She came down the stairs from the spare bedrooms, and I said, ‘Now what am I going to do? When I told Petrus, he just asked calmly when they could go and fetch the body. They think they’re going to bury him themselves.’
‘Well, go back and tell him,’ said Lerice. ‘You must tell him. Why didn’t you tell him then?’
When I found Petrus again, he looked up politely. ‘Look, Petrus,’ I said. ‘You can’t go to fetch your brother. They’ve done it already – they’ve buried him, you understand?’
‘Where?’ he said, slowly, dully, as if he thought that perhaps he was getting this wrong.
‘You see, he was a stranger. They knew he wasn’t from here, and they didn’t know he had some of his people here, so they thought they must bury him.’ It was difficult to make a pauper’s grave sound like a privilege.
‘Please, baas, the baas must ask them.’ But he did not mean that he wanted to know the burial-place. He simply ignored the incomprehensible machinery I told him had set to work on his dead brother; he wanted the brother back.
‘But, Petrus,’ I said, ‘how can I? Your brother is buried already. I can’t ask them now.’
‘Oh baas!’ he said. He stood with his bran-smeared hands uncurled at his sides, one corner of his mouth twitching. ‘Goodness, Petrus, they won’t listen to me! They can’t, anyway. I’m sorry, but I can’t do it. You understand?’
He just kept on looking at me, out of his knowledge that white men have everything, can do anything; if they don’t, it is because they won’t.
And then, at dinner, Lerice started. ‘You could at least phone,’ she said.
‘What do you think I am? Am I supposed to bring the dead back to life?’
[Source: Six Feet of the Country, Nadine Gordimer]
SAMPLE PASSAGE 2
“Dave, I know Port St Johns is out of your district, but I’m asking you a favour. That’s what ex-colleagues are for. No, seriously, we haven’t heard from her for two months.”
“I remember Teresa. Wasn’t she a rather wild matric student with a ponytail?”
“She’s grown up since then, Dave. Believe me. She now answers to the name of Tigger. You wouldn’t recognise her.” “Tigger, uh. As in Winnie the Pooh? What did you say she was doing at the Wild Coast?”
“Studying,” Jake answered quickly.
“Well, you’ll have to send me a photograph.”
“I’ll fax you one,” replied Jake. “Don’t you have somebody in the Port St Johns area who could ask a few questions?” “It’s the Wild West up there, Jake, with a lot of ground to cover, but I’ll see what we can do.” “Thanks, Dave, I really appreciate it. When next you’re in Cape Town…”
“I know, I know, you’ll wine and dine me. Promises, promises.”
Embarrassed by having made a request which was completely out of the normal channels of his profession, Jake changed the subject and asked some questions about the cases Dave was working on in East London. It didn’t take long for them to run out of things to say to each other. An old friend living a new life in a different city is hard to keep in touch with, and Jake was relieved when the conversation petered out and he could say goodbye
Jake checked his watch. Sixteen minutes past seven – morning parade had already begun. He hurried downstairs and slid into a vacant seat by the door, nodded apologies to the Colonel and pulled out his notebook. Except for the taxi ambush in Mowbray it had been a quiet night on the Peninsula. BJ reported on the possibility of one of the township gangs attacking an armoured vehicle. He had been warned by an informer, who had chosen to turn in his friends and claim the advertised ten thousand rand reward rather than risk being involved in a bungled attempt to rob a bank security vehicle. BJ was working on it and would keep everyone informed about the progress of the negotiations. Jackson Sondile’s absence had been noted with displeasure by the Colonel, but Jake covered for his colleague, informing the meeting that his partner was working on something related to the Witbooi case. BJ immediately objected angrily to Sondile going solo on something which was now his affair. The Colonel made no comment, merely moving business along. By a quarter
to eight the meeting was over and the men drifted off upstairs for morning sandwiches and coffee. Dan caught Jake’s eye and summoned Jake into his office.
“I got an ugly call from Captain Steenkamp early this morning. Apparently you and Sondile were sniffing around on his crime scene.” The Colonel moved in behind his desk and sat down, tilting his chair back until his head touched the wall behind him.
“We were responding to an all-units. When we got there we found it was a Valentine taxi which had been attacked. It didn’t take much brainpower to make the connection between the ambush and the kid who was murdered the other night. The owner of the taxi, a Mr Ronnie Valentine, had identified the murdered boy as his son. I also spoke to his mother yesterday morning,” said Jake, unsure whether he should sit down or remain standing. Dan Pienaar observed him silently for a moment. With the Colonel you were never sure when it was acceptable to behave informally. Jake remained standing.
“Ja, well, I don’t know how you do it, Jake, but it looks like this case of yours is getting to be bigger than I first expected. Steenkamp is up to his neck in taxi violence. It’s escalating all the time. It seems there’s a full-out war developing between Tetwa Taxis and this Ronnie Valentine character. Late last night there were more shots exchanged in Guguletu. Steenkamp believes it was in retaliation for the Mowbray ambush. No one was killed, but a Tetwa taxi was damaged. Steenkamp is scratching around, but with nothing to show for it, and I think the key to the matter lies with this kid, Jimmy Valentine.” Dan Pienaar swung his chair forward and opened one of the desk drawers. He handed a piece of paper to Jake, who leant over the empty chair on his side of the desk to take it.
[Source: Who Killed Jimmy Valentine?, Michael Williams]
SAMPLE PASSAGE 3
Congratulations. The fact you’re reading this means you’ve taken one giant step closer to surviving till your next birthday. Yes, you, standing there, leafing through these pages. Do not put this book down. I’m dead serious – your life could depend on it.
This is my story, the story of my family, but it could just as easily be your story too. We’re all in this together, trust me on that.
I’ve never done anything like this, so I’m just going to jump in, and you try to keep up.
Okay. I’m Max, I’m fourteen. I live with my family, who are five kids not related to me by blood, but still totally my family. We’re – well, we’re kind of amazing. Not to sound too full of myself, but we’re like nothing you’ve ever seen before.
Basically, we’re pretty cool, nice, smart - but not ‘average’ in any way. The six of us – me, Fang, Iggy, Nudge, the Gasman, and Angel – were made on purpose, by the sickest, most horrible ‘scientists’ you could possibly imagine. They created us as an experiment. An experiment where we ended up only 98% human. That other 2% has had a big impact, let me tell you.
We grew up in a science-lab-slash-prison called the School, in cages, like lab rats. It’s pretty amazing we can think or speak at all. But we can – and so much more.
There was one other School experiment that made it past infancy. Part human, part wolf – all predator: they’re called Erasers. They’re tough, smart, and hard to control. They look human, but when they want to, they are capable of morphing into wolf men, complete with fur, fangs, and claws. The School uses them as guards, police - and executioners.
To them, we’re six moving targets – prey smart enough to be a fun challenge. Basically, they want to rip our throats out. And make sure the world never finds out about us.
But I’m not lying down just yet. I’m telling you, right?
This story could be about you – or your children. If not today, then soon. So please, please, take this seriously. I’m risking everything that matters by telling you – but you need to know.
Keep reading – don’t let anyone stop you.
– Max. And my family: Fang, Iggy, Nudge, the Gasman, and Angel.
Welcome to our nightmare.
[Source: The Prologue – Maximum Ride The Angel Experiment, James Patterson]
SAMPLE PASSAGE 4
‘It is clear that it is the work of a madman.’ Jon de Jong, tall, lean, grey, ascetic and the general manager of Schiphol airport, looked and sounded very gloomy indeed and, in the circumstances, he had every justification in looking and sounding that way.
‘Insanity. A man has to be deranged, unhinged, to perform a wanton, mindless, pointless and purposeless task like this.’ Like the monkish professor he so closely resembled, De Jong tended to be precise to the point of pedantry and, as now, had a weakness for pompous tautology.
‘A lunatic.’
‘One sees your point of view,’ De Graaf said. Colonel van de Graaf, a remarkably broad man of medium height with a deeply trenched, tanned face, had about him an imperturbability and an unmistakable cast of authority that accorded well with the Chief of Police of a nation’s capital city. ‘I can understand and agree with it but only to a certain extent. I appreciate how you feel, my friend. Your beloved airport, one of the best in Europe -’
‘Amsterdam airport is the best in Europe.’ De Jong spoke as if by rote, his thoughts elsewhere. ‘Was.’
‘And will be again. The criminal responsible for this is, it is certain, not a man of a normal cast of mind. But that does not mean that he is instantly certifiable. Maybe he doesn’t like you, has a grudge against you. Maybe he’s an ex-employee fired by one of your departmental managers for what the manager regarded as a perfectly valid reason but a reason with which the disgruntled employee didn’t agree. Maybe he’s a citizen living close by, on the outskirts of Amsterdam, say, or between here and Aalsmeer, who finds the decibel level from the aircraft intolerably high. Maybe he’s a dedicated environmentalist who objects, in what must be a very violent fashion, to jet engines polluting the atmosphere, which they undoubtedly do. Our country, as you are well aware, has more than its fair share of dedicated environmentalists. Maybe he doesn’t like our Government’s policies.’ De Graaf ran a hand through his thick, iron-grey hair. ‘Maybe anything. But he could be as sane as either of us.
‘Maybe you’d better have another look, Colonel,’ De Jong said. His hands were clenching and unclenching and he was shivering violently. Both of those were involuntary but for different reasons. The former accurately reflected an intense frustration and anger; the latter was due to the fact that, when an ice-cold wind blows east-north-east off the Ijsselmeer, and before that from Siberia, the roof of the main concourse of Schiphol airport was no place to be. ‘As sane as you or I? Would you or I have been responsible for this – this atrocity? Look, Colonel, just look.
De Graaf looked. Had he been the airport manager, he reflected, it would hardly have been a sight to gladden his heart. Schiphol airport had just disappeared, its place taken by a wave-rippled lake that stretched almost as far as the eyes could see.
[Source: Floodgate, Alistair Maclean]
How to teach and assess a prepared speech
Speeches should be delivered in the context of real-life experience. This means selecting content which is relevant to his or her life or things that they can relate to or are within their frame of reference.
The learner should:
Encourage learners to think about what they enjoy and choose a suitable topic. Insist on planning. Possibly begin the planning in class after the discussion. Stress how a good introduction can make or break a speech. Allow the class to brainstorm some possibilities. Ensure that the conclusion is planned too. Discourage the endings that just “happen”. Remind the learners that the conclusion is the last thing that the assessor hears before deciding on the mark.
Once the planning is complete, and the speech is long enough, ensure that all learners transfer their speeches onto cards (cardboard can be cut into little rectangles for this.) You must tell them how long you want this speech to be. Motivate your learners to practise their delivery. Speak to them about eye contact, pace, pitch and the use of pause. Remind them how important it is to bear in mind that they are communicating with an audience and to consider their impact on that audience!
The prepared speech rubric can be found in the addendum. Before the learners begin their preparation it is necessary to spend some time going through the rubric with them so that they know how they are to be assessed.
Include as many opportunities as you can in your planning for learners to practise their speaking skills in general.
Task 6 – Oral: Prepared Speech
Date of presentation: _________________________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
Choose ONE of the following topics, or select your own:
TOTAL: 20
c. Term 3
How to administer a shorter transactional task
Learners should be familiar with all the transactional formats as prescribed in the policy documents:
Task 9 – Exemplar 1 : Writing a shorter transactional task
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 20
Task 9 – Exemplar 2 : Writing a shorter transactional task
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 20
Attachment:
Egypt Basic Facts: Egypt, one of the world’s oldest continuous civilizations, still draws visitors and businessmen by the plane-load. Old monuments, the Red Sea coast, Nile River cruises and Africa’s largest city, Cairo, are among its many attractions.
Location: Egypt is located in North Africa bordering the Mediterranean Sea. Libya is on the west and the Gaza Strip and the Red Sea make up the eastern border; see map.
Area: Egypt covers just over 1 million square kilometres, about the same size as France and Germany combined.
Capital City: Cairo
Population: Around 78 million people live in Egypt
Language: Arabic (official), English and French are widely understood by educated classes.
Religion: Muslim (mostly Sunni) 94%, Coptic Christian and other 6%.
Climate: It’s hot and sunny for most of the year in Egypt. Winters (November to February) are generally mild.
When to Go: October–April when it’s a bit cooler, but the Red Sea coast is a year-round destination.
Currency: Egyptian pound.
Egypt’s Main Attractions:
Travel to Egypt
Egypt’s International Airport: Egypt’s main airport is Cairo International Airport, 20 kilometres northeast of Cairo’s city centre.
Egypt’s Embassies/Visas: A valid passport and a tourist visa are required for most nationalities. Tourist visas are available at Egyptian embassies and consulates around the world.
Egypt’s Tourist Information Office: Miser Travel Tower, Abbassia Square, Cairo, Egypt. Tel: 285-4509 or 284-1970; E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; Website: http://www.egypt.travel.
5. Marking guidelines
Task 1 – Exemplar 1: Listening Comprehension
TOTAL: 10
Task 1 – Exemplar 2: Listening Comprehension
Accept any other reasonable answer. (2)
Level 5
TOTAL: 10
Task 2: Essay
GENERAL MARKING GUIDELINES AND INSTRUCTIONS
Sample: Essay
Response to visual stimuli Exemplar 2 No. 7.2
My Joy
Silence consumes me. The snow melts where I finally allow the hot teardrops to fall. All I can do is stand in the cold while my limbs grow numb, echoing the numbness of my soul.
My mind flicks through images of the past. I have been the proudest father from the moment the nurse placed you in my hands. You were perfectly delicate, curled up in the palm of my oversized hand. In that moment, in the centre of pain and loss, my heart surged with joy and you will forever be my baby girl, I named you Joy.
You grew up to encompass beauty and grace, with long locks of hair, and eyes the colour of chestnut that shone with life. Even the sickness that spread slowly through your blood could not take away your glow or beauty. Every time I glanced your way, I had to look twice, because you grew so fast and every day you resembled your mother more and more.
You radiated joy, as if you couldn’t contain it. If was on days like this, you would wake up early, haul me out of bed and in our pyjamas we would dance in the garden. As you danced, it overflowed into a song and the entire world grew still in wonder when you sang. A sound sweeter than the robin or any instrument or chime that created warmth to drive out the biting cold. Without your whimsical laughter or sweet voice, the silence is deafening.
Throughout all the dark, threatening storms of pain you were my sunshine. Every trip to the hospital, every operation, every chemotherapy session, you were the strong one. You held my hand through it all; we were Daddy and Joy against the world. When it all became too much and the storm threatened to overwhelm me, you rescued me with a song. The sound of Amazing Grace echoed off the walls of my heart and gave me strength.
I knew today would be the day I would have to say good-bye, so did you. Your joy gave me peace and hope that everything would be okay. As the first snowflake hit the ground, the light in your eyes went out. Every moment of the last five years you filled me with joy and now you are taken away from me as if you were only borrowed from a place better than this one. You were the last piece of your mother, I could hold on to as she too was taken as you arrived.
Goodbye, my baby girl, my Joy. I promise to live the way you taught me: to see all things as a miracle and to find beauty and wonder in the ordinary. Forever you will live in my heart. Forever you are my Joy.
Task 3: Longer transactional tasks
GENERAL MARKING GUIDELINES
Task 3 – Exemplar 1: Marking Guidelines
TOPICS
TOTAL: 30
Task 3 – Exemplar 2: Marking Guidelines
TOPICS
TOTAL: 30
Task 3 – Exemplar 3: Marking Guidelines
TOPICS
TOTAL: 30
Sample: Longer transactional task
Restaurant review:
Last week I had the misfortune of dining at the ‘Roots’ traditional restaurant. No, this is not one of those ‘health food’ restaurants where they try to pass off bits of their lawn as food, though I think I would have been better off at one of those, chewing on some grass for an hour, than what I experienced. This is one of those ‘we are an African country, so let me exploit that and make only traditional African food’ restaurants.
Let me give you a general outline of the experience. The Chef – here is a person who has never heard the word ‘presentation’, ever, if you can imagine I was served a stew which was just slopped into a bowl, droplets of gravy on the edges of the bowl. The waiter – service, what service? I found myself waiting a whole hour for my food. When the food eventually arrived, horrible presentation and all, he simply disappeared. The manager – shining in her absence. Not once did she come to the tables to see how the patrons felt about the food, just as well for her sake. There was a line of people waiting at the door, all because of her double bookings.
The bottom line is ‘Roots Traditional restaurant’ is a real disaster. I can only manage a one out of ten stars – only because the food was at least lukewarm.
Task 9 – Shorter transactional tasks
GENERAL MARKING GUIDELINES
Task 9 – Exemplar 1: Shorter transactional task
TOPICS
TOTAL: 20
Task 9 – Exemplar 2: Shorter transactional task
TOPICS
TOTAL: 20
Sample: Shorter transactional task
Diary entry:
31 October 2014
Dear Diary
Today I wished a close friend ‘Happy Birthday’ on Facebook. What saddens me is that if I hadn’t posted her a message on Facebook, I would be seen as a bad friend.
I am not expected to call or even wish her well in person, as long as I publicly display my presence in her life over a social media network. I feel despicable engaging in such
shallowness.
Social media has become a vessel for falsehood. Maybe it is merely exposing humans for who we really are – vacuous beings with no depth. Yet I crave the opposite. I long
for someone who also appreciates the beauty and intricacies of life.
Diary, how do I find someone real when I myself am falling into the shallow waters of materialism?
(No greeting/ending or name to be included.)
5. Rubrics
APPENDIX B: ASSESMENT RUBRICS FOR FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE.
SECTION A: RUBRIC FOR ASSESSING AN ESSAY - FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE (60 MARKS)
Code 7: Outstanding 80-100% | Code 6: Meritorious 70-79% | Code 5: Substantial 60-69% | Code 4: Adequate 50-59% | Code 3: Moderate 40-49% | Code 2: Elementary 30-39% | Code 1: Not -achieved 0-29% | |
CONTENT AND PLANNING 32 MARKS | 26-32
| 22½- 25½
| 19½-22
| 16-19
| 13-15½
| 10-12½
| 0-9½
|
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING 12 MARKS | 10-12
| 8½-9½
| 7½-8
| 6-7
| 5-5½
| 4-4½
| 0-3½
|
STRUCTURE 6 MARKS | 5-6
| 4½
| 4
| 3-3½
| 2½
| 2
| 0-1½
|
CONTENT AND PLANNING | 32 MARKS | TOTAL | |
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING | 12 MARKS | ||
STRUCTURE | 6 MARKS |
SECTION B: RUBRIC FOR ASSESING LONGER TRANSACTIONAL TEXTS - FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE (30 MARKS)
Code 7: Outstanding 80-100% | Code 6: Meritorious 70-79% | Code 5: Substantial 60-69% | Code 4: Adequate 50-59% | Code 3: Moderate 40-49% | Code 2: Elementary 30-39% | Code 1: Not -achieved 0-29% | |
CONTENT AND PLANNING 20 MARKS | 16-20
| 14-15½
| 12-13½
| 10-11½
| 8-9½
| 6-7½
| 0-5½
|
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING 10 MARKS | 8-10
| 7-7½
| 6-6½
| 5-5½
| 4-4½
| 3-3½
| 0-2½
|
CONTENT AND PLANNING | 20 MARKS | TOTAL: | |
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING | 10 MARKS |
ENGLISH FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
LEARNER'S GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENT | |||
CONTENT | PAGE | ||
1 | Introduction | 3 | |
2 | Aims and objectives of school-based assessment | 4 | |
3 | Programme of assessment | 5 | |
4 | Assessment tasks | 6 | |
a | Term 1 | ||
Task 1 | 6 | ||
Task 2 – Exemplar 1 | 8 | ||
Task 2 – Exemplar 2 | 10 | ||
Task 2 – Exemplar 3 | 12 | ||
Task 3 – Exemplar 1 | 14 | ||
Task 3 – Exemplar 2 | 16 | ||
Task 3 – Exemplar 3 | 17 | ||
b | Term 2 | ||
Task 5 | 19 | ||
Sample: Reading passages | 20 | ||
Task 6 | 23 | ||
c | Term 3 | ||
Task 9 – Exemplar 1 | 25 | ||
Task 9 – Exemplar 2 | 27 | ||
5 | Rubrics | 33 | |
Essay | 33 | ||
Longer Transactional Task | 34 | ||
Shorter Transactional Task | 35 | ||
Prepared Reading | 36 | ||
Prepared Speech | 38 |
1. Introduction
School-based assessment in English First Additional Language is an integral part of your preparation for the final examinations. Your school-based assessment mark is formally recorded by your teacher for progression and certification purposes. It is important that you understand that school-based assessment does impact on your final marks at the end of Grade 12.
These formal assessment tasks provide your teacher with a systematic way of evaluating how well you are progressing and it includes various assessment tasks such as tests, examinations, writing tasks, oral presentations and listening comprehension.
School-based assessment is compulsory for all students. If you do not comply with the requirements specified according to the policy, you may not be eligible to enter for the subject in the final examination.
Formal assessment tasks form part of a year-long formal programme of assessment. These tasks should not be taken lightly and you should submit your best possible efforts for final assessment.
2. Aims and objectives of school-based assessment
Assessment, primarily, is aimed at improving your learning and achievement. Through assessment you get information about what you should learn.
Assessment provides complete information about your achievement. It provides information on how much you know and what you can do with what you know. Furthermore, assessment is used to evaluate your knowledge and skills, as well as your values, attitudes and habits that have an influence on your performance and achievements at school and out of it.
Assessment complements the teaching process. There is a clear relationship between the goals and the content of instruction and those of assessment (between what is learnt and taught and what is assessed).
You have an active role to play in the assessment process, thus enhancing your progress. The different methods and types of assessment, which take into consideration various learning styles and personality types, ensure that your potential to do well is laid out for you.
Assessment is a continuous process. It involves activities of monitoring and evaluation of your performance and achievements during the entire school year.
You should be familiar with what you are expected to learn, how and when you are going to be assessed.
3. Programme of assessment
Term 1 | Task 1 | Task 2 | Task 3 | Task 4 | ||
Oral: | Writing: | *Writing: | **Test 1: | |||
Total: | 10 | 50 | 30 | 40 | ||
Term 2 | Task 5 | Task 6 | Task 7 | Task 8 | ||
Oral: | Oral: | Literature: | ****Mid-year examinations | |||
Total: | 20 | 20 | 35 | 250 | ||
Term 3 | Task 9 | Task 10 | ||||
***Writing: Shorter transactional writing | ****Preparatory examinations | |||||
Total: | 20 | 250 |
* Friendly/Formal letters (request/complaint/application/business)/formal and informal letters to the press/ curriculum vitae and covering letter/obituary/agenda and minutes of meeting/report/review/newspaper article/magazine article/dialogue/ interview.
** Test 1 should be set out of 40 marks or, if more, should be converted to 40 marks. While the Comprehension, Summary, Language structures and conventions combination is suggested, teachers are urged to design a combination of aspects that fits the character (test programme, time allocation, etc.) of the school. A test in the Programme of Assessment should not be made up of several smaller tests. Each test should cover a substantial amount of content, should be set for 45–60 minutes, and should reflect the different cognitive levels as set out for exam papers.
*** Advertisements/Diary entries/Postcards/Invitation cards/Filling in forms/ Directions/Instructions/Flyers/Posters/ emails.
**** Mid-year and Trial examinations: In Grade 12 one of the tasks in Term 2 and/or Term 3 (Tasks 8 and/or 10) must be an internal examination. In instances where only one of the two internal examinations is written in Grade 12, the other examination could be replaced by a test. A recommendation has been made that the written test, if this option is chosen, should be set out of 80 marks. This test should take the format of the Language structure and conventions, as set in the examinations.
4. Assessment tasks
This section outlines the various tasks that are expected you. You are also given guidance on how to approach the tasks.
a. Term 1
Task 1 – Oral: Listening comprehension
You will listen to an extract, for the first time, when your teacher reads it to you on the day of the assessment. You will not be given a chance to read the passage on your own. You will have access to the questions once the teacher has read the passage for the first time. It is thus important for you to listen attentively when the teacher reads the passage.
You may want to take note of the information that follows:
Many people think of listening as a skill that requires no thought or effort. The listening comprehension skill is therefore often overlooked in teaching and learning. However, what many people do not realise is that listening is as much a fundamental skill in language learning as speaking, reading and writing.
Better listening helps you to focus on specific vocabulary acquisition, grammar practice and listening for different purposes. You can consciously focus on remembering the vocabulary used in each activity when you listen and understand the purpose of the activity.
How your teacher will administer the formal listening comprehension tasks:
Task 2 – Writing: Essay
In order to write well, you need knowledge of different text types, a wide vocabulary, a good control of English grammar, spelling and punctuation, and a critical understanding of the potential effects of your writing.
An essay is an extended piece of writing, in which a writer expresses his/ her point of view on the topic given. An essay should have an introduction, body and conclusion. A brief explanation of each follows:
Introduction
The introduction should catch the reader’s attention, define the topic and briefly tell the reader what the essay will be addressing.
Body
The body comprises the full content of the essay. The body must be divided into paragraphs, each of which must pursue a specific idea to the end. The writer must address all the ideas he or she wanted to address, keeping to the topic.
Conclusion
The conclusion is the ending, the rounding-off of the presentation. This should tie up all that was presented by the writer, a parting shot that justifies the writer’s point of view. As this is the end, the writer must not bring in new information.
Task 2 – Writing: Essay Total out of 50
Exemplar 1
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
7.1
[Source: Google image]
7.2
[Source: http://www.lifelonghappiness.com]
TOTAL: 50
Task 2 – Writing: Essay
Exemplar 2
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
7.1
[Source: Google image]
7.2
[Source: Google image]
TOTAL: 50
Task 2 – Writing: Essay
Exemplar 3
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
7.1
[Source: Google image]
7.2
[Source: Google image]
TOTAL: 50
Task 3 – Writing: Transactional Writing
Transactional writing texts are either a response or an initiation of a response. As implied, these are ‘transaction texts’ - a friendly letter of appreciation will possible yield a response, as much as a speech will get the audience won over or yelling in disagreement. Transactional texts are divided into Longer and Shorter texts.
Exemplar 1
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date of submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 30
Task 3 – Writing: Transactional Writing
Exemplar 2
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 30
Task 3 – Writing: Transactional Writing
Exemplar 3
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
I am writing this letter about dogs being seen in all stores in shopping carts. I understand there are service animals (for blind people) but now people take their animals wherever they please. I put my food items in these carts as well as my 1-year-old granddaughter. I was at my eye doctor yesterday and they had a sign on the door that said NO PETS PLEASE. These signs should be placed in all stores. Mind you, I love animals myself but it is now being blown out of proportion. From: Animals-at-home |
TOTAL: 30
b. Term 2
Task 5 – Oral: Prepared Reading
Date of presentation: ____________________________________
Prepare a reading piece for oral assessment. Your reading should be TWO to THREE minutes long. Carefully follow the instructions:
TOTAL: 10
Sample: Reading passages
SAMPLE PASSAGE 1
As I had expected, it turned out to be quite a business. I had to notify the police as well as the health authorities, and answer a lot of tedious questions: How was it I was ignorant of the boy’s presence? If I did not supervise my native quarters, how did I know that that sort of thing didn’t go on all the time? Et cetera, et cetera. And when I flared up and told them that so long as my natives did their work, I didn’t think it my right or concern to poke my nose into their private lives, I got from the coarse, dull-witted police sergeant one of those looks that come not from any thinking process going on in the brain but from that faculty common to all who are possessed by the master-race theory – a look of insanely inane certainty. He grinned at me with a mixture of scorn and delight at my stupidity.
Then I had to explain to Petrus why the health authorities had to take away the body for a post-mortem – and, in fact, what a post-mortem was. When I telephoned the health department some days later to find out the result, I was told that the cause of death was, as we had thought, pneumonia, and that the body had been suitably disposed of. I went out to where Petrus was mixing a mash for the fowls and told him that it was all right, there would be no trouble; his brother had died from that pain in his chest. Petrus put down the paraffin tin and said, ‘When can we go fetch him, baas?’
‘To fetch him?’
‘Will the baas please ask them when we must come?’
I went back inside and called Lerice, all over the house. She came down the stairs from the spare bedrooms, and I said, ‘Now what am I going to do? When I told Petrus, he just asked calmly when they could go and fetch the body. They think they’re going to bury him themselves.’
‘Well, go back and tell him,’ said Lerice. ‘You must tell him. Why didn’t you tell him then?’
When I found Petrus again, he looked up politely. ‘Look, Petrus,’ I said. ‘You can’t go to fetch your brother. They’ve done it already – they’ve buried him, you understand?’
‘Where?’ he said, slowly, dully, as if he thought that perhaps he was getting this wrong.
‘You see, he was a stranger. They knew he wasn’t from here, and they didn’t know he had some of his people here, so they thought they must bury him.’ It was difficult to make a pauper’s grave sound like a privilege.
‘Please, baas, the baas must ask them.’ But he did not mean that he wanted to know the burial-place. He simply ignored the incomprehensible machinery I told him had set to work on his dead brother; he wanted the brother back.
‘But, Petrus,’ I said, ‘how can I? Your brother is buried already. I can’t ask them now.’
‘Oh baas!’ he said. He stood with his bran-smeared hands uncurled at his sides, one corner of his mouth twitching. ‘Goodness, Petrus, they won’t listen to me! They can’t, anyway. I’m sorry, but I can’t do it. You understand?’
He just kept on looking at me, out of his knowledge that white men have everything, can do anything; if they don’t, it is because they won’t.
And then, at dinner, Lerice started. ‘You could at least phone,’ she said.
‘What do you think I am? Am I supposed to bring the dead back to life?’
[Source: Six Feet of the Country, Nadine Gordimer]
SAMPLE PASSAGE 2
“Dave, I know Port St Johns is out of your district, but I’m asking you a favour. That’s what ex-colleagues are for. No, seriously, we haven’t heard from her for two months.”
“I remember Teresa. Wasn’t she a rather wild matric student with a ponytail?”
“She’s grown up since then, Dave. Believe me. She now answers to the name of Tigger. You wouldn’t recognise her.” “Tigger, uh. As in Winnie the Pooh? What did you say she was doing at the Wild Coast?”
“Studying,” Jake answered quickly.
“Well, you’ll have to send me a photograph.”
“I’ll fax you one,” replied Jake. “Don’t you have somebody in the Port St Johns area who could ask a few questions?” “It’s the Wild West up there, Jake, with a lot of ground to cover, but I’ll see what we can do.” “Thanks, Dave, I really appreciate it. When next you’re in Cape Town…”
“I know, I know, you’ll wine and dine me. Promises, promises.”
Embarrassed by having made a request which was completely out of the normal channels of his profession, Jake changed the subject and asked some questions about the cases Dave was working on in East London. It didn’t take long for them to run out of things to say to each other. An old friend living a new life in a different city is hard to keep in touch with, and Jake was relieved when the conversation petered out and he could say goodbye
Jake checked his watch. Sixteen minutes past seven – morning parade had already begun. He hurried downstairs and slid into a vacant seat by the door, nodded apologies to the Colonel and pulled out his notebook. Except for the taxi ambush in Mowbray it had been a quiet night on the Peninsula. BJ reported on the possibility of one of the township gangs attacking an armoured vehicle. He had been warned by an informer, who had chosen to turn in his friends and claim the advertised ten thousand rand reward rather than risk being involved in a bungled attempt to rob a bank security vehicle. BJ was working on it and would keep everyone informed about the progress of the negotiations. Jackson Sondile’s absence had been noted with displeasure by the Colonel, but Jake covered for his colleague, informing the meeting that his partner was working on something related to the Witbooi case. BJ immediately objected angrily to Sondile going solo on something which was now his affair. The Colonel made no comment, merely moving business along. By a quarter
to eight the meeting was over and the men drifted off upstairs for morning sandwiches and coffee. Dan caught Jake’s eye and summoned Jake into his office.
“I got an ugly call from Captain Steenkamp early this morning. Apparently you and Sondile were sniffing around on his crime scene.” The Colonel moved in behind his desk and sat down, tilting his chair back until his head touched the wall behind him.
“We were responding to an all-units. When we got there we found it was a Valentine taxi which had been attacked. It didn’t take much brainpower to make the connection between the ambush and the kid who was murdered the other night. The owner of the taxi, a Mr Ronnie Valentine, had identified the murdered boy as his son. I also spoke to his mother yesterday morning,” said Jake, unsure whether he should sit down or remain standing. Dan Pienaar observed him silently for a moment. With the Colonel you were never sure when it was acceptable to behave informally. Jake remained standing.
“Ja, well, I don’t know how you do it, Jake, but it looks like this case of yours is getting to be bigger than I first expected. Steenkamp is up to his neck in taxi violence. It’s escalating all the time. It seems there’s a full-out war developing between Tetwa Taxis and this Ronnie Valentine character. Late last night there were more shots exchanged in Guguletu. Steenkamp believes it was in retaliation for the Mowbray ambush. No one was killed, but a Tetwa taxi was damaged. Steenkamp is scratching around, but with nothing to show for it, and I think the key to the matter lies with this kid, Jimmy Valentine.” Dan Pienaar swung his chair forward and opened one of the desk drawers. He handed a piece of paper to Jake, who leant over the empty chair on his side of the desk to take it.
[Source: Who Killed Jimmy Valentine?, Michael Williams]
SAMPLE PASSAGE 3
Congratulations. The fact you’re reading this means you’ve taken one giant step closer to surviving till your next birthday. Yes, you, standing there, leafing through these pages. Do not put this book down. I’m dead serious – your life could depend on it.
This is my story, the story of my family, but it could just as easily be your story too. We’re all in this together, trust me on that.
I’ve never done anything like this, so I’m just going to jump in, and you try to keep up.
Okay. I’m Max, I’m fourteen. I live with my family, who are five kids not related to me by blood, but still totally my family. We’re – well, we’re kind of amazing. Not to sound too full of myself, but we’re like nothing you’ve ever seen before.
Basically, we’re pretty cool, nice, smart - but not ‘average’ in any way. The six of us – me, Fang, Iggy, Nudge, the Gasman, and Angel – were made on purpose, by the sickest, most horrible ‘scientists’ you could possibly imagine. They created us as an experiment. An experiment where we ended up only 98% human. That other 2% has had a big impact, let me tell you.
We grew up in a science-lab-slash-prison called the School, in cages, like lab rats. It’s pretty amazing we can think or speak at all. But we can – and so much more.
There was one other School experiment that made it past infancy. Part human, part wolf – all predator: they’re called Erasers. They’re tough, smart, and hard to control. They look human, but when they want to, they are capable of morphing into wolf men, complete with fur, fangs, and claws. The School uses them as guards, police - and executioners.
To them, we’re six moving targets – prey smart enough to be a fun challenge. Basically, they want to rip our throats out. And make sure the world never finds out about us.
But I’m not lying down just yet. I’m telling you, right?
This story could be about you – or your children. If not today, then soon. So please, please, take this seriously. I’m risking everything that matters by telling you – but you need to know.
Keep reading – don’t let anyone stop you.
– Max. And my family: Fang, Iggy, Nudge, the Gasman, and Angel.
Welcome to our nightmare.
[Source: The Prologue – Maximum Ride The Angel Experiment, James Patterson]
SAMPLE PASSAGE 4
‘It is clear that it is the work of a madman.’ Jon de Jong, tall, lean, grey, ascetic and the general manager of Schiphol airport, looked and sounded very gloomy indeed and, in the circumstances, he had every justification in looking and sounding that way.
‘Insanity. A man has to be deranged, unhinged, to perform a wanton, mindless, pointless and purposeless task like this.’ Like the monkish professor he so closely resembled, De Jong tended to be precise to the point of pedantry and, as now, had a weakness for pompous tautology.
‘A lunatic.’
‘One sees your point of view,’ De Graaf said. Colonel van de Graaf, a remarkably broad man of medium height with a deeply trenched, tanned face, had about him an imperturbability and an unmistakable cast of authority that accorded well with the Chief of Police of a nation’s capital city. ‘I can understand and agree with it but only to a certain extent. I appreciate how you feel, my friend. Your beloved airport, one of the best in Europe -’
‘Amsterdam airport is the best in Europe.’ De Jong spoke as if by rote, his thoughts elsewhere. ‘Was.’
‘And will be again. The criminal responsible for this is, it is certain, not a man of a normal cast of mind. But that does not mean that he is instantly certifiable. Maybe he doesn’t like you, has a grudge against you. Maybe he’s an ex-employee fired by one of your departmental managers for what the manager regarded as a perfectly valid reason but a reason with which the disgruntled employee didn’t agree. Maybe he’s a citizen living close by, on the outskirts of Amsterdam, say, or between here and Aalsmeer, who finds the decibel level from the aircraft intolerably high. Maybe he’s a dedicated environmentalist who objects, in what must be a very violent fashion, to jet engines polluting the atmosphere, which they undoubtedly do. Our country, as you are well aware, has more than its fair share of dedicated environmentalists. Maybe he doesn’t like our Government’s policies.’ De Graaf ran a hand through his thick, iron-grey hair. ‘Maybe anything. But he could be as sane as either of us.
‘Maybe you’d better have another look, Colonel,’ De Jong said. His hands were clenching and unclenching and he was shivering violently. Both of those were involuntary but for different reasons. The former accurately reflected an intense frustration and anger; the latter was due to the fact that, when an ice-cold wind blows east-north-east off the Ijsselmeer, and before that from Siberia, the roof of the main concourse of Schiphol airport was no place to be. ‘As sane as you or I? Would you or I have been responsible for this – this atrocity? Look, Colonel, just look.
De Graaf looked. Had he been the airport manager, he reflected, it would hardly have been a sight to gladden his heart. Schiphol airport had just disappeared, its place taken by a wave-rippled lake that stretched almost as far as the eyes could see.
[Source: Floodgate, Alistair Maclean]
Task 6 – Oral: Prepared Speech
Date of presentation: _________________________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
Choose ONE of the following topics, or select your own:
TOTAL: 20
c. Term 3
Task 9 – Writing: Shorter Transactional Writing
Exemplar 1
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 20
Task 9 – Writing: Shorter Transactional Writing
Exemplar 2
Name: ____________________________ Grade: ______________
Date for submission: ____________________
INSTRUCTIONS
TOPICS
TOTAL: 20
Attachment:
Egypt Basic Facts: Egypt, one of the world’s oldest continuous civilizations, still draws visitors and businessmen by the plane-load. Old monuments, the Red Sea coast, Nile River cruises and Africa’s largest city, Cairo, are among its many attractions.
Location: Egypt is located in North Africa bordering the Mediterranean Sea. Libya is on the west and the Gaza Strip and the Red Sea make up the eastern border; see map.
Area: Egypt covers just over 1 million square kilometres, about the same size as France and Germany combined.
Capital City: Cairo
Population: Around 78 million people live in Egypt
Language: Arabic (official), English and French are widely understood by educated classes.
Religion: Muslim (mostly Sunni) 94%, Coptic Christian and other 6%.
Climate: It’s hot and sunny for most of the year in Egypt. Winters (November to February) are generally mild.
When to Go: October–April when it’s a bit cooler, but the Red Sea coast is a year-round destination.
Currency: Egyptian pound.
Egypt’s Main Attractions:
Travel to Egypt
Egypt’s International Airport: Egypt’s main airport is Cairo International Airport, 20 kilometres northeast of Cairo’s city centre.
Egypt’s Embassies/Visas: A valid passport and a tourist visa are required for most nationalities. Tourist visas are available at Egyptian embassies and consulates around the world.
Egypt’s Tourist Information Office: Miser Travel Tower, Abbassia Square, Cairo, Egypt. Tel: 285-4509 or 284-1970; E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; Website: http://www.egypt.travel.
Sample: Shorter transactional task
Diary entry:
31 October 2014
Dear Diary
Today I wished a close friend ‘Happy Birthday’ on Facebook. What saddens me is that if I hadn’t posted her a message on Facebook, I would be seen as a bad friend.
I am not expected to call or even wish her well in person, as long as I publicly display my presence in her life over a social media network. I feel despicable engaging in such
shallowness.
Social media has become a vessel for falsehood. Maybe it is merely exposing humans for who we really are – vacuous beings with no depth. Yet I crave the opposite. I long
for someone who also appreciates the beauty and intricacies of life.
Diary, how do I find someone real when I myself am falling into the shallow waters of materialism?
(No greeting/ending or name to be included.)
5. Rubrics
SECTION A: RUBRIC FOR ASSESSING AN ESSAY - FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE (60 MARKS)
Code 7: Outstanding 80-100% | Code 6: Meritorious 70-79% | Code 5: Substantial 60-69% | Code 4: Adequate 50-59% | Code 3: Moderate 40-49% | Code 2: Elementary 30-39% | Code 1: Not -achieved 0-29% | |
CONTENT AND PLANNING 32 MARKS | 26-32
| 22½- 25½
| 19½-22
| 16-19
| 13-15½
| 10-12½
| 0-9½
|
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING 12 MARKS | 10-12
| 8½-9½
| 7½-8
| 6-7
| 5-5½
| 4-4½
| 0-3½
|
STRUCTURE 6 MARKS | 5-6
| 4½
| 4
| 3-3½
| 2½
| 2
| 0-1½
|
CONTENT AND PLANNING | 32 MARKS | TOTAL | |
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING | 12 MARKS | ||
STRUCTURE | 6 MARKS |
SECTION B: RUBRIC FOR ASSESING LONGER TRANSACTIONAL TEXTS - FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE (30 MARKS)
Code 7: Outstanding 80-100% | Code 6: Meritorious 70-79% | Code 5: Substantial 60-69% | Code 4: Adequate 50-59% | Code 3: Moderate 40-49% | Code 2: Elementary 30-39% | Code 1: Not -achieved 0-29% | |
CONTENT AND PLANNING 20 MARKS | 16-20
| 14-15½
| 12-13½
| 10-11½
| 8-9½
| 6-7½
| 0-5½
|
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING 10 MARKS | 8-10
| 7-7½
| 6-6½
| 5-5½
| 4-4½
| 3-3½
| 0-2½
|
CONTENT AND PLANNING | 20 MARKS | TOTAL: | |
LANGUAGE, STYLE AND EDITING | 10 MARKS |
GRADE 12 MATHEMATICS
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
LEARNER'S GUIDE
Table of Contents | ||
Contents | Page | |
1 | ASSIGNMENT Sequences and series | 4 |
2 | INVESTIGATION 1 | 6 |
3 | INVESTIGATION 2 | 12 |
4 | PROJECT A practical application of differential calculus | 14 |
INTRODUCTION
One of the aims of our curriculum is to ensure that learners acquire and apply knowledge and skills in ways that are meaningful to their own lives. In this regard, and where applicable, the assessment tasks in this document seek to test practical knowledge in context.
The table below shows the school-based assessment requirements for the year. Please note that although the project/ investigation is indicated in the first term, it may be scheduled in the second term.
SCHOOL-BASED ASSESSMENT | ||
TASK | WEIGHT (%) | |
Term 1 | Test | 10 |
Term 2 | Test | 10 |
Term 3 | Test | 10 |
School-based assessment as a % of the promotion mark | 25% |
1. ASSIGNMENT: SEQUENCES AND SERIES TOTAL: 60 INSTRUCTIONS
QUESTION 1
Lucy is arranging 1-cent and 5-cent coins in rows. The pattern of the coins in each row is shown below.
1.1 Calculate the total number of coins in the 40th row. (3)
1.2 Calculate the total value of the coins in the 40th row. (4)
1.3 Which row has coins with a total value of 337 cents? (6)
1.4 Show that the total value of the coins in the first 40 rows is 4 800 cents. (6)
[19]
QUESTION 2
The sum of the first n terms of a sequence is given by: Sn = n(23 – 3n)
2.1 Write down the first THREE terms of the sequence. (5)
2.2 Calculate the 15th term of the sequence. (3)
[8]
QUESTION 3
The sum of the second and third terms of a geometric sequence is 280, and the sum of the fifth and the sixth terms is 4 375. Determine:
3.1 The common ratio AND the first term (6)
3.2 The sum of the first 10 terms (2)
[8]
QUESTION 4
Determine the value of k if: [6]
QUESTION 5
Given the series: 2(5)5 + 2(5)4 + 2(5)3 + ...
Show that this series converges.
[2]
QUESTION 6
If 2; x; 18; ... are the first three terms of a geometric sequence, determine the value(s) of x.
[4]
QUESTION 7
Given Tn = 3n+1 . Which term is the first to exceed 20 000?
[4]
QUESTION 8
The sequence 3; 9; 17; 27; ... is a quadratic sequence.
8.1 Write down the next term of the sequence. (1)
8.2 Determine an expression for the nth term of the sequence. (4)
8.3 What is the value of the first term of the sequence that is greater than 269? (4)
[9]
TOTAL: 60
2. INVESTIGATION 1: FUNCTIONS AND INVERSES TOTAL: 50
INSTRUCTIONS
PART 1: WHICH RELATIONS CONSTITUTE FUNCTIONS?
One-to-one relation: A relation is one-to-one if for every input value there is only one output value.
Many-to-one relation: A relation is many-to-one if for more than one input value there is one output value.
One-to-many relation: A relation is one-to-many if for one input value there is more than one output value.
1.1 Determine the type of relation in each case and give a reason.
1.1. (1)
1.1.2 {(1 ; 3), (2 ; 5), (6 ; 13), (7 ; 15)} (1)
1.1.3 (1)
A function is a set of ordered number pairs where no two ordered pairs have the same x-coordinate, or put differently: a function is a set of ordered pairs where, for every value of x there is one and only one value for y. However, for the same value of y there may be different values for x.
1.2 Which of the relations (in QUESTIONS 1.1.1 to 1.1.3) are functions? Why?
The vertical-line test is used to determine whether or not a given graph is a function.
To determine whether a graph is a function, do the vertical-line test. If any vertical line intersects the graph of f only once, then f is a function; and if any vertical line intersects the graph of f more than once, then f is not a function.
1.3 Determine whether or not the following graphs are functions. Give a reason for your answer.
PART 2: THE INVERSE OF AN EXPONENTIAL FUNCTION
2.1 Consider the equation g(x) = 2x. Now complete the following table:
x | – 3 | – 2 | – 1 | 0 | 1 | 2 |
y |
(1)
2.2 Sketch the graph of g.
2.3 Sketch the graph of f(x) = x as a dotted line on the same set of axes as g. (1)
2.4 Complete the table below for h, if h is g when the x and y values are interchanged.
x | ||||||
y |
Draw h on the same set of axes as g. (4)
2.5 Hence, write down the x-intercept of each graph.
y = 2x x = 2y
2.5.1___________________________________________________________
2.5.2___________________________________________________________ (2)
2.6 Write down the domain and range of:
2.6.1 y = 2x
Domain: ___________________
Range: ____________________ (2)
2.6.2 x = 2y
Domain:____________________
Range:______________________ (2)
2.6.3 What is the relationship between the domain and the range of the two graphs? (1)
2.6.4 Are both graphs functions? Give reasons. (2)
2.6.5 Write the equation of x = 2y in the form y = (1)
2.6.6 Do you notice any line of symmetry in your sketch? What is the equation of this line? (1)
2.6.7 In mathematics we call h the inverse of g. Make a conjecture about the graph and its inverse. (3)
PART 3: WHEN IS THE INVERSE OF A QUADRATIC FUNCTION ALSO A FUNCTION?
3.1 Given: f (x) = 2x2, for
3.1.1 Write down the equation of the inverse of f. (1)
3.1.2 Write down the turning points of both f and its inverse. (2)
3.1.3 Sketch the graphs of f and its inverse on the same set of axes. (2)
3.1.4 Decide whether or not the inverse of f is a function, and give a reason for your answer. (2)
3.1.5 Explain how you would restrict the domain of f such that its inverse is a function. (2)
3.1.6 Hence, write down the corresponding range of the inverse of f if:
3.1.7 On separate sets of axes, sketch the graphs of the inverse of f with restricted domains as in QUESTION 3.1.6. Indicate the domain and range of each. (2)
3.1.8 Are the two graphs in QUESTION 3.1.7 functions? Give a reason or reasons for your answer. (2)
TOTAL: 50
3. INVESTIGATION 2: APPLICATION OF DIFFERENTIAL CALCULUS TOTAL: 50
INSTRUCTIONS
OBJECTIVE: Investigating the point of inflection of a cubic graph and its relationship with the graphs of the first and the second derivatives.
CASE 1
Given: f (x) = x3 – 7x2 + 36
1.1 Draw the graph of f neatly on graph paper. Clearly indicate all intercepts and coordinates of turning points. (8)
1.2 Determine the first derivative of f, and name it g. (1)
1.3 Draw the graph of g on the same set of axes as f. Clearly show all intercepts and the turning point. (3)
1.4 Determine the second derivative of f and name it h. Then sketch the graph of h on the same set of axes as f and g. Clearly show all intercepts of the graph with the axes. (3)
1.5 What do you notice regarding the x-intercepts of the quadratic function and the x-coordinates of the turning points of the cubic function? (1)
1.6 The point of inflection can be determined by solving f “(x) = 0. It can also be determined by calculating the midpoint of the turning points of the cubic graph.
Hence, determine the point of inflection of f. (3)
1.7 What do you notice regarding the axis of symmetry of g, the x-intercept of h and the x-coordinate of the point of inflection of f ? (1)
[20]
CASE 2
Given: f (x) = – x3 – 2x2 + 4x + 8
2.1 Draw the graph of f neatly on graph paper. Clearly indicate all intercepts and coordinates of turning points. (7)
2.2 Determine the first derivative of f, and name it g. (1)
2.3 Draw the graph of g on the same set of axes as f, and clearly show all intercepts and the turning point. (4)
2.4 Determine the second derivative of f and name it h, then sketch the graph of h on the same set of axes as f and g. Clearly show all intercepts of the graph with the axes. (3)
2.5 What do you notice regarding the x-intercepts of the quadratic function and the x-coordinates of the turning points of the cubic function? (1)
2.6 The point of inflection can be determined by solving f “ (x) = 0. It can also be determined by calculating the mid point of the turning points of the cubic graph.
Hence, determine the point of inflection of f. (3)
2.7 What do you notice regarding the axis of symmetry of g, the x-intercept of h and the x-coordinate of the point of inflection of f ? (1)
[20]
3. CONCLUSION
Based on the two cases, what conclusion can you draw about the point of inflection of a cubic function in relation to the graphs of the first and second derivatives? [2]
4. APPLICATION
The parabola shown below is the graph of the derivative of a function f.
4.1 For what value(s) of x is f :
4.1.1 Increasing (2)
4.1.2 Decreasing (2)
4.2 Give the abscissae of the turning point(s) of y = f (x). (2)
4.3 Classify the stationary point(s). (2)
[8]
TOTAL: 50
4. PROJECT: A PRACTICAL APPLICATION OF DIFFERENTIAL CALCULUS TOTAL: 50
INSTRUCTIONS
CONTAINERS
SPECIFICATIONS
FURTHER COMPARISON
Apart from your conclusion based on the three options, what other shape of soft drink container would you use in the manufacturing of soft drink cans? Give a reason for your answer.
HINT: The shape in question would be the most economical to manufacture but may not be the most practical choice.
RUBRIC
CRITERIA | MAXIMUM MARK | MARKS AWARDED | ||
A | B | C | ||
Correct mathematical formulae | 3 x 3 | |||
Correct calculations: | ||||
Measurements of bases | 4 x 3 | |||
Height of the containers | 2 x 3 | |||
Logical reasoning and presentation | 3 x 3 | |||
Submitting on time | 2 | |||
Conclusion of the least material needed | 1 x 3 | |||
Final, further comparison | 1 x 3 | |||
Sketches | 2 x 3 | |||
TOTAL | 50 |
LIFE SCIENCES
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
TEACHER GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENTS | |||
Contents | Page | ||
1 | Introduction | 3 | |
2 | Aims of the project | 3 | |
3 | Programme of formal assessment in Life Sciences | 4 | |
3.1 | Practical tasks | 5 | |
3.2 | Research Project | 5 | |
3.3 | Assignment | 6 | |
3.4 | Tests and Examinations | 6 | |
4 | Scope of the project | 7 | |
5 | Quality assurance process followed | 7 | |
6 | Assessment tasks | 8 | |
6.1 | Practical Task 1 – Surveying human characteristics | 8 | |
6.2 | Practical Task 2 – Simulating natural selection | 10 | |
6.3 | Assignment 1 – Response to the environment | 13 | |
6.4 | Assignment 2 – Reproduction | 20 | |
6.5 | Test – Nucleic acids and meiosis | 25 | |
7 | Marking guidelines | 30 | |
7.1 | Practical Task 1 – Surveying human characteristics | 30 | |
7.2 | Practical Task 2 – Simulating natural selection | 32 | |
7.3 | Assignment 1 – Response to the environment | 34 | |
7.4 | Assignment 2 – Reproduction | 41 | |
7.5 | Test – Nucleic acids and meiosis | 48 |
1. Introduction
Assessment is a continuous planned process of identifying, gathering and interpreting information about the performance of learners, using various forms of assessment. It involves four steps: generating and collecting evidence of achievement, evaluating this evidence, recording the findings and using this information to understand and assist in the learners’ development to improve the process of learning and teaching. Assessment should be both informal (Assessment for Learning) and formal (Assessment of Learning). In both cases regular feedback should be provided to learners to enhance the learning experience.
School-based assessment (SBA) forms part of the formal assessment component. It is a purposive collection of learners’ work that tells the story of the learners’ efforts, progress or achievement in attaining knowledge (content, concepts and skills) in the subject. The advantages of school-based assessment can be summarised as follows:
School-based assessment forms part of a year-long formal Programme of Assessment in each grade and subject. The assessment tasks should be carefully designed to cover the content of the subject as well as the range of skills and cognitive levels that have been identified in specific aims. Tests, practical tasks, assignments and projects make up the SBA component in Life Sciences.
Teachers should ensure learners understand the assessment criteria and have extensive experience using it for self- and peer assessment in informal situations before conducting a planned formal assessment activity. Teachers should also have used these criteria for informal assessment and teaching purposes before they conduct any formal assessment so that learners are familiar with the criteria and the assessment process.
2. Aims of the project
Through this publication it is envisaged that TEACHER capacity will be increased in respect of each of the following:
Through this publication it is also envisaged that LEARNERS will benefit by:
3. Programme of formal assessment in Life Sciences
Formal, recorded, school-based assessment | Trial (Preliminary) examination | ||
Content | Practical | Two written examination papers (2½ hours + 2½ hours) | |
|
|
This examination must test:
| |
School-based assessment (during the year) | |||
Term 1 | Term 2 | Term 3 and Term 4 | |
|
|
| |
33⅓% | 33⅓% | 33⅓% | |
Convert to 50% | 50% | ||
SBA Total: 100 |
NOTE: The SBA mark must be converted to 25% and the external examination counts 75% of the final mark.
A description of the requirements for each of the different types of assessment tasks follows below.
3.1 Practical tasks
When designing the practical tasks, the Life Sciences teacher must ensure that:
3.2 Research Project
At least ONE of the tasks across Grades 10–12 must be a research project.
When designing the research project, the Life Sciences teacher must ensure that it:
3.3 Assignment
At least ONE of the tasks across Grades 10–12 must be an assignment.
When designing an assignment, the Life Sciences teacher must ensure that it:
3.4 Tests and Examinations
When designing the tests as well as the mid-year and trial examinations, the Life Sciences teacher must ensure that:
4. Scope of the project
This publication includes the following:
The following exemplars together with their marking guidelines have been included in this publication:
Type of assessment task included in this publication | Number included in this publication | Number required in the Grade 12 year | Term in which assessment task is required |
Assignment | 2 | 1 | Term 3 |
Practical task | 2 | 3 | Term 1, Term 2, Term 3 or 4 |
Test | 1 | 3 | Term 1, Term 2, Term 3 or 4 |
5. Quality assurance process followed
A team of experts comprised of teachers and subject advisors from provinces was appointed by the DBE to develop and compile assessment tasks. They were required to extract excellent examples of learner tasks from their respective schools and districts. The panel of experts spent a period of four days at the DBE, developing tasks based on guidelines and policies. Moderation and quality assurance of the tasks were undertaken by national and provincial examiners and moderators. The assessment tasks were further refined by the national internal moderators to ensure that they were in line with the CAPS document.
6. Assessment tasks
6.1 Practical Task 1 – Surveying human characteristics
Topic | Genetics | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 2 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 30 | Duration | 90 minutes |
Task
Conduct a survey of the occurrence/frequency of dominant and recessive phenotypes for each of three traits/ characteristics (as shown in the pictures below) among the learners in your school.
Background information
Many characteristics in humans are controlled by one gene with two alleles, one dominant and one recessive. Three examples are shown below.
Method
QUESTIONS
[30]
6.2 Practical Task 2 – Simulating natural selection
Topic | Evolution | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 2 | Type of activity | Pair/ Individual |
Marks | 30 | Duration | 60 minutes |
Task
Simulate ‘natural selection’ using a paper model.
Background information
A simulation allows one to demonstrate something that might sometimes be dangerous or that might sometimes require a lot of time, quickly and in a simple and safe way, using models.
The different parts that comprise the paper model in this task represent different components in nature. The sheet of newspaper and the sheet of white paper represent two different environmental conditions. The circles cut from white paper and from newspaper represent the different appearances/phenotypes of different individuals of the same species.
Aim
You are required to investigate the survival of the organisms with the two different phenotypes under different environmental conditions.
Materials required
Method
Question 1.
DIFFERENT | STARTING POPULATION | NUMBER OF CIRCLES | ||
White paper circles | Newspaper circles | White paper circles | Newspaper circles | |
White paper | 30 | 30 | ||
Newspaper | 30 | 30 |
Draw a bar graph on the same system of axes to represent the results of your investigation. (8)
Explain the difference in results obtained for the two types of circles when using the sheet of white paper. (3)
State ONE way in which you could improve the reliability of the results. (1)
[30]
6.3 Assignment 1 – Response to the environment
Topic | Response to the environment | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 1, SA 2, SA 3 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 100 | Duration | 90 minutes |
Instructions and information
NOTE: If it is not possible to schedule a single 90-minute session for this assignment, then SECTION A can be done on one day in a 45-minute session and SECTION B the following day in another 45-minute session.
________________________________________________________________________
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
An investigation was conducted to study apical dominance in bean plants. Four groups of plants were used. The diagram below illustrates the process.
The results are shown in the table below.
Group 1 | Group 2 | Group 3 | Group 4 | |
Treatment given | Untreated | Apical meristem removed | Apical meristem removed and auxin applied to the cut tip | Apical meristem intact but a barrier to the movement of substances was placed under the tip |
Response to treatment given | Growth of apical meristem but not of lateral buds | Growth of lateral buds | No growth of lateral buds | Growth of lateral buds |
1.1 For this investigation, state the: (1)
1.1.1 Independent variable (1)
1.1.2 Dependent variable (2)
1.1.3 Any TWO fixed variables (3)
1.2 Formulate a possible hypothesis for the above investigation. (4)
1.3 Explain the difference in results for Groups 3 and 4. (1)
1.4 Do the results allow you to accept or reject the hypothesis you formulated in QUESTION 1.2? [12]
QUESTION 2
The diagrams below show some stages in an investigation involving germinating bean seeds, kept in an evenly warm, damp environment.
2.1 What physical stimulus leads to the response above? (1)
2.2 Using the information in the diagram and your own knowledge, describe how the tip of the root grows in the direction that it does after two days. (6)
2.3 State TWO functions (other than growth movements and apical dominance) of the hormone responible for the growth movement illustrated above. (2)
2.4 Will the same results be obtained if the investigation is carried out in a dark cupboard? (1)
2.5 Explain your answer to QUESTION 2.4. (2)
2.6 Explain why the cotton wool was kept moist. (2)
[14]
QUESTION 3
Read the passage below and answer the questions that follow.
DIABETES MELLITUS Diabetes mellitus is a disorder relating to the role of insulin. There are two forms of the condition: insulin-dependent diabetes (IDDM) and a non-insulin dependent form (NIDDM). |
The normal plasma glucose level is 100 mg/100 ml. The glucose tolerance test was conducted for three adults and the plasma glucose level (mg/100 ml) was recorded for two hours at 30-minute intervals. The results are shown below.
Time (minutes) | 0 | 30 | 60 | 90 | 120 | |
Plasma glucose levels (mg/100 ml) | Adult 1 | 85 | 125 | 100 | 85 | 80 |
Adult 2 | 130 | 215 | 250 | 260 | 240 | |
Adult 3 | 100 | 210 | 180 | 170 | 160 |
3.1 State how the glucose tolerance response test above is used to decide if a person is suffering from diabetes. (2)
3.2 Adult 1 is not diabetic.
3.2.1 Describe the changes expected in insulin secretion in Adult 1 during the period 30 minutes to 90 minutes after the glucose drink.
3.2.2 Explain your answer to QUESTION 3.2.1. (2)
3.3 Draw two line graphs on the same set of axes to show the glucose tolerance of Adults 1 and 2. (9)
3.4 What was the percentage increase in glucose level when the glucose was at its maximum in Adult 2? Show all working. (3)
3.5 Write down the plasma glucose level of the three adults after two hours as a ratio in simple whole numbers. Show all working. (2)
3.6 Suggest, with reasons, what would happen to insulin secretion for Adult 2:
3.6.1 If the condition was IDDM (2)
3.6.2 If the condition was NIDDM (2)
[24]
TOTAL SECTION A: 50
SECTION B
QUESTION 4
Read the passage and information below and answer the questions that follow.
STIMULUS AND RESPONSE The eagle and the rabbit are dependent for their survival on their nervous system response rate. Their eye, ear and skin sensors send messages along sensory neurons to the central nervous system. The message is transferred by interneurons to provide a response along motor neurons demanding that the muscles move quickly. |
Two learners conducted an investigation in the following way to determine which sense organ sends the message fastest to the brain: the eye, the ear or the skin (sight, hearing, or touch):
The results they obtained are shown in the following table:
Trial number | Distance on meter stick (cm) | ||
Sight | Hearing | Touch | |
1 | 2 | 5 | 10 |
2 | 3 | 6 | 8 |
3 | 2 | 6 | 9 |
Average distance (cm) | 2,3 | X | 9 |
4.1 Name the path that is described in the passage. (2)
4.2 In relation to this path, what term is used to describe each of the following in terms of the role they play?
4.2.1 The muscles (1)
4.2.2 Skin sensors (1)
4.3 Why should you advise the two learners to repeat the procedure more than three times for each investigation? (2)
4.4 Identify the following in their investigation:
4.4.1 The dependent variable (1)
4.4.2 The independent variable (1)
4.5 Calculate the average distance that the meter stick fell when doing the ‘hearing’ investigation. Show all working. (3)
4.6 Study the graph below showing how the distance on the meter stick can be converted to reaction time in milliseconds.
Use the reaction time over distance conversion graph to determine:
4.6.1 The actual reaction time if the meter stick dropped 9 centimetres (2)
4.6.2 The distance the ruler will drop for a reaction time of 400 milliseconds (2)
[15]
QUESTION 5
The graph shows the speed of a nerve impulse along neurons with different diameters, measured in micrometres (μm).
5.1 Describe the relationship between the diameter of a neuron and the speed of an impulse travelling along the neuron. (2)
5.2 Use the graph to estimate how fast an impulse would travel along a neuron with a diameter of 5 μm. (2)
5.3 Name the functional gap found between two neurons across which impulses are transmitted. (1)
5.4 Explain the significance of the myelin sheath that covers the neurons. (2)
5.5 Draw a diagram to illustrate the structure of a motor neuron. Indicate the direction of the impulse by means of an arrow in the diagram. (7)
[14]
QUESTION 6
A person sitting in a darkened room covers one eye. A dim electric bulb, positioned at varying distances from the person, is switched on at one-minute intervals for a period of 9 seconds. During this period the diameter of the pupil of the eye is measured. The results obtained are shown in the table below. Study the table and answer the questions that follow.
Time interval | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 |
Diameter of pupil (mm) | 2 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 8 | 7 | 3 | 1 | 6 |
6.1 Name the structure in the eye that controls the size of the pupil. (1)
6.2 Between which TWO time intervals did the following changes in the diameter of the pupil occur?
6.2.1 Smallest increase (2)
6.2.2 Biggest decrease (2)
6.3 State why the size of the pupil changes from interval 8 to interval 9. (2)
6.4 Describe how the size of the pupil changes from interval 8 to interval 9. (4)
6.5 Why is the response in QUESTION 6.3 referred to as a ‘reflex’? (1)
6.6 What is the significance of this reflex? (1)
6.7 At which time interval was the bulb the furthest from the eye? (1)
6.8 Explain your answer to QUESTION 6.7. (2)
6.9 State TWO ways in which the investigator could ensure that the results of this investigation are reliable. (2)
6.10 State THREE things that must be kept constant in this investigation to ensure that it is valid. (3)
[21]
TOTAL SECTION B: 50
GRAND TOTAL: 100
6.4 Assignment 2 – Reproduction
Topic | Reproduction | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 1, SA 2, SA 3 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 100 | Duration | 90 minutes |
Instructions and information
NOTE: If it is not possible to schedule a single 90-minute session for this assignment, then SECTION A can be done on one day in a 45-minute session and SECTION B the following day in another 45-minute session.
________________________________________________________________________
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
Read the text below and then answer the questions that follow.
REPRODUCTIVE STRATEGIES OF THE BULLFROG Most amphibians spend at least part of their lives in moist surroundings, and their fragile, jelly-like eggs are usually laid in water. |
1.1 State the type of fertilisation (external or internal) that occurs in bullfrogs and describe how it occurs. State whether reproduction in bullfrogs is viviparous, oviparous or ovoviviparous.(3)
1.2 Explain your answer to QUESTION 1.2. (1)
1.3 Describe TWO characteristics of a frog’s egg. (2)
1.4 Give TWO reasons suggested in the article for bullfrog eggs to be laid in water. (2)
1.5 Frog eggs are vulnerable to predators, since there is little or no parental protection. (2)
1.6 Explain THREE strategies that ensure a good survival rate of tadpoles.
[16]
QUESTION 2
The electron micrograph below is that of the human sperm. Study the micrograph and answer the questions that follow.
2.1 Draw a labelled line diagram of the human sperm represented in the electron micrograph. (6)
2.2 Use the scale line provided to calculate the width of the sperm at its widest point. (4)
2.3 Explain THREE ways in which the sperm is structurally suited for its role in fertilisation. (6)
[16]
QUESTION 3
Records of human fertility for the period 1941 to 1990 have shown changes in the sperm counts of normal men. The table below summarises the changing percentages of men with high or low sperm counts over a period of 50 years.
TIME PERIOD | MEN WITH HIGH SPERM COUNTS (%) | MEN WITH LOW SPERM COUNTS (%) |
1941–1950 | 50 | 4 |
1951–1960 | 45 | 5 |
1961–1970 | 28 | 11 |
1971–1980 | 21 | 14 |
1981–1990 | 15 | 18 |
3.1 During which time period was there:
3.1.1 The highest percentage of men with low sperm counts? (1)
3.1.2 The lowest percentage of men with high sperm counts? (1)
3.1.3 The greatest difference between men with high sperm counts and men with low sperm counts? (1)
3.2 Describe the trend for men with low sperm counts, and compare it with those with high sperm counts over the period of 50 years. (2)
3.3 Calculate the percentage increase in men with low sperm counts from 1971 to 1990. (2)
3.4 Suggest TWO reasons for the trend described in QUESTION 3.2. (2)
[9]
QUESTION 4
The table below shows the results of a survey on the use of contraceptives by a sample of women in a rural area.
CONTRACEPTIVE | NUMBER OF WOMEN |
Sterilisation | 34 |
Pill | 38 |
Condom | 22 |
Rhythm method | 30 |
None | 76 |
TOTAL | 200 |
Draw a pie chart to show the results of the survey. Show all working. [9]
TOTAL SECTION A: 50
SECTION B
QUESTION 5
The diagram below shows the changes in the ovary, uterus and level of hormones during a 28-day menstrual cycle. Study the diagram and answer the questions that follow.
5.1 Which hormone is responsible for:
5.1.1 Ovulation (1)
5.1.2 Primary (first) thickening of the endometrium (1)
5.2 According to the graph, on which day(s) does each of the following occur:
5.2.1 Menstruation (1)
5.2.2 Ovulation (1)
5.3 Two structures in the ovaries are responsible for the secretion of two female hormones.
5.3.1 Name the TWO structures and the hormones they secrete. (4)
5.3.2 Give evidence from the graph to support your answer to QUESTION 5.3.1. 4)
5.4 Explain the interaction that occurs between the hormones FSH and progesterone and why it is necessary. (3)
5.5 Is the female, whose cycle is represented in the diagram, pregnant? (1)
5.6 Give TWO reasons from the graph for your answer to QUESTION 5.5. (2)
[18]
QUESTION 6
The table below shows the average human foetal length of males and females over a 40-week gestation period.
Time (weeks) | Foetal length (cm) | |
Male | Female | |
8 | 1 | 1 |
13 | 7 | 7 |
16 | 14 | 13 |
24 | 33 | 31 |
36 | 46 | 43 |
40 | 51 | 49 |
6.1 Draw TWO sets of bar graphs on the same system of axes to compare male and female foetal length over time. (9)
6.2 State TWO conclusions that could be drawn from the results in the graph. (4)
[13]
QUESTION 7
John and Mary have two children. The oldest is Patrick, followed by Anne, a girl. Mary is pregnant again.
7.1 By representing a genetic cross, show the percentage probability of them having another daughter. (7)
7.2 Mary and John’s first child is a haemophiliac and they are afraid that their third child may also have the disorder. Mary is a carrier of haemophilia and John has the normal clotting factor. An ultrasound scan shows that Mary is expecting a girl. (7)
Show, using a genetic cross, the percentage probability of their third child having haemophilia.
7.3 Use the following symbols to construct a simple pedigree diagram showing the inheritance of haemophilia in this family: (5)
[19]
TOTAL SECTION B: 50
6.5 Test – Nucleic acids and meiosis
Topic | Nucleic acids and meiosis | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 1, SA 3 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 50 | Duration | 60 minutes |
Instructions and information
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
1.1 Various possible options are provided as answers to the following questions. Choose the answer and write only the letter (A–D) next to the question number (1.1.1–1.1.5) in the ANSWER BOOK, for example 1.1.6 D.
1.1.1 All nucleic acids are made up of …
1.1.2 If a DNA molecule contains 20 000 base molecules, of which 20% are cytosine, how many adenine molecules will be present?
1.1.3 DNA replication ensures that all daughter cells formed as a result of …
1.1.4 In individuals with normal haemoglobin, the mRNA for haemoglobin includes the codon GAA. This sequence is changed in individuals with sickle cell anaemia so that their mRNA has a codon GUA at the same location. This suggests that the DNA has undergone a mutation involving a change of base sequence from ...
1.1.5 The result of profiling various DNA samples in a criminal investigation is shown below.
Which conclusion about the crime could the DNA analyst draw?
1.2 Give the correct biological term for each of the following descriptions. Write only the term next to the question number (1.2.1–1.2.4) in the ANSWER BOOK.
1.2.1 Specific lengths of DNA which carry codes for specific characteristics of organisms
1.2.2 The part of protein synthesis taking place in the nucleus
1.2.3 The bonds between the two strands of a DNA molecule
1.2.4 The chromosome condition/ploidy of a somatic cell (4)
1.3 Indicate whether each of the statements in COLUMN I applies to A only, B only, both A and B or none of the items in COLUMN II. Write A only, B only, both A and B, or none next to the question number (1.3.1–1.3.3) in the ANSWER BOOK.
COLUMN I | COLUMN II | ||
1.3.1 | Chromatids separate and move to the poles. | A: B: | Anaphase I Anaphase II |
1.3.2 | The strand of DNA that provides the code during replication. | A: B: | Template Complementary strand |
1.3.3 | Contain bases that are complementary to that of DNA. | A: B: | Codon Anticodon |
(3 x 2) (6)
TOTAL SECTION A: 20
SECTION B
QUESTION 2
Study the diagram below showing a process that takes place in all living cells.
2.1 Identify the process represented in the above diagram. (1)
2.2 Name the specific part of the process mentioned in QUESTION 2.1 that occur at the organelle labelled G. (1)
2.3 Describe the process named in answer to QUESTION 2.2. (5)
2.4 State TWO similarities in structure between molecules B and C. (2)
2.5 The table below indicates the amino acids that are carried by different tRNAs.
tRNA BASES | AMINO ACID | tRNA BASES | AMINO ACID | tRNA BASES | AMINO ACID |
GUU | Glutamine | CUA | Aspartate | GAU | Leucine |
GCG | Arginine | GGU | Proline | UAU | Isoleucine |
CCG | Glycine | ACA | Cysteine | GUG | Histidine |
CUU | Glutamate | AGC | Serine | ACC | Tryptophan |
Identify the amino acids which will be brought to organelle G according to the code provided by the mRNA found on G. (3)
2.6 Write down the triplet of DNA bases that correspond to each of the molecules B, F and H, respectively. (3)
[15]
QUESTION 3
Study the diagrams below that represent different phases of Meiosis I.
3.1 Identify the structures labelled B and E. (2)
3.2 State TWO functions of the structure labelled F. (2)
3.3 Describe the process shown at A in Diagram I. (2)
3.4 Tabulate TWO ways in which a cell in the phase shown in Diagram II would differ from a cell in the same phase in Meiosis II. (5)
3.5 How many chromosomes will be present in each cell at the end of meiosis? (1)
3.6 If the above cell division occurred in a human being, describe the events leading to the formation of an offspring with Down syndrome. (3)
[15]
TOTAL SECTION B: 30
GRAND TOTAL: 50
7. Marking guidelines
7.1 Practical Task 1 – Surveying human characteristics
Criterion | Elaboration | Mark |
Caption | Includes both variables: 'number of learners' and 'different characteristics' | 1 |
Appropriate column headings | Includes names of learners as well as dominant and recessive phenotypes for each characteristic | 1 |
Data entered | Information on the observed phenotypes entered per learner for each characteristic | 1 |
Percentage of learners | Shown at the end of the table for the different phenotypes for each characteristic | 1 |
(4)
Criterion | Elaboration | Mark |
Same system of axes | Bar graphs drawn on the same system of axes | 1 |
Caption | Includes both variables: 'number of learners' and 'different characteristics' | 1 |
X-axis | Correct label (phenotypes of each characteristic) Correct scale (equal width and interval of bars) | 1 1 |
Y-axis | Correct label (percentage of learners) Correct scale | 1 1 |
Plotting of bars | 1 mark: 1-5 bars plotted correctly 2 marks: all 6 bars plotted correctly | 2 |
(8)
Key | Tongue roller: R | Non-roller: r | |
P1 phenotype | Tongue roller | x | Tongue roller✓ |
genotype | Rr | x | Rr✓ |
meiosis | |||
G1 | R , r | x | R , r✓ |
fertilisation | |||
F1 genotype | RR ; Rr ; Rr; | rr✓ | |
phenotype | 3 tongue rollers | 1 non-roller ✓ |
[30]
7.2 Practical Task 2 – Simulating natural selection
Criterion | Mark |
Results not entered | 0 |
Some results entered | 1 |
All results entered | 2 |
(2)
Criterion | Elaboration | Mark |
Same system of axes | Bar graphs drawn on the same system of axes | 1 |
Caption | Includes both variables: 'number of circles' and 'different backgrounds' | 1 |
X-axis | Correct label (Different backgrounds) | 1 |
Y-axis | Correct label (number of circles picked up) | 1 |
Plotting of bars | 1 mark: 1-3 bars plotted correctly | 2 |
(8)
[30]
7.3 Assignment 1 – Response to the environment
QUESTION 1
1.1
1.1.1 Presence/absence of auxins✔ (1)
1.1.2 Growth of lateral buds✔ (1)
1.1.3
1.2 Auxins✔ at the growing tip of the stem stimulate✔ the growth of lateral buds✔
OR
Auxins✔ at the growing tip of the stem inhibit✔ the growth of lateral buds✔
OR
Auxins✔ at the growing tip of the stem have no effect✔ on the growth of lateral buds✔ (3)
1.3
1.4 Support✓ (if the results obtained are in line with the hypothesis stated by the learner in Question 1.2)
OR
Reject✓ (if the results obtained contradict the hypothesis stated by the learner in Question 1.2) (1)
[12]
QUESTION 2
2.1 Gravity✔ (1)
2.2
2.3 Cell division ✔; cell elongation✔; the development of fruit✔; the abscission of leaves and fruit✔; the development of adventitious roots in stem cuttings ✔ (any 2) (2)
2.4 Yes ✔ (1)
2.5 The growth is in response to gravity✔ and not light✔ (2)
2.6 Moisture is essential✔ for germination✔. (2)
[14]
QUESTION 3
3.1 Patient is diabetic if blood glucose level is above 200 mg/100 ml✔ for up to two hours after the glucose test drink✔. (2)
3.2
3.2.1 Insulin level will increase between 30 and 60 minutes✔ and then decrease✔. (2)
3.2.2 The level would initially increase when glucose level is higher than normal✔then decrease when the level of glucose decreases✔. (2)
3.3 Changes in the plasma glucose level during a glucose test over a period of time
Allocation of marks for the graph
Criterion | Elaboration | Mark |
Same system of axes | Both line graphs drawn on the same system of axes | 1 |
Caption | Includes both variables: ‘time’ and ‘plasma glucose levels’ | 1 |
Key for graphs | Key provided or each graph labelled for Adult 1 and Adult 2 | 1 |
X-axis | Correct label and units (Time in minutes ) Correct scale | 1 1 |
Y-axis | Correct label and units (Plasma glucose level in mg/100 ml) Correct scale | 1 1 |
Plotting of points | 1 mark: 1-9 points plotted correctly 2 marks: all 10 points plotted correctly | 2 |
(9)
3.4
(260 mg/100 ml – 130 mg/100 ml) = 130 ✔
130/130 X 100✔
= 100%✔ (3)
3.5 Adult 1: Adult 2: Adult 3 = 80 :240 :160✔ = 1 :3 :2✔
3.6.1 IDDM - no insulin is produced✔ because the pancreatic cells responsible for insulin secretion are not functioning✔/do not produce insulin. (2)
3.6.2 NIDDM – insulin secretion will increase✔ since the pancreas is not affected✔/cells that normally respond become less sensitive to insulin (2)
[24]
TOTAL SECTION A: 50
SECTION B
QUESTION 4
4.1 Reflex arc ✓ ✓ (2)
4.2
4.2.1 Effectors✓ (1)
4.2.2 Receptors✓ (1)
4.3 To improve ✓the reliability✓ of the investigation (2)
4.1
4.4.1 Distance on meter stick/reaction time ✓ (1)
4.4.2 Different senses (sight/hearing/touch) ✓ (1)
4.5
5 cm + 6 cm + 6 cm = 17 cm ✓
17 cm = 5,7 cm ✓
3 ✓ (3)
4.6
4.6.1 475 ✓ milliseconds ✓ (2)
4.6.2 3✓ cm✓
[15]
QUESTION 5
5.1 As the diameter of the neuron increases✔ the speed of the impulse increases✔ (2)
5.2 35✔m/s✔ (2)
5.3 Synapse✔ (1)
5.4 It provides electrical insulation✔ thus increasing the speed of impulse transmission✔ (2)
5.5
Allocation of marks for the drawing
Caption | 1 |
Label lines do not cross | 1 |
Any four correct labels | 4 |
Direction of impulse correctly shown | 1 |
(7)
[14]
QUESTION 6
6.1 Iris✔ (1)
6.2
6.2.1 2✔to 3✔ (2)
6.2.2 6✔ to 7✔ (2)
6.3 Dim light conditions✔ causes pupil to adjust so that more light can enter✔ the eye (2)
6.4
6.5 It occurs automatically✔/involuntarily/without the control of the will (1)
6.6 It protects✔ the eye from damage in bright conditions (1)
6.7 Interval 5✔ (1)
6.8 Diameter of the pupil✔ was at its widest✔ (2)
6.9
6.10
[21]
TOTAL SECTION B: 50
GRAND TOTAL: 100
7.4 Assignment 2 – Reproduction
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
1.1 Fertilisation occurs externally ✔ (1)
Eggs are released into the water and then male releases sperms✔ which fertilise eggs in the water✔ (2) (3)
1.2 Oviparous✔ (1)
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
[16]
QUESTION 2
2.1 (6)
Allocation of marks for the drawing
Criterion | Mark |
Size and proportion | 1 |
Caption | 1 |
Any 4 correct labels | 4 |
2.2
1 µm = 4 mm✔
Width of sperm = 12 mm✔ = X µm
1 µm = 4 mm
X µm = 12 mm ✔
X = 3 µm ✔ (4)
2.3
[16]
QUESTION 3
3.1
3.1.1 1981–1990 ✔ (1)
3.1.2 1981–1990 ✔ (1)
3.1.3 1941–1950 ✔ (1)
3.2 Men with low sperm counts have increased ✔ while men with high sperm counts have decreased ✔ (2)
3.3
% increase = 18- 14 ✔
= 4 ✔ % (2)
3.4
[9]
QUESTION 4
CALCULATIONS:
34÷200 x 360 = 61,2º (rounded down to 61º)
38÷200 x 360 = 68,4º (rounded down to 68º)
22÷200 x 360 = 39,6º (rounded up to 40º)
30÷200 x 360 = 54º
76÷200 x 360 = 136,8º (rounded up to 137º)
Allocation of marks for the graph
Criterion | Elaboration | Mark |
Calculations/working to determine the correct proportions | 3 marks: All five calculations correct | 3 |
Caption | Includes both variables: ‘contraceptives’ and ‘number of rural women’ | 1 |
Proportions accurate for each sector labelled | 5 marks: All five sectors correct (1 x mark/sector) | 5 |
[9]
TOTAL SECTION A: 50
SECTION B
QUESTION 5
5.1
5.1.1 LH ✔ (1)
5.1.2 Oestrogen ✔ (1)
5.2
5.2.1 0–7 days ✔ (1)
5.2.2 Day 14 ✔ (1)
5.3
5.3.1
5.3.2
5.4
5.5 No ✔ (1)
5.6
Corpus luteum has degenerated ✔
Progesterone has decreased✔
FSH started to increase at the end of the cycle✔ (any 2) (2)
[18]
QUESTION 6
6.1
Allocation of marks for the graph
Criterion | Elaboration | Mark |
Same system of axes | Bar graph drawn on the same system of axes | 1 |
Caption | Includes both variables: ‘time’ and ‘foetal length’ | 1 |
Key for graphs | Key provided or each graph labelled for ‘males’ and ‘females’ | 1 |
X-axis | Correct label and units (Time in weeks) Correct width and interval of bars | 1 1 |
Y-axis | Correct label and units (Foetal length in cm) Correct scale | 1 1 |
Plotting of bars | 1 mark: 1-11 bars plotted correctly 2 marks: all 12 bars plotted correctly | 2 |
6.2
[13]
QUESTION 7
7.1
Key | Male: XY | Female: XX | |
P1 phenotype | Male | x | Female✓ |
genotype | XY | x | XX✓ |
meiosis | |||
G1 | X , Y | x | X✓ |
fertilisation | |||
genotype | XX ; XY✓ | ||
F1 phenotype | 1 Male : 1 Female✓ | ||
50% probability of being a female✓* |
Allocate marks for the following labels:
P1/parents and F1/offspring✓
Meiosis and fertilisation✓ (1 compulsory* + 6 others) (7)
7.2
Key | Normal: H | Haemophiliac : h | |||
P1 phenotype | Normal father | x | Normal mother✓ | ||
genotype | XHY | x | XHXh ✓ | ||
meiosis | |||||
G1 | XH ; Y | x | XH ; Xh ✓ | ||
fertilisation | |||||
F1 genotype | XH XH | XH Xh | XH Y | Xh Y ✓ | |
phenotype | 2 normal daughters | 1 normal son | 1 son with haemophilia | ||
0% probability✓* of a child with haemophilia |
(1 compulsory* + 6 others)
(7)
7.3
(5)
[19]
TOTAL SECTION B: 50
GRAND TOTAL: 100
7.5 Test – Nucleic acids and meiosis
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
1.1
1.1.1 B✓✓
1.1.2 C✓✓
1.1.3 A✓✓
1.1.4 B✓✓
1.1.5 D✓✓ (5 x 2) (10)
1.2
1.2.1 Genes✓
1.2.2 Transcription✓
1.2.3 Weak hydrogen bonds✓
1.2.4 Diploid✓ (4)
1.3
1.3.1 B only✓✓
1.3.2 A only✓✓
1.3.3 A only✓✓ (3 x 2) (6)
TOTAL SECTION A: 20
SECTION B
QUESTION 2
2.1 Protein synthesis✔ (1)
2.2 Translation✔ (1)
2.3
2.4
2.5 Histidine ✔ cysteine ✔ serine ✔ (3)
2.6 GTT ✔ GGT ✔ AGC ✔ (3)
[15]
QUESTION 3
3.1
B – centromere✔ (2)
E – homologous chromosomes✔/bivalent
3.2
3.3 Crossing over✔ takes place Chromatids overlap✔
Segments of chromatids are exchanged✔ (any 2) (2)
3.4
Meiosis I | Meiosis II |
1. Chromosomes line up in their homologous pairs at the equa tor✔ | 1. Single chromosomes line up at the equator✔ |
Table ✔ (5)
3.5 Two✔ (1)
3.6
[15]
TOTAL SECTION B: 30
GRAND TOTAL: 50
LIFE SCIENCES
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
LEARNER GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENTS | PAGE | ||
1 | Introduction | 3 | |
2 | Programme of formal assessment in Life Sciences | 4 | |
3 | Assessment tasks | 7 | |
3.1 | Practical Task 1 – Surveying human characteristics | 7 | |
3.2 | Practical Task 2 – Simulating natural selection | 9 | |
3.3 | Assignment 1 – Response to the environment | 11 | |
3.4 | Assignment 2 – Reproduction | 19 | |
3.5 | Test – Nucleic acids and meiosis | 26 |
1. Introduction
Assessment is a continuous, planned process of identifying, gathering and interpreting information about your performance, using various forms of assessment. It involves four steps:
Keep track of your progress from the various assessment tasks that you undertake. Make a note of your personal areas of difficulty and develop a programme that will allow you to address each of these areas. This will guarantee a high quality pass at the end of the year.
We wish you great success through the year.
2. Programme of formal assessment in Life Sciences
The table below shows the number and types of assessment tasks required in the Grade 12 year.
Formal, recorded, school-based assessment | Trial (Preliminary) examination | |||
Content | Practical | Two written examination papers (2½ hours + 2½ hours) | ||
|
|
This examination must test:
| ||
School-based assessment (during the year) | ||||
Term 1 | Term 2 | Term 3 and Term 4 | ||
|
|
| ||
33% | 33% | 33% | ||
Convert to 50% | 50% | |||
SBA Total: 100 |
NOTE: The SBA mark must be converted to 25% and the external examination counts 75% of the final mark.
A description of the requirements for each of the different types of assessment tasks follows below.
2.1 Practical tasks
When designing the practical tasks, the Life Sciences teacher must ensure that:
2.2 Research project
A research project:
2.3 Assignment
The assignment:
2.4 Tests and Examinations
The following exemplars have been included in this publication:
Type of assessment task included in this publication | Number included in this publication | Number required in the Grade 12 year | Term in which assessment task is required |
Assignment | 2 | 1 | Term 3 |
Practical task | 2 | 3 | Term 1, Term 2, Term 3 or 4 |
Test | 1 | 3 | Term 1, Term 2, Term 3 or 4 |
The exemplars provided are meant to show you the format of these tasks as well as the way in which the content and skills of each topic may be assessed.
3. Assessment tasks
3.1 Practical Task 1 – Surveying human characteristics
Topic | Genetics | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 2 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 30 | Duration | 90 minutes |
Task
Conduct a survey of the occurrence/frequency of dominant and recessive phenotypes for each of three traits/ characteristics (as shown in the pictures below) among the learners in your school.
Background information
Many characteristics in humans are controlled by one gene with two alleles, one dominant and one recessive. Three examples are shown below.
Method
QUESTIONS
[30]
3.2 Practical Task 2 – Simulating natural selection
Topic | Evolution | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 2 | Type of activity | Pair/ Individual |
Marks | 30 | Duration | 60 minutes |
Task
Simulate ‘natural selection’ using a paper model.
Background information
A simulation allows one to demonstrate something that might sometimes be dangerous or that might sometimes require a lot of time, quickly and in a simple and safe way, using models.
The different parts that comprise the paper model in this task represent different components in nature. The sheet of newspaper and the sheet of white paper represent two different environmental conditions. The circles cut from white paper and from newspaper represent the different appearances/phenotypes of different individuals of the same species.
Aim
You are required to investigate the survival of the organisms with the two different phenotypes under different environmental conditions.
Materials required
Method
Question 1.
DIFFERENT BACKGROUNDS | STARTING POPULATION | NUMBER OF CIRCLES PICKED UP ON DIFFERENT BACKGROUNDS | ||
White paper circles | Newspaper circles | White paper circles | Newspaper circles | |
White paper | 30 | 30 | ||
Newspaper | 30 | 30 |
Draw a bar graph on the same system of axes to represent the results of your investigation. (8)
Explain the difference in results obtained for the two types of circles when using the sheet of white paper. (3)
State ONE way in which you could improve the reliability of the results. (1)
[30]
3.3 Assignment 1 – Response to the environment
Topic | Response to the environment | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 1, SA 2, SA 3 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 100 | Duration | 90 minutes |
Instructions and information
NOTE: If it is not possible to schedule a single 90-minute session for this assignment, then SECTION A can be done on one day in a 45-minute session and SECTION B the following day in another 45-minute session.
________________________________________________________________________
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
An investigation was conducted to study apical dominance in bean plants. Four groups of plants were used. The diagram below illustrates the process.
The results are shown in the table below.
Group 1 | Group 2 | Group 3 | Group 4 | |
Treatment given | Untreated | Apical meristem removed | Apical meristem removed and auxin applied to the cut tip | Apical meristem intact but a barrier to the movement of substances was placed under the tip |
Response to treatment given | Growth of apical meristem but not of lateral buds | Growth of lateral buds | No growth of lateral buds | Growth of lateral buds |
1.1 For this investigation, state the: (1)
1.1.1 Independent variable (1)
1.1.2 Dependent variable (2)
1.1.3 Any TWO fixed variables (3)
1.2 Formulate a possible hypothesis for the above investigation. (4)
1.3 Explain the difference in results for Groups 3 and 4. (1)
1.4 Do the results allow you to accept or reject the hypothesis you formulated in QUESTION 1.2? [12]
QUESTION 2
The diagrams below show some stages in an investigation involving germinating bean seeds, kept in an evenly warm, damp environment.
2.1 What physical stimulus leads to the response above? (1)
2.2 Using the information in the diagram and your own knowledge, describe how the tip of the root grows in the direction that it does after two days. (6)
2.3 State TWO functions (other than growth movements and apical dominance) of the hormone responible for the growth movement illustrated above. (2)
2.4 Will the same results be obtained if the investigation is carried out in a dark cupboard? (1)
2.5 Explain your answer to QUESTION 2.4. (2)
2.6 Explain why the cotton wool was kept moist. (2)
[14]
QUESTION 3
Read the passage below and answer the questions that follow.
DIABETES MELLITUS Diabetes mellitus is a disorder relating to the role of insulin. There are two forms of the condition: insulin-dependent diabetes (IDDM) and a non-insulin dependent form (NIDDM). |
The normal plasma glucose level is 100 mg/100 ml. The glucose tolerance test was conducted for three adults and the plasma glucose level (mg/100 ml) was recorded for two hours at 30-minute intervals. The results are shown below.
Time (minutes) | 0 | 30 | 60 | 90 | 120 | |
Plasma glucose levels (mg/100 ml) | Adult 1 | 85 | 125 | 100 | 85 | 80 |
Adult 2 | 130 | 215 | 250 | 260 | 240 | |
Adult 3 | 100 | 210 | 180 | 170 | 160 |
3.1 State how the glucose tolerance response test above is used to decide if a person is suffering from diabetes. (2)
3.2 Adult 1 is not diabetic.
3.2.1 Describe the changes expected in insulin secretion in Adult 1 during the period 30 minutes to 90 minutes after the glucose drink.
3.2.2 Explain your answer to QUESTION 3.2.1. (2)
3.3 Draw two line graphs on the same set of axes to show the glucose tolerance of Adults 1 and 2. (9)
3.4 What was the percentage increase in glucose level when the glucose was at its maximum in Adult 2? Show all working. (3)
3.5 Write down the plasma glucose level of the three adults after two hours as a ratio in simple whole numbers. Show all working. (2)
3.6 Suggest, with reasons, what would happen to insulin secretion for Adult 2:
3.6.1 If the condition was IDDM (2)
3.6.2 If the condition was NIDDM (2)
[24]
TOTAL SECTION A: 50
SECTION B
QUESTION 4
Read the passage and information below and answer the questions that follow.
STIMULUS AND RESPONSE The eagle and the rabbit are dependent for their survival on their nervous system response rate. Their eye, ear and skin sensors send messages along sensory neurons to the central nervous system. The message is transferred by interneurons to provide a response along motor neurons demanding that the muscles move quickly. |
Two learners conducted an investigation in the following way to determine which sense organ sends the message fastest to the brain: the eye, the ear or the skin (sight, hearing, or touch):
The results they obtained are shown in the following table:
Trial number | Distance on meter stick (cm) | ||
Sight | Hearing | Touch | |
1 | 2 | 5 | 10 |
2 | 3 | 6 | 8 |
3 | 2 | 6 | 9 |
Average distance (cm) | 2,3 | X | 9 |
4.1 Name the path that is described in the passage. (2)
4.2 In relation to this path, what term is used to describe each of the following in terms of the role they play?
4.2.1 The muscles (1)
4.2.2 Skin sensors (1)
4.3 Why should you advise the two learners to repeat the procedure more than three times for each investigation? (2)
4.4 Identify the following in their investigation:
4.4.1 The dependent variable (1)
4.4.2 The independent variable (1)
4.5 Calculate the average distance that the meter stick fell when doing the ‘hearing’ investigation. Show all working. (3)
4.6 Study the graph below showing how the distance on the meter stick can be converted to reaction time in milliseconds.
Use the reaction time over distance conversion graph to determine:
4.6.1 The actual reaction time if the meter stick dropped 9 centimetres (2)
4.6.2 The distance the ruler will drop for a reaction time of 400 milliseconds (2)
[15]
QUESTION 5
The graph shows the speed of a nerve impulse along neurons with different diameters, measured in micrometres (μm).
5.1 Describe the relationship between the diameter of a neuron and the speed of an impulse travelling along the neuron. (2)
5.2 Use the graph to estimate how fast an impulse would travel along a neuron with a diameter of 5 μm. (2)
5.3 Name the functional gap found between two neurons across which impulses are transmitted. (1)
5.4 Explain the significance of the myelin sheath that covers the neurons. (2)
5.5 Draw a diagram to illustrate the structure of a motor neuron. Indicate the direction of the impulse by means of an arrow in the diagram. (7)
[14]
QUESTION 6
A person sitting in a darkened room covers one eye. A dim electric bulb, positioned at varying distances from the person, is switched on at one-minute intervals for a period of 9 seconds. During this period the diameter of the pupil of the eye is measured. The results obtained are shown in the table below. Study the table and answer the questions that follow.
Time interval | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 |
Diameter of pupil (mm) | 2 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 8 | 7 | 3 | 1 | 6 |
6.1 Name the structure in the eye that controls the size of the pupil. (1)
6.2 Between which TWO time intervals did the following changes in the diameter of the pupil occur?
6.2.1 Smallest increase (2)
6.2.2 Biggest decrease (2)
6.3 State why the size of the pupil changes from interval 8 to interval 9. (2)
6.4 Describe how the size of the pupil changes from interval 8 to interval 9. (4)
6.5 Why is the response in QUESTION 6.3 referred to as a ‘reflex’? (1)
6.6 What is the significance of this reflex? (1)
6.7 At which time interval was the bulb the furthest from the eye? (1)
6.8 Explain your answer to QUESTION 6.7. (2)
6.9 State TWO ways in which the investigator could ensure that the results of this investigation are reliable. (2)
6.10 State THREE things that must be kept constant in this investigation to ensure that it is valid. (3)
[21]
TOTAL SECTION B: 50
GRAND TOTAL: 100
3.4 Assignment 2 – Reproduction
Topic | Reproduction | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 1, SA 2, SA 3 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 100 | Duration | 90 minutes |
Instructions and information
NOTE: If it is not possible to schedule a single 90-minute session for this assignment, then SECTION A can be done on one day in a 45-minute session and SECTION B the following day in another 45-minute session.
________________________________________________________________________
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
Read the text below and then answer the questions that follow.
REPRODUCTIVE STRATEGIES OF THE BULLFROG Most amphibians spend at least part of their lives in moist surroundings, and their fragile, jelly-like eggs are usually laid in water. |
1.1 State the type of fertilisation (external or internal) that occurs in bullfrogs and describe how it occurs. State whether reproduction in bullfrogs is viviparous, oviparous or ovoviviparous.(3)
1.2 Explain your answer to QUESTION 1.2. (1)
1.3 Describe TWO characteristics of a frog’s egg. (2)
1.4 Give TWO reasons suggested in the article for bullfrog eggs to be laid in water. (2)
1.5 Frog eggs are vulnerable to predators, since there is little or no parental protection. (2)
1.6 Explain THREE strategies that ensure a good survival rate of tadpoles.
[16]
QUESTION 2
The electron micrograph below is that of the human sperm. Study the micrograph and answer the questions that follow.
2.1 Draw a labelled line diagram of the human sperm represented in the electron micrograph. (6)
2.2 Use the scale line provided to calculate the width of the sperm at its widest point. (4)
2.3 Explain THREE ways in which the sperm is structurally suited for its role in fertilisation. (6)
[16]
QUESTION 3
Records of human fertility for the period 1941 to 1990 have shown changes in the sperm counts of normal men. The table below summarises the changing percentages of men with high or low sperm counts over a period of 50 years.
TIME PERIOD | MEN WITH HIGH SPERM COUNTS (%) | MEN WITH LOW SPERM COUNTS (%) |
1941–1950 | 50 | 4 |
1951–1960 | 45 | 5 |
1961–1970 | 28 | 11 |
1971–1980 | 21 | 14 |
1981–1990 | 15 | 18 |
3.1 During which time period was there:
3.1.1 The highest percentage of men with low sperm counts? (1)
3.1.2 The lowest percentage of men with high sperm counts? (1)
3.1.3 The greatest difference between men with high sperm counts and men with low sperm counts? (1)
3.2 Describe the trend for men with low sperm counts, and compare it with those with high sperm counts over the period of 50 years. (2)
3.3 Calculate the percentage increase in men with low sperm counts from 1971 to 1990. (2)
3.4 Suggest TWO reasons for the trend described in QUESTION 3.2. (2)
[9]
QUESTION 4
The table below shows the results of a survey on the use of contraceptives by a sample of women in a rural area.
CONTRACEPTIVE | NUMBER OF WOMEN |
Sterilisation | 34 |
Pill | 38 |
Condom | 22 |
Rhythm method | 30 |
None | 76 |
TOTAL | 200 |
Draw a pie chart to show the results of the survey. Show all working. [9]
TOTAL SECTION A: 50
SECTION B
QUESTION 5
The diagram below shows the changes in the ovary, uterus and level of hormones during a 28-day menstrual cycle. Study the diagram and answer the questions that follow.
5.1 Which hormone is responsible for:
5.1.1 Ovulation (1)
5.1.2 Primary (first) thickening of the endometrium (1)
5.2 According to the graph, on which day(s) does each of the following occur:
5.2.1 Menstruation (1)
5.2.2 Ovulation (1)
5.3 Two structures in the ovaries are responsible for the secretion of two female hormones.
5.3.1 Name the TWO structures and the hormones they secrete. (4)
5.3.2 Give evidence from the graph to support your answer to QUESTION 5.3.1. 4)
5.4 Explain the interaction that occurs between the hormones FSH and progesterone and why it is necessary. (3)
5.5 Is the female, whose cycle is represented in the diagram, pregnant? (1)
5.6 Give TWO reasons from the graph for your answer to QUESTION 5.5. (2)
[18]
QUESTION 6
The table below shows the average human foetal length of males and females over a 40-week gestation period.
Time (weeks) | Foetal length (cm) | |
Male | Female | |
8 | 1 | 1 |
13 | 7 | 7 |
16 | 14 | 13 |
24 | 33 | 31 |
36 | 46 | 43 |
40 | 51 | 49 |
6.1 Draw TWO sets of bar graphs on the same system of axes to compare male and female foetal length over time. (9)
6.2 State TWO conclusions that could be drawn from the results in the graph. (4)
[13]
QUESTION 7
John and Mary have two children. The oldest is Patrick, followed by Anne, a girl. Mary is pregnant again.
7.1 By representing a genetic cross, show the percentage probability of them having another daughter. (7)
7.2 Mary and John’s first child is a haemophiliac and they are afraid that their third child may also have the disorder. Mary is a carrier of haemophilia and John has the normal clotting factor. An ultrasound scan shows that Mary is expecting a girl. (7)
Show, using a genetic cross, the percentage probability of their third child having haemophilia.
7.3 Use the following symbols to construct a simple pedigree diagram showing the inheritance of haemophilia in this family: (5)
[19]
TOTAL SECTION B: 50
3.5 Test – Nucleic acids and meiosis
Topic | Nucleic acids and meiosis | ||
Specific aim(s) | SA 1, SA 3 | Type of activity | Individual |
Marks | 50 | Duration | 60 minutes |
Instructions and information
SECTION A
QUESTION 1
1.1 Various possible options are provided as answers to the following questions. Choose the answer and write only the letter (A–D) next to the question number (1.1.1–1.1.5) in the ANSWER BOOK, for example 1.1.6 D.
1.1.1 All nucleic acids are made up of …
1.1.2 If a DNA molecule contains 20 000 base molecules, of which 20% are cytosine, how many adenine molecules will be present?
1.1.3 DNA replication ensures that all daughter cells formed as a result of …
1.1.4 In individuals with normal haemoglobin, the mRNA for haemoglobin includes the codon GAA. This sequence is changed in individuals with sickle cell anaemia so that their mRNA has a codon GUA at the same location. This suggests that the DNA has undergone a mutation involving a change of base sequence from ...
1.1.5 The result of profiling various DNA samples in a criminal investigation is shown below.
Which conclusion about the crime could the DNA analyst draw?
1.2 Give the correct biological term for each of the following descriptions. Write only the term next to the question number (1.2.1–1.2.4) in the ANSWER BOOK.
1.2.1 Specific lengths of DNA which carry codes for specific characteristics of organisms
1.2.2 The part of protein synthesis taking place in the nucleus
1.2.3 The bonds between the two strands of a DNA molecule
1.2.4 The chromosome condition/ploidy of a somatic cell (4)
1.3 Indicate whether each of the statements in COLUMN I applies to A only, B only, both A and B or none of the items in COLUMN II. Write A only, B only, both A and B, or none next to the question number (1.3.1–1.3.3) in the ANSWER BOOK.
COLUMN I | COLUMN II | ||
1.3.1 | Chromatids separate and move to the poles. | A: B: | Anaphase I Anaphase II |
1.3.2 | The strand of DNA that provides the code during replication. | A: B: | Template Complementary strand |
1.3.3 | Contain bases that are complementary to that of DNA. | A: B: | Codon Anticodon |
(3 x 2) (6)
TOTAL SECTION A: 20
SECTION B
QUESTION 2
Study the diagram below showing a process that takes place in all living cells.
2.1 Identify the process represented in the above diagram. (1)
2.2 Name the specific part of the process mentioned in QUESTION 2.1 that occur at the organelle labelled G. (1)
2.3 Describe the process named in answer to QUESTION 2.2. (5)
2.4 State TWO similarities in structure between molecules B and C. (2)
2.5 The table below indicates the amino acids that are carried by different tRNAs.
tRNA BASES | AMINO ACID | tRNA BASES | AMINO ACID | tRNA BASES | AMINO ACID |
GUU | Glutamine | CUA | Aspartate | GAU | Leucine |
GCG | Arginine | GGU | Proline | UAU | Isoleucine |
CCG | Glycine | ACA | Cysteine | GUG | Histidine |
CUU | Glutamate | AGC | Serine | ACC | Tryptophan |
Identify the amino acids which will be brought to organelle G according to the code provided by the mRNA found on G. (3)
2.6 Write down the triplet of DNA bases that correspond to each of the molecules B, F and H, respectively. (3)
[15]
QUESTION 3
Study the diagrams below that represent different phases of Meiosis I.
3.1 Identify the structures labelled B and E. (2)
3.2 State TWO functions of the structure labelled F. (2)
3.3 Describe the process shown at A in Diagram I. (2)
3.4 Tabulate TWO ways in which a cell in the phase shown in Diagram II would differ from a cell in the same phase in Meiosis II. (5)
3.5 How many chromosomes will be present in each cell at the end of meiosis? (1)
3.6 If the above cell division occurred in a human being, describe the events leading to the formation of an offspring with Down syndrome. (3)
[15]
TOTAL SECTION B: 30
GRAND TOTAL: 50
GEOGRAPHY
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
LEARNER GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENTS | PAGE | |||
1 | Introduction | 3 | ||
2 | Objectives/Aims of the project | 3 | ||
3 | Assessment tasks as outlined by CAPS | 3 | ||
4 | Assessment tasks | 4 | ||
4.1 | Term 1 – Data-handling task | 4 | ||
4.1.1 | Exemplar: Data-handling task 1 | 4 | ||
4.1.2 | Exemplar: Data-handling task 2 | 8 | ||
4.2 | Term 2 – Research task | 12 | ||
4.2.1 | Learner guidelines for conducting research | 12 | ||
4.2.2 | Guidelines for research | 12 | ||
4.2.3 | Compiling a bibliography for a research task | 15 | ||
4.2.4 | Proposed cover page for a research task | 17 | ||
4.2.5 | Exemplar: Research task 1 | 18 | ||
4.2.6 | Exemplar: Research task 2 | 20 | ||
4.2.7 | Proposed marking rubric for a research task | 22 | ||
5 | Conclusion | 25 |
1. Introduction
The purpose of this document is to provide learners with a set of benchmarked school- based assessment tasks (SBAs). It contains useful information and guidelines in the form of exemplars on the following aspects of the curriculum:
2. Objectives/Aims of the project
It is envisaged that this SBA document will provide learners with examples of SBA tasks that are of high quality and a high standard.
3. Assessment tasks as outlined by CAPS
Term 1 | Term 2 | Term 3 | Term 4 |
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
SBA mark which comprises 25% of final mark (100 marks) | 75% of final mark (300 marks) |
Term | Task | Total | SBA weight | Total | |
1 | Data handling | 60 | 20 | 100 (25%) | |
Standardised test | 100 | 10 | |||
2 | Mapwork task | 60 | 20 | ||
June Paper 1 | 200 | 300 | 10 | ||
June Paper 2 | 100 | ||||
3 | Research/Essay writing task | 60 | 20 | ||
Standardised test | 100 | 10 | |||
Trial Paper 1 | 225 | 300 | 10 | ||
Trial Paper 2 | 75 | ||||
4 | External Paper 1 | 225 | 300 | 300 (75%) | |
External Paper 2 | 75 |
4. Assessment tasks
4.1 Term 1 – Data-handling task
Two examples of typical data-handling tasks are provided below.
4.1.1 Exemplar: Data-handling task 1
GRADE 12 SBA (CAPS 2014)
DATA-HANDLING TASK
PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY
TIME: 1 hour (60 minutes)
MARKS: 60
QUESTION 1
1.1 Refer to FIGURE 1A showing a synoptic weather map of Tropical Cyclone Irina.
1.1.1 Determine the number of tropical cyclones, including Irina, that has occurred during this tropical cyclone season. (1 x 2) (2)
1.1.2 Give a reason to support your answer to QUESTION 1.1.1. (1 x 2) (2)
1.1.3 Describe the surface air circulation within Tropical Cyclone Irina. (1 x 2) (2)
1.2 Refer to FIGURE 1B showing a satellite image of Tropical Cyclone Irina and FIGURE 1C showing the projected path of Tropical Cyclone Irina.
1.2.1 Using the satellite image, determine in which stage of development Tropical Cyclone Irina is. (1 x 2) (2)
1.2.2 Give evidence from the satellite image to support your answer to QUESTION 1.2.1 (1 x 2) (2)
1.2.3 Discuss TWO socio-economic impacts of Tropical Cyclone Irina on areas along the east coast of southern Africa. (2 x 2) (4)
1.2.4 Draw a labelled cross-section of Tropical Cyclone Irina as depicted on the satellite image from X to Y. Clearly indicate the position of the eye and the cumulonimbus clouds on your cross-section. (2 x 2) (4)
1.2.5 State the reason for the use of the words, ‘projected path’ when describing the path of Tropical Cyclone Irina. (1 x 2) (2)
1.3 Refer to FIGURE 1A.
1.3.1 Identify the high-pressure cells labelled P and Q. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3.2 Use evidence from the map to explain whether wind speed will be greater in area P or area Q. (3 x 2) (6)
[30]
QUESTION 2
2.1 Refer to FIGURE 2A showing cross-sections of the Tugela River along its course in its drainage basin shown in FIGURE 2B.
2.1.1 Define the term drainage basin. (1 x 2) (2)
2.1.2 Which of FIGURE 2A and FIGURE 2B shows a longitudinal and transverse profile respectively? (2 x 2) (4)
2.1.3 Match each of cross-sections A, B and C (FIGURE 2A) with positions (i), (ii) and (iii) (FIGURE 2B). (3 x 2) (6)
2.1.4 Briefly explain the difference in the width of the river channel at A and C. (2 x 2) (4)
2.2 Refer to FIGURE 2B showing the drainage basin of the Tugela River from its upper to the middle to the lower course.
2.2.1 Determine the stream order of the Tugela River at point X along its course. 1 x 2) (2)
2.2.2 Identify and explain ONE of the stream channel patterns of the Tugela River at (ii) along its course. (3 x 2) (6)
2.2.3 Draw a labelled free-hand cross-section through the river channel along line T–S, showing the position of and the difference in shape between a slip-off slope and an undercut slope. (2 x 2) (4)
2.2.4 Give ONE reason why the Tugela River is more likely to flood in the vicinity of (iii). (1 x 2) (2)
[30]
GRAND TOTAL: 60
FIGURE 1A: TROPICAL CYCLONE IRINA
FIGURE 2A: CROSS-SECTIONS OF THE TUGELA RIVER ALONG VARIOUS POINTS
FIGURE 2B: SCHEMATIC PLAN VIEW OF THE DRAINAGE BASIN OF THE TUGELA RIVER
4.1.2 Exemplar: Data-handling task 2
GRADE 12 SBA (CAPS 2014)
DATA-HANDLING TASK
PEOPLE AND THEIR NEEDS
TIME: 1 hour (60 minutes)
MARKS: 60
QUESTION 1
1.1 Refer to FIGURES 1A and 1B and answer the questions that follow.
1.1.1 Define the following terms:
1.2 Identify the largest and the smallest contributor to the South African GDP. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3 Use FIGURE 1B to describe the trend of the South African GDP from 2010 to 2012. (1 x 2) (2)
1.4 How will the trend mentioned in QUESTION 1.3 affect South Africa’s Balance of Trade? (1 x 2) (2)
1.5 Which economic activity (primary, secondary or tertiary) in FIGURE 1A accounts for the existing trend mentioned in QUESTION 1.3? (1 x 2) (2)
1.6 Discuss the relationship between the percentage contributed by agriculture to the South African GDP and food security in the country. (2 x 2) (4)
1.7 FIGURE 1A indicates that the agricultural sector contributes a very small percentage to the GDP. Write a short paragraph (approximately 12 lines) in which you account for the small contribution of the agricultural sector to the South African GDP. (6 x 2) (12)
[30]
QUESTION 2 | ||
Refer to FIGURE 2 before answering the questions below. | ||
2.1 | Write down the correct names for the industrial areas marked B and D. (2 x 2) | (4) |
2.2 | Identify the largest of the four industrial areas visible in FIGURE 2. (1 x 2) | (2) |
2.3 Explain any TWO factors that have led to the growth and development of the industrial area referred to in QUESTION 2.2. (2 x 2) (4)
[10]
QUESTION 3
Refer to FIGURE 3 before answering the questions below.
3.1 What is an IDZ? (1 x 2) (2)
3.2 Name the province in which the Coega IDZ is located. (1 x 2) (2)
3.3 Briefly describe TWO aims for the development of the Coega IDZ. (2 x 2) (4)
3.4 As a manufacturer of heavy earth-moving equipment for sale in Asia, explain what would encourage you to open a factory in the Coega IDZ. (2 x 2) (4)
3.5 Suppose you are a South African government official responsible for economic development. State FOUR incen tives you would use to attract foreign investors to the Coega IDZ. (4 x 2) (8)
[20]
GRAND TOTAL: 60
FIGURE 1A: PERCENTAGE CONTRIBUTION OF MAIN SECTORS TO THE GDP Electricity
FIGURE 1B: SOUTH AFRICAN GDP
FIGURE 2: INDUSTRY AND MINING IN SOUTH AFRICA
Industry And Mining |
FIGURE 3: COEGA IDZ
THE COEGA INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT ZONE The Coega Development Corporation (CDC) is a state-owned entity formed in 1999. It was mandated to develop and operate the Coega Industrial Development Zone (IDZ), which is located adjacent to the modern deep-water port facility, Port of Ngqura. |
4.2 Term 3 – Research task
Two examples of typical research tasks are provided below.
4.2.1 Learner guidelines for conducting research
Research framework for assessment (Guideline on administration of research task)
RESEARCH ACTIVITIES | STEPS | MARKS | LENGTH | TIMEFRAME |
Formulate the hypothesis/Problem statement | 1 | 5 | 50 words No more than | One week |
Background information about the study area | 2 | 6 | 75 to 100 words | |
Mapping | 3 | 5 | A4 size or smaller | |
Data collection | 4 | 6 | 75 to 100 words | Two weeks |
Analysis and synthesis of data | 5 | 15 | 300 to 450 words | One week |
Recommendations and possible solutions | 6 | 6 | 75 to 100 words | |
Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis | 7 | 5 | 50 words No more than | One week |
Bibliography | 8 | 4 | ||
Cover page | 3 | |||
Presentation | 5 | |||
TOTAL | 60 | |||
Submission | 9 | Due date |
In choosing a topic for research, isolate topics in specific areas in the Geography CAPS content that you have studied in Grade 12.
4.2.2 Guidelines for research
Research Task
Step 1: Formulating a hypothesis/problem statement
As Geographers we seek to understand and explain the interactions amongst humans, and between humans and the environment in space and time. This is achieved by asking questions or making informed geographical decisions. This entails the development of a hypothesis or a problem statement to be tested.
A possible hypothesis in Settlement Geography: Rural-urban migration
A possible hypothesis in Geomorphology: Catchment and river management
Other possible hypothesis-type research examples:
Step 2: Background information about an area of study
Step 3: Mapping
Step 4: Methods of data collection
Step 5: Analysis and synthesis of data
Step 6: Recommendations and possible solutions
Step 7: Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis
Step 8: Bibliography
Step 9: Submission
4.2.3 Compiling a bibliography for a research task
4.2.4 Proposed cover page for a research task
NAME OF SCHOOL | |
NAME OF LEARNER | |
SUBJECT | |
RESEARCH TOPIC | |
CURRICULUM CONTENT | |
Design cover suitable for research topic and place here
|
STATEMENT OF AUTHENTICITY
I hereby declare that ALL pieces of writing contained in this research task are my own original work and that if I made use of any source, I have duly acknowledged it.
Learner’s signature: __________________________________ Date: _____________
4.2.5 Exemplar: Research task 1
CRIME IN THE INNER CITY South African cities attract thousands of new residents every year in search of work and a better life. The housing shortage, along with a shortage of housing subsidies, means that for many South Africans there is no alternative but to live in informal housing and shack settlements. The rapid increase in informal settlements around the cities in South Africa has resulted in an increase in crime rates in the inner city. |
Compile your research by completing the activities outlined below.
Step 1: Formulate the hypothesis/problem statement
Step 2: Background information about the study area
Give a brief introduction and description (background information) of the city (study area) you have selected in terms of:
Step 3: Mapping
Step 4: Data collection
Collect data using at least THREE methods, for example:
Step 5: Analysis and synthesis of data
Step 6: Recommendations and solutions
Step 7: Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis
Step 8: Bibliography
Step 9: Submission
4.2.6 Exemplar: Research task 2
THE IMPACT OF HUMAN ACTIVITIES ON RIVERS Rivers obtain water from surface run-off and ground water of their drainage basins. Activities taking place in the drainage basin affect the quality of water in the river. |
Choose a river close to your school or where you live as an area of study, and conduct your research by following the steps outlined below.
Step 1: Formulate the hypothesis/problem statement
Human activities impact negatively on the quality of water and the flow pattern in the upper reaches/course of the Blood River in Limpopo. |
Step 2: Background information about the river under study
Step 3: Mapping
Step 4: Data collection
Collect data using at least THREE methods, for example:
Step 5: Analysis and synthesis of data
Step 6: Recommendations and solutions
Step 7: Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis
Step 8: Bibliography
Step 9: Submission
4.2.7 Proposed marking rubric for a research task
NAME OF LEARNER: _________________________________________________________GRADE: __________
CURRICULUM TOPIC: __________________________________________________________________________
RESEARCH TOPIC: __________________________________________________________________________
MARK
| 1 | 2–3 | 4–5 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 1
|
|
|
| |||||
MARK
| 1 | 2–3 | 3–4 | 5–6 | Educator Mark | Moderator Mark | ||
Step 2
|
|
|
|
| ||||
MARK
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Educator Mark | Moderator Mark | |
Step 3 |
|
. |
|
|
| |||
MARK | 1 | 2–3 | 4–5 | 6 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | ||
Step 4 Data collection |
|
|
|
| ||||
MARK | 1–3 | 4–6 | 7–9 | 10–12 | 13–15 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |
Step 5 Analysis and synthesis of data |
|
|
|
|
| |||
MARK | 1 | 2–3 | 4–5 | 6 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | ||
Step 6 Recommendations and solutions |
|
|
|
| ||||
MARK | 0 | 1–3 | 4–5 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 7 Conclusion |
|
|
| |||||
MARK | 0 | 1–3 | 4 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 8 Bibliography |
|
|
| |||||
MARK | 0 | 1–2 | 3 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 9 Cover page |
|
|
| |||||
MARK | 1–4 | 5 | 5 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 10 Presentation |
|
|
| |||||
Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||||||
TOTAL: 60 | ||||||||
SBA MARK: 60 ÷ 3 = 20 |
EDUCATOR NAME: ______________________________DATE OF ASSESSMENT: __________________
MODERATOR NAME: ______________________________DATE OF MODERATION: __________________
5. CONCLUSION
This document provides you with a framework to develop your own research task. It also provides you with a framework of expectancy for data-handling tasks. The framework for data-handling tasks can also be used to prepare for external examinations where data-handling-type questions can be asked.
A clear guideline has been developed on how to conduct research. This guideline can be applied to any topic within the CAPS in which you wish to conduct research. The marking rubric that has been included will also provide you with a clear guide on the time that should be spent on the various phases of doing research.
The high standard of these tasks will provide a platform for you to develop skills such as research, interpretation of resources, integration of resources and graphs, all skills required for the final external Geography examination. These are also skills that can be put to use at a later stage in your life.
GEOGRAPHY
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
TEACHER'S GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENTS | ||||
1 | Introduction | 3 | ||
2 | Objectives/Aims of the project | 4 | ||
3 | Assessment tasks as outlined by CAPS | 5 | ||
4 | Programme of assessment tasks | 6 | ||
4.1 | Types of tasks | 6 | ||
4.2 | Compliance with CAPS requirements | 6 | ||
4.3 | Assessment of skills | 6 | ||
4.4 | Guidelines for research tasks | 7 | ||
4.4.1 | Teachers’ guidelines for conducting research | 7 | ||
4.4.2 | Guidelines for research | 7 | ||
4.4.3 | Compiling a bibliography for a research task | 10 | ||
4.4.4 | Proposed cover page for a research task | 11 | ||
5 | Quality assurance processes followed | 12 | ||
6 | Assessment tasks | 12 | ||
6.1 | Research tasks | 12 | ||
6.1.1 | Exemplar: Research task 1 | 12 | ||
6.1.2 | Exemplar: Research task 2 | 14 | ||
6.1.3 | Proposed marking rubric for research tasks | 16 | ||
6.2 | Data-handling tasks | 20 | ||
6.2.1 | Exemplar: Data-handling task 1 | 19 | ||
6.2.2 | Exemplar: Data-handling task 2 | 23 | ||
6.2.3 | Marking memoranda/Guidelines for data-handling tasks | 27 | ||
7 | Conclusion | 31 |
1. Introduction
Assessment is a continuous planned process of identifying, gathering and interpreting information about the performance of learners, using various forms of assessment. It involves four steps: generating and collecting evidence of achievement; evaluating this evidence; recording the findings and using this information to understand and assist with the learners’ development to improve the process of learning and teaching. Assessment should be both informal (assessment for learning) and formal (assessment of learning). In both cases regular feedback should be provided to learners to enhance the learning experience.
School-based assessment (SBA) is a purposive collection of learners’ work that tells the story of learners’ efforts, progress or achievement in given areas. The quality of SBA tasks is integral to learners’ preparation for the final examinations. This booklet serves as a resource of four exemplar SBA tasks to schools and subject teachers of Geography. SBA marks are formally recorded by the teacher for progression and certification purposes. The SBA component is compulsory for all learners. Learners who cannot comply with the requirements specified according to the policy may not be eligible to enter for the subject in the final examination.
The formal assessment tasks provide the teacher with a systematic way of evaluating how well learners are progressing. This publication includes tests, a project and a case study. Formal assessment tasks form part of a year-long formal programme of assessment. These tasks should not be taken lightly and learners should be encouraged to submit their best possible efforts for final assessment.
The teachers are expected to ensure that assessment tasks are relevant to and suitable for the learners being taught. Teachers should adapt the tasks to suit learners’ level of understanding and should be context-bound; however, they should also take cognisance of the requirements as set out in the Curriculum and Assessment Policy Statement (CAPS) document.
This publication comprises four tasks that address the demands of the Grade 12 Geography curriculum. It is expected that these tasks will serve as a valuable resource to:
2. Objectives/Aims of the project
The distinctive characteristics of SBA (and its strengths as a relatively small component of a coherent assessment system) have implications for its design and implementation, in particular the nature of the assessment tasks and the role of the teacher in standardisation procedures. These implications are summarised as follows:
Teachers should ensure that learners understand the assessment criteria and their relevance for self- and peer assessment. Teachers should also use these criteria for informal assessment and teaching purposes before they conduct any formal assessment, so that they are familiar with the criteria and the assessment process.
The project provides exemplar tasks that are aimed at:
3. Assessment tasks as outlined by CAPS
Term 1 | Term 2 | Term 3 | Term 4 |
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
SBA mark which comprises 25% of final mark (100 marks) | 75% of final mark (300 marks) |
Term | Task | Total | SBA weight | Total | |
1 | Data handling | 60 | 20 | 100 (25%) | |
Standardised test | 100 | 10 | |||
2 | Mapwork task | 60 | 20 | ||
June Paper 1 | 200 | 300 | 10 | ||
June Paper 2 | 100 | ||||
3 | Research/Essay writing task | 60 | 20 | ||
Standardised test | 100 | 10 | |||
Trial Paper 1 | 225 | 300 | 10 | ||
Trial Paper 2 | 75 | ||||
4 | External Paper 1 | 225 | 300 | 300 (75%) | |
External Paper 2 | 75 |
4. Programme of assessment tasks
4.1 Types of tasks
4.2 Compliance with CAPS requirements
The types of tasks and number of tasks are fully compliant with CAPS. Compliancy is outlined under point 3. The content covered by each of these tasks is indicated with each task. The content covered by each task is included in the curriculum and may be tested in any external examination.
4.3 Assessment of skills
The following skills are assessed. Some/All of these skills may be tested in any external examination.
4.4 Guidelines for research tasks
4.4.1 Teachers’ guidelines for conducting research
Research framework for assessment (Guideline on administration of research task)
RESEARCH ACTIVITIES | STEPS | MARKS | LENGTH | TIMEFRAME |
Formulate the hypothesis | 1 | 5 | No more than 50 words | One week |
Background information about the study area | 2 | 6 | A4 size or smaller | |
Mapping | 3 | 5 | 75 to 100 words | |
Data collection | 4 | 6 | 75 to 100 words | Two weeks |
Analysis and synthesis of data | 5 | 15 | 300 to 450 words | One week |
Recommendations and possible solutions | 6 | 6 | 75 to 100 words | |
Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis | 7 | 5 | No more than 50 words | One week |
Bibliography | 8 | 4 | ||
Cover page | 3 | |||
Presentation | 5 | |||
TOTAL | 60 | |||
Submission | 9 | Due date |
In choosing a topic for research, isolate topics in specific areas in the Geography NCS/CAPS content, for example human-environment interactions.
4.4.2 Guidelines for research
Research Task
Step 1: Formulating a hypothesis/problem statement
As Geographers we seek to understand and explain the interactions amongst humans, and between humans and the environment in space and time. This is achieved by asking questions or making informed geographical decisions. This entails the development of a hypothesis or a problem statement to be tested.
A possible hypothesis in Settlement Geography: Rural-urban migration
A possible hypothesis in Geomorphology: Catchment and river management
Other possible hypothesis-type research examples:
Step 2: Background information about an area of study
Step 3: Mapping
Step 4: Methods of data collection
Step 5: Analysis and synthesis of data
Step 6: Recommendations and possible solutions
Step 7: Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis
Step 8: Bibliography
Step 9: Submission
4.4.3 Compiling a bibliography for a research task
4.4.4 Proposed cover page for a research task
NAME OF SCHOOL | |
NAME OF LEARNER | |
SUBJECT | |
RESEARCH TOPIC | |
CURRICULUM CONTENT | |
Design cover suitable for research topic and place here
|
STATEMENT OF AUTHENTICITY
I hereby declare that ALL pieces of writing contained in this research task are my own original work and that if I made use of any source, I have duly acknowledged it.
Learner’s signature: __________________________________ Date: _____________
5. Quality assurance processes followed
A team of subject/curriculum experts were selected by the Department of Basic Education. This team met and compiled a set of research tasks and data-handling tasks. These tasks were set in such a way that they would be suitable to use for the CAPS. On completion of the setting of these tasks, all tasks were moderated and adjusted accordingly. Once the moderation and adjustments had been completed, a panel consisting of national examiners and internal moderators was compiled to ensure that the quality of the tasks met all the requirements for the CAPS.
6. Assessment tasks
6.1 Research tasks
6.1.1 Exemplar: Research task 1
CRIME IN THE INNER CITY South African cities attract thousands of new residents every year in search of work and a better life. The housing shortage, along with a shortage of housing subsidies, means that for many South Africans there is no alternative but to live in informal housing and shack settlements. The rapid increase in informal settlements around the cities in South Africa has resulted in an increase in crime rates in the inner city. |
Step 1: Formulate the hypothesis/problem statement
The increasing number of informal settlements (choose localised informal settlement) in and around urban areas in South Africa has resulted in higher crime rates within the inner city due to higher unemployment. (Focus: More people in surrounding informal settlements result in unemployment causing people to turn to crime.) |
Step 2: Background information about the study area
Give a brief introduction and description (background information) of the city (study area) you have selected in terms of:
Step 3: Mapping
Step 4: Data collection
Collect data using at least THREE methods, for example:
Step 5: Analysis and synthesis of data
Step 6: Recommendations and solutions
Step 7: Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis
Step 8: Bibliography
Step 9: Submission
6.1.2 Exemplar: Research task 2
THE IMPACT OF HUMAN ACTIVITIES ON RIVERS Rivers obtain water from surface run-off and ground water of their drainage basins. Activities taking place in the drainage basin affect the quality of water in the river. |
Choose a river close to your school or where you live as an area of study, and conduct your research by following the steps outlined below.
Step 1: Formulate the hypothesis/problem statement
Human activities impact negatively on the quality of water and the flow pattern in the upper reaches/course of the Blood River in Limpopo. |
Step 2: Background information about the river under study
Step 3: Mapping
Step 4: Data collection
Collect data using at least THREE methods, for example:
Step 5: Analysis and synthesis of data
Step 6: Recommendations and solutions
Step 7: Conclusion – accept or reject the hypothesis
Step 8: Bibliography
Step 9: Submission
6.1.3 Proposed marking rubric for research tasks
NAME OF LEARNER: _________________________________________________________GRADE: __________
CURRICULUM TOPIC: __________________________________________________________________________
RESEARCH TOPIC: __________________________________________________________________________
MARK
| 1 | 2–3 | 4–5 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 1
|
|
|
| |||||
MARK
| 1 | 2–3 | 3–4 | 5–6 | Educator Mark | Moderator Mark | ||
Step 2
|
|
|
|
| ||||
MARK
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Educator Mark | Moderator Mark | |
Step 3 |
|
. |
|
|
| |||
MARK | 1 | 2–3 | 4–5 | 6 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | ||
Step 4 Data collection |
|
|
|
| ||||
MARK | 1–3 | 4–6 | 7–9 | 10–12 | 13–15 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |
Step 5 Analysis and synthesis of data |
|
|
|
|
| |||
MARK | 1 | 2–3 | 4–5 | 6 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | ||
Step 6 Recommendations and solutions |
|
|
|
| ||||
MARK | 0 | 1–3 | 4–5 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 7 Conclusion |
|
|
| |||||
MARK | 0 | 1–3 | 4 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 8 Bibliography |
|
|
| |||||
MARK | 0 | 1–2 | 3 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 9 Cover page |
|
|
| |||||
MARK | 1–4 | 5 | 5 | Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||
Step 10 Presentation |
|
|
| |||||
Teacher Mark | Moderator Mark | |||||||
TOTAL: 60 | ||||||||
SBA MARK: 60 ÷ 3 = 20 |
TEACHER NAME: ______________________________DATE OF ASSESSMENT: __________________
MODERATOR NAME: ______________________________DATE OF MODERATION: __________________
6.2 Data-handling tasks
6.2.1 Exemplar: Data-handling task 1
GRADE 12 SBA (CAPS 2014)
DATA-HANDLING TASK
PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY
TIME: 1 hour (60 minutes)
MARKS: 60
QUESTION 1
1.1 Refer to FIGURE 1A showing a synoptic weather map of Tropical Cyclone Irina.
1.1.1 Determine the number of tropical cyclones, including Irina, that has occurred during this tropical cyclone season. (1 x 2) (2)
1.1.2 Give a reason to support your answer to QUESTION 1.1.1. (1 x 2) (2)
1.1.3 Describe the surface air circulation within Tropical Cyclone Irina. (1 x 2) (2)
1.2 Refer to FIGURE 1B showing a satellite image of Tropical Cyclone Irina and FIGURE 1C showing the projected path of Tropical Cyclone Irina.
1.2.1 Using the satellite image, determine in which stage of development Tropical Cyclone Irina is. (1 x 2) (2)
1.2.2 Give evidence from the satellite image to support your answer to QUESTION 1.2.1 . (1 x 2) (2)
1.2.3 Discuss TWO socio-economic impacts of Tropical Cyclone Irina on areas along the east coast of southern Africa. (2 x 2) (4)
1.2.4 Draw a labelled cross-section of Tropical Cyclone Irina as depicted on the satellite image from X to Y. Clearly indicate the position of the eye and the cumulonimbus clouds on your cross-section. (2 x 2) (4)
1.2.5 State the reason for the use of the words, ‘projected path’ when describing the path of Tropical Cyclone Irina. (1 x 2) (2)
1.3 Refer to FIGURE 1A.
1.3.1 Identify the high-pressure cells labelled P and Q. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3.2 Use evidence from the map to explain whether wind speed will be greater in area P or area Q. (3 x 2) (6)
[30]
QUESTION 2
2.1 Refer to FIGURE 2A showing cross-sections of the Tugela River along its course in its drainage basin shown in FIGURE 2B.
2.1.1 Define the term drainage basin. (1 x 2) (2)
2.1.2 Which of FIGURE 2A and FIGURE 2B shows a longitudinal and transverse profile respectively? (2 x 2) (4)
2.1.3 Match each of cross-sections A, B and C (FIGURE 2A) with positions (i), (ii) and (iii) (FIGURE 2B). (3 x 2) (6)
2.1.4 Briefly explain the difference in the width of the river channel at A and C. (2 x 2) (4)
2.2 Refer to FIGURE 2B showing the drainage basin of the Tugela River from its upper to the middle to the lower course.
2.2.1 Determine the stream order of the Tugela River at point X along its course. (1 x 2) (2)
2.2.2 Identify and explain ONE of the stream channel patterns of the Tugela River at (ii) along its course. (3 x 2) (6)
2.2.3 Draw a labelled free-hand cross-section through the river channel along line T–S, showing the position of and the difference in shape between a slip-off slope and an undercut slope. (2 x 2) (4)
2.2.4 Give ONE reason why the Tugela River is more likely to flood in the vicinity of (iii). (1 x 2) (2)
[30]
GRAND TOTAL: 60
FIGURE 1A: TROPICAL CYCLONE IRINA
FIGURE 2A: CROSS-SECTIONS OF THE TUGELA RIVER ALONG VARIOUS POINTS
FIGURE 2B: SCHEMATIC PLAN VIEW OF THE DRAINAGE BASIN OF THE TUGELA RIVER
6.2.2 Exemplar: Data-handling task 2
GRADE 12 SBA (CAPS 2014)
DATA-HANDLING TASK
PEOPLE AND THEIR NEEDS
TIME: 1 hour (60 minutes)
MARKS: 60
QUESTION 1
1.1 Refer to FIGURES 1A and 1B and answer the questions that follow.
1.1.1 Define the following terms:
1.2 Identify the largest and the smallest contributor to the South African GDP. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3 Use FIGURE 1B to describe the trend of the South African GDP from 2010 to 2012. (1 x 2) (2)
1.4 How will the trend mentioned in QUESTION 1.3 affect South Africa’s Balance of Trade? (1 x 2) (2)
1.5 Which economic activity (primary, secondary or tertiary) in FIGURE 1A accounts for the existing trend mentioned in QUESTION 1.3? (1 x 2) (2)
1.6 Discuss the relationship between the percentage contributed by agriculture to the South African GDP and food security in the country. (2 x 2) (4)
1.7 FIGURE 1A indicates that the agricultural sector contributes a very small percentage to the GDP.
Write a short paragraph (approximately 12 lines) in which you account for the small contribution of the agricultural sector to the South African GDP. (6 x 2) (12)
[30]
QUESTION 2
Refer to FIGURE 2 before answering the questions below.
2.1 Write down the correct names for the industrial areas marked B and D. (2 x 2) (4)
2.2 Identify the largest of the four industrial areas visible in FIGURE 2. (1 x 2) (2)
2.3 Explain any TWO factors that have led to the growth and development of the industrial area referred to in QUESTION 2.2. (2 x 2) (4) [10]
QUESTION 3
Refer to FIGURE 3 before answering the questions below.
3.1 What is an IDZ? (1 x 2) (2)
3.2 Name the province in which the Coega IDZ is located. (1 x 2) (2)
3.3 Briefly describe TWO aims for the development of the Coega IDZ. (2 x 2) (4)
3.4 As a manufacturer of heavy earth-moving equipment for sale in Asia, explain what would encourage you to open a factory in the Coega IDZ. (2 x 2) (4)
3.5 Suppose you are a South African government official responsible for economic development. State FOUR incentives you would use to attract foreign investors to the Coega IDZ. (4 x 2) (8)
[20]
GRAND TOTAL: 60
FIGURE 1A: PERCENTAGE CONTRIBUTION OF MAIN SECTORS TO THE GDP
FIGURE 1B: SOUTH AFRICAN GDP
FIGURE 2: INDUSTRY AND MINING IN SOUTH AFRICA
Industry And Mining |
FIGURE 3: COEGA IDZ
THE COEGA INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT ZONE The Coega Development Corporation (CDC) is a state-owned entity formed in 1999. It was mandated to develop and operate the Coega Industrial Development Zone (IDZ), which is located adjacent to the modern deep-water port facility, Port of Ngqura. |
6.2.3 Marking memoranda/Guidelines for data-handling tasks
MEMORANDUM – Data-handling task 1
TIME: 1 hour (60 minutes)
MARKS: 60
QUESTION 1
1.1
1.1.1 9 cyclones (2) 1x2 (2)
1.1.2 Tropical cyclones are named alphabetically - ‘I’ is the 9th letter of the alphabet (2) 1x2 (2)
1.1.3 Surface circulation is in a clockwise direction (2) 1x2 (2)
1.2
1.2.1 Mature stage (2) 1x2 (2)
1.2.2
The extent/diameter of the cloud cover is large (2)
The cyclone is still approaching the land (2)
Situated over warm ocean (2)
[Any ONE] 1x2 (2)
1.2.3
Damage to transportation networks (2)
Damage to buildings (2)
Loss of life (2)
Disruption of communication networks (2)
Destruction of topsoil/soil erosion (2)
Crops destroyed (2)
Livestock drowned (2)
Decrease in economic activities (2)
Disruption in exporting and importing activities at the harbour (2)
Drop in food security (2)
Increase in food insecurity (2)
Outbreak of waterborne diseases (2)
[Any TWO. Accept other reasonable answers] 2x2 (4)
1.2.4 2x2 (4)
1.2.5 A tropical cyclone follows an erratic path and therefore it is difficult to predetermine its exact path (2) [Concept] 1x2 (2)
1.3
1.3.1
P - South Atlantic/St Helena High Pressure Cell (2)
Q – South Indian/Mauritius High Pressure Cell (2) 2x2 (4)
1.3.2 P (2)
Steeper pressure gradient/isobars closely spaced (2)
The steeper the pressure gradient the stronger the winds (2) 3x2 (6) [30]
QUESTION 2
2.1
2.1.1 The total area drained by a river system and all its tributaries (2)
[Concept] 1x2 (2)
2.1.2
2A - transverse profile (2)
2B - longitudinal profile (2) 2x2 (4)
2.1.3
A - (i) (2)
B - (ii) (2)
C - (iii) (2) 3x2 (6)
2.1.4
A - mainly downward erosion therefore narrow river channel (2)
C - river weaves from side to side thus lateral erosion and wide river channel (2) 2x2 (4)
2.2
2.2.1 3rd order stream 1x2 (2)
2.2.2
Meandering stream channel pattern (2)
The gradient becomes gentle and there is a reduction in the velocity of the river (2)
To overcome excess energy, stream starts weaving from side to side (2)
[Any ONE reason]
OR
Braided stream channel pattern (2)
The gradient becomes gentle and there is a reduction in the velocity of the river (2)
The river deposit sediments on the riverbed and the water flows around the deposited material (2)
[Any ONE reason] 2x2 (4)
2.2.3
T - slip-off ✔✔ S - undercut ✔✔
T must be on left
S must be on right
Shape of two slopes must be correct 2x2 (4)
2.2.4
River shallow due to deposition and water will overflow easily (2)
Wide, flat floodplain allows overflowing water to spread easily (2)
Large volume of water that cannot be contained by the river channel (2)
[Any ONE] 1x2 (2)
[30]
GRAND TOTAL: 60
MEMORANDUM – Data-handling task 2
TIME: 1 hour (60 minutes)
MARKS: 60
QUESTION 1
1.1.1 The total value of goods and service produced in a country in one year. [Concept] 1x2 (2)
1.1.2 Balance of Trade refers to the difference between the value of imports and exports of goods produced in a country/Value of exports minus imports in a country (2)
[Concept] 1x2 (2)
1.2 Largest - Wholesale and retail trade, hotel and restaurants (2) Smallest - Electricity (2) 2x2 (4)
1.3 Increasing trend/upward trend/economic improvement (2) 1x2 (2)
1.4 Positive Balance of Trade/Positive Trade Balance (2) 1x2 (2)
1.5 Tertiary Activities/Services (2) 1x2 (2)
1.6
Low agricultural production means there will be less food produced (2)
This will lead to a shortage of food (2)
Food security is threatened/food Insecurity (2)
[Any TWO] 2x2 (4)
1.7
Low and unreliable South African rainfall (2)
Soil quality is generally poor in South Africa (2)
High frequency of drought (2)
Hail that often occurs in the Highveld impacts negatively on crop production (2)
Dual agricultural system/existence of subsistence and commercial farmers (2)
Fluctuating prices of agricultural products both locally and internationally (2)
High prevalence of HIV/Aids lowers production on farms (2)
Pests and insects destroy crops and fruit (2)
Growing importance of secondary sector (2)
Greater income from exporting processed goods (2)
Growing importance of tertiary sector (2)
[Any SIX. Accept any other reasonable answer] (6x2) (12) [30]
QUESTION 2
2.1
B - EThekwini metropolitan region/Durban-Pinetown region (2)
D - South-Western Cape region (2) 2x2 (4)
2.2 Gauteng Industrial Region/PWV (2) 1x2 (2)
2.3
Market - Large cities and towns in the region form markets for manufactured goods (2) Ever-increasing population in the region forms excellent market for locally manufactured goods (2)
Transport - Good transport system connects Gauteng Industrial region to various sources of raw materials and harbours to facilitate exports and imports (2)
Raw materials - Large deposits of minerals stimulate the development of industries in this area (2)
Power - Available coal in Gauteng and Mpumalanga used to generate electricity (2) Easy access to power produced by ESKOM attracted many industries to the region (2)
Water - Availability of water from water transfer schemes much needed by industries (2)
[Any TWO. Must explain and not only list/mention] (2x2) (4) [10]
QUESTION 3
3.1 An area close to an airport or port intended to attract investment, increases exports and the competitiveness of South African products (2) [Concept] 1x2 (2)
3.2 Eastern Cape (2) 1x2 (2)
3.3
To stimulate economic growth in the region (2)
Provision of skills (2)
Job creation (2)
Alleviate poverty (2)
Improve infrastructure (2)
To encourage export of manufactured goods (2)
[Any TWO. Accept other reasonable answer] 2x2 (4)
3.4
Break-of-bulk point (2)
Availability of harbour to export the equipment (2)
Presence of cheap water transport (2)
Availability of skilled/unskilled labour (2)
Coega IDZ is on the eastern coast - closer to Asian market (2)
[Any TWO. Accept other reasonable answer] 2x2 (4)
3.5
Develop world class infrastructure specially designed to attract investors (2)
Provide access to latest information technology for global communication (2)
Duty-free benefits on raw materials for imports (2)
Subsidised electricity supply rates (2)
Tax rebates (2)
Tax holidays (2)
Reduced cost for water supplies (2)
Develop direct links to an international port and airport for exports (2)
Subsidise training for workers (2)
[Any FOUR. Accept other] 4x2 (8)
[20]
GRAND TOTAL: 60
7. CONCLUSION
This document provides teachers with a framework within which to work and develop their own research and data handling tasks.
A clear guideline has been developed on how to conduct research. This guideline can be applied to any topic within the CAPS in which learners wish to conduct research. The marking rubric that has been included also provides teachers and learners with a clear guide on the time that should be spent on the various phases of doing the research.
The high standard of these tasks will provide a platform for learners to develop skills such as research, interpretation of resources, integration of resources and graphs, all skills required for the final external Geography examination. These are also skills that can be put to use at a later stage in their lives.
HISTORY
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
LEARNER GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENTS | PAGE | |
1. | Introduction | 3 |
2. | Aims and Objectives of School-based Assessment | 3 |
3. | Assessment Tasks as outlined in the CAPS | 4 |
4. | Guidelines for School-based Assessment | 5 |
5. | Bibliography | 35 |
1. INTRODUCTION
Assessment is a continuous, planned process of identifying, gathering and interpreting information about the performance of learners, using various forms of assessment. School-Based Assessment (SBA) is a purposive collection of learners’ work that tells the story of their efforts, progress or achievement in a given area. The quality of SBA tasks is integral to learners’ preparation for the final examinations.
This booklet serves as a resource of exemplar SBA tasks for learners who study History. SBA marks are formally recorded for progression and certification purposes. The SBA component is compulsory for all learners. Learners who cannot comply with the requirements specified according to the policy may not be eligible to enter for the subject in the final National Senior Certificate (NSC) examination.
This publication comprises of several tasks that address the demands of the Grade 12 History curriculum. It is expected that this booklet will serve as a valuable resource for Grade 12 History learners. It provides useful information which will assist you in your preparation for the NSC examinations in History.
2. AIMS AND OBJECTIVES OF SCHOOL-BASED ASSESSMENT
The aim of this resource booklet is to assist you in your preparation for the Grade 12 examination from 2014 onwards. It contains crucial information on how to work with the prescribed content as contained in the Curriculum and Assessment Policy Statement (CAPS).
The booklet contains information on how to undertake a research assignment, work with sources and write a coherent essay. A step-by-step approach on how to undertake a research assignment is given. The Research Assignment forms a significant part of your SBA mark for History. Hence, you are encouraged to use these guidelines when preparing to submit your assignments for final assessment. In addition, exemplars of source
based questions and essays are also provided. It outlines clearly the format, style and cognitive levels of questions which learners will be required to answer in their SBA tasks in Grade 12 History.
Our objective is to help learners succeed in Grade 12 History. Therefore, you are encouraged to use this resource booklet to sharpen your skills in History in order to achieve a good mark.
3. ASSESSMENT TASKS AS OUTLINED IN THE CAPS
The final Grade 12 mark is calculated from the National Senior Certificate (NSC) examination that learners will write (out of 300 marks) plus school-based assessment (out of 100 marks). The curriculum policy document stipulates SEVEN formal tasks that comprise school-based assessment in History. The table below outlines the programme of assessment that needs to be completed in your Grade 12 year.
Term 1 | Term 2 | Term 3 | Term 4 |
3 tasks | 2 tasks | 2 tasks | |
|
|
|
|
25% of total year mark = 100 marks | 75% of total year mark = 300 marks |
4. GUIDELINES FOR SCHOOL-BASED ASSESSMENT
4.1 RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT: Grade 12
To ensure that there is compliance with the requirements of SBA in History, an example of how to undertake research is given below.
Introduction
The research assignment in Grade 12 accounts for 20% of the total school-based assessment (SBA). It is, therefore, essential that this be a significant piece of work. This assignment offers learners the opportunity to demonstrate their skills, knowledge and understanding of History which they have acquired during the course of the FET phase.
The research assignment can be written on any section of the Grade 12 curriculum. There are, however, two sections in the curriculum, which are not formally examined in the final Grade 12 examination:
It is recommended that one of these topics be investigated as a research project.
Some points to consider when planning a research assignment:
Learners are expected to fulfil the following requirements in their research assignment:
Some suggestions of what can be done with the research assignments when they are completed:
STRUCTURE OF A RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT | SUGGESTIOND ON HOW TO CARRY OUT YOUR RESEARCH |
Hint 1 Before you start your research |
|
Cover Page |
|
Introduction (Write approximately ½ - 1 page) |
|
Background (Write approximately 1 - 2 page) |
|
Hint 2 : During the research process |
|
Body of Essay (Write approximately 2-3 pages) |
|
Conclusion (Write approximately ½–page) |
|
Reflection (Write approximately ½–1 page) |
|
Bibliography |
|
Hint 3: Before you submit your research assignment |
|
ANNEXURE A: EXAMPLE OF A COVER PAGE FOR A RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT:
GRADE 12 RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT: HISTORY | |
NAME OF SCHOOL | |
NAME OF LEARNER | |
SUBJECT | |
RESEARCH TOPIC | |
KEY QUESTION |
STATEMENT OF AUTHENTICITY:
I hereby declare that ALL pieces of writing contained in this research assignment, are my own original work and that if I made use of any source, I have duly acknowledged it.
LEARNER’S SIGNATURE:____________________________________________
DATE:_____________________________________________________________
ANNEXURE B: AN EXAMPLE OF A MONITORING LOG
DATE | ACTIVITY | COMMENT |
January | Commencement | Learners are given the instructions, guidelines and key question for the research assignment. |
March | 1st DRAFT:
| |
April | 2nd DRAFT:
| |
May |
| |
July |
|
Teacher’s name:_______________________
Teacher’s signature:___________________
Learner’s signature:____________________
SCHOOL STAMP
|
ANNEXURE C: LIST OF SUGGESTED RESOURCES WITH A SYNOPSIS (IN ITALICS)
BOOKS:
Berger, I., Threads of solidarity: Women in South African industry, (Indiana University Press, 1991).
This book details women’s changing place in formal and casual work. It explores the relationship between women across the colour lines as workers and members of trade unions.
Bernstein, H., For their triumphs and for their tears. Women in Apartheid South Africa. (IDAF, 1985).
This booklet gives a great deal of very useful information about how women lived, worked, struggled and survived in apartheid South Africa.
Bozzoli, B. with Nkotsoe, M., Women of Phokeng (Ravan Press, 1991).
This book traces the life histories and experiences of 22 black women from the small town of Phokeng.
Cock, J., Colonels and cadres. War and gender in South Africa, (OUP, 1991).
This book contains interviews with women who served in both the SADF and MK and analyses their experiences.
Cock, J., Maids and madams. A study in the politics of exploitation, (Ravan Press, 1989).
An investigation into experiences of women domestic workers during apartheid.
Du Preez Bezdrob, A.M. Winnie Mandela a life. (Paarl: Paarl Printers. 2003).
Gordon, S., A talent for tomorrow. Life stories of South African servants (Ravan Press, 1985).
A book that contains the life stories of 23 people, most of whom are women, who worked as domestic labourers under apartheid.
Human, M.; Mutloatse, M. & Masiza, J. The Women’s Freedom March of 1956. (Pan McMillan (Pty Ltd), 2006).
Luthuli, A., Let my people go, The Autobiography of Albert Luthuli. (Paarl Printers, 2006).
Mashinini, E., Strikes have followed me all my life (The Women’s Press, 1989).
The autobiography of Emma Mashinini who was secretary of one of South Africa’s biggest black Trade Unions, the CCAWUSA (the Shop and Distributive Workers’ Union).
Naidoo, P., Footprints in Grey Street. (Ocean Jetty Publishing, 2002).
Platzky, L. & Walker, C., The surplus people. Forced removal in South Africa (Ravan Press, 1985).
The creation of racially separate areas was the cornerstone of apartheid policy. The majority of people who were forcibly removed in order to create this artificial separation were women and children. This book documents their experiences and their struggle to survive.
Vahed, G. & Waetjen,T., Gender modernity and Indian delights. The Women’s Cultural Group of Durban 1954- 2010 (HSRC, 2010).
Part social history part biography, this book shows how the women in the Durban Cultural Group creating an identity for themselves in the context of apartheid.
Walker, C., Women and gender in Southern Africa to 1945. (New Africa Books, 1990). Gives valuable background information about the experience of women in South Africa. It sets the scene for a discussion of the 1950s–1970s.
Walker, C., Women and resistance in South Africa. (Onyx Press, 1991).
This remains the most detailed historical account of women’s resistance during apartheid. Walker has chapters on the Federation of South African Women, Anti-Pass protests, the Women’s Charter of 1954, among others.
South African History Online, ‘For freedom and equality’, Celebrating women in South African history (DBE, no date).
This booklet contains information about women’s involvement in the liberation struggle. There are a number of biographical profiles of great South African women. It can be downloaded from the South African History Online website at: http://www.sahistory.org.za/aids-resources/freedom-and-equality-celebrating-women-south-african history-booklet
Malibongwe Igama Lamakhosikama. Praise be to women. Remembering the role of women in South Africa through dialogue (Nelson Mandela Foundation, 2007).
The text in this booklet is the edited version of the Malibingwe Dialogue which took place on 30 May 2007 at the Nelson Mandela Foundation.
It can be downloaded from the following website: http://www.nelsonmandela.org/uploads/files/Malibongwe_WEB.pdf
WEBSITES:
www.blacksash.org.za
Full digital texts of the Black Sash publication Sash is available from 1960-1990.
http://www.sahistory.org.za/topic/womens-struggle-1900-1994
South African History Online. This site has a wide range of information about women’s struggles in South Africa 1900-1994.
http://www.anc.org.za/themes.php?t=Women`s%20Struggles
This site, maintained by the ANC, has documents concerning women in the liberation struggle
ORAL INTERVIEWS
There is a saying in Mozambique that ‘our old people are our libraries’. If you are living in an area where it is difficult to access the Internet, or do not have a local library, then remember that the people living in your community have a wealth of information in their memories. You may consider conducting interviews with women and men in your community and recording their stories as evidence to answer your key question.
ANNEXURE D: EXAMPLE OF A TEMPLATE FOR NOTE-TAKING DURING RESEARCH
FULL REFERENCE OF RESOURCE | EVIDENCE (This could be used to support your argument) |
E.g.: | ‘During the 1980s hundreds of thousands of black women were forced to move and were dumped in remote rural areas called Bantustans or ‘homelands’: These forced removals mainly affected women’ (p 23). This extract could be used as evidence that women’s role in the struggle against apartheid was different to men’s role. |
ANNEXURE E: GUIDELINES ON HOW TO WRITE A BIBLIOGRAPHY
4.2 SOURCE- BASED QUESTIONS
QUESTION 1
WHY DID SOUTH AFRICA BECOME INVOLVED IN THE ANGOLAN CIVIL WAR IN THE 1980s?
SOURCE 1A
The following extract was written by Joseph Hanlon, a journalist, in the mid-1980s. It describes why South Africa became involved in the Angolan civil war and eventually decided to retreat. [From: Beggar Your Neighbours: Apartheid Power in Southern Africa by J Hanlon] |
SOURCE 1B
The following is a cartoon by British cartoonist, Leslie Gilbert. It depicts the Soviet Union as Santa Claus on his sleigh, delivering presents in the form of weapons to the MPLA which were used in the civil war against UNITA and the FNLA. The cartoon was entitled ‘Slay Bells’. ‘Slay’ means to kill.
SOURCE 1C
This is part of an interview that was conducted with the former South African Prime Minister, BJ Vorster, by Clarence Rhodes of UPITN-TV (United Press International Television News) on 13 February 1976.
Rhodes: President Kaunda of Zambia described the Soviet and the Cuban intervention in Angola. I think the quote is ‘a plundering (thieving) tiger and its deadly cub’. … Would you say that this then poses a bigger threat than the emergence of yet another independent black African nation on South African borders? [Internet site: http://www.sahistory.org.za/archive/interview-south-african-prime-minister-mr-b-j-vorster-mr-clarence rhodes-upitn-tv-13-february. Accessed on 13 May 2013. |
SOURCE 1D
The following is a transcript of a news bulletin that was presented by the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) on 10 August 1982.
Good evening. Another 113 SWAPO terrorists have been killed in continuing Security Force operations aimed at SWAPO bases in southern Angola. The Prime Minister and Minister of Defence have expressed the gov ernment’s sympathy with families of the fifteen South African airmen and soldiers killed. They said events like this shook the people of South Africa, but comfort could be drawn from the fact that the deaths were incurred maintaining civilisation. They sacrificed their lives in the preservation of the norms and values of a Christian community. In the modern world, the barbarian* at the gates is the terrorist**… [From: South Africa: A Different Kind of War by J Frederikse] |
*Barbarian: a negative word used by the apartheid regime to refer to activists from the liberation movements which operated in exile.
** Terrorist: a word used by the apartheid regime to refer to freedom fighters.
QUESTION 2
HOW SUCCESSFUL WAS THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) IN HEALING OUR PAST?
SOURCE 2A
This is a photograph of the first Truth and Reconciliation Commission hearing that took place in East London on 15 April 1996.
[Internet site: http://qu301southafrica.com/tag/reconu. Accessed on 3 May 2013]
SOURCE 2B
The following extract focuses on the assassination of anti-apartheid activist and attorney, Griffiths Mxenge, on 20 November 1981.
On 20 November 1981, Mr Griffiths Mxenge was found dead in a cycling stadium at Umlazi. Three Vlakplaas operatives namely, Commander Dirk Coetzee and askaris (spy/sell-out) Almond Nofemela and David Tshikilange were charged and convicted of the killing. Coetzee, Nofemela and Tshikilange applied for amnesty for Mxenge’s killing. [Internet site: www.justice.gov.za/trc/report/. Accessed on 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 2C
The following statement was issued by the Amnesty Committee of the TRC. It focuses on the reasons for the granting of amnesty to Dirk Coetzee, Almond Nofemela and David Tshikilange for the murder of Griffiths Mxenge.
The Amnesty Committee of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission today granted amnesty to Dirk Coetzee, David Tshikalange and Butana Almond Nofomela in respect of the murder of Durban attorney, Mr Griffiths Mxenge, in November 1981. [Internet site: www.info.gov.za/speeches/1997/08050w13297.html. Accessed on 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 2D
The following report by the South African Press Association (SAPA) outlines the reasons for the Mxenge family’s opposition to the process of amnesty.
DURBAN 5 November 1996 — SAPA The family of slain human-rights lawyer, Griffiths Mxenge, on Tuesday said the granting of amnesty to former policeman Dirk Coetzee, who has confessed to ordering Mxenge’s murder, would be a travesty (mockery) of justice ... [Internet site: www.justice.gov.za/trc/media/1996/9611/s961105h.html. Accessed on 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 2E
The following is part of an interview that Shaun de Waal, reporter from the Mail and Guardian, conducted with Mahmood Mamdani about South Africa’s TRC process. Mamdani is an African academic and current director of the Makerere Institute of Social Research.
Shaun de Waal: So you’re saying the TRC was the performative extension of the settlement reached at Codesa and, for all that, it did help to produce a political solution ... Mamdani: … Yet the TRC defined victims as though no apartheid had ever existed – simply as individuals whose bodily integrity had been violated. That is to put apartheid on the same plane as any dictatorship anywhere in the world. But apartheid affected the entire society, not just isolated individuals. Its cutting edge was legislation that defined the whole population into groups it called races, then it passed laws that enabled a minority and disabled the majority ... [From: Mail and Guardian, 3–9 May 2013 |
QUESTION 3
WHAT IMPACT DID GLOBALISATION HAVE ON THE NEW WORLD ORDER?
SOURCE 3A
The following extract focuses on the phenomenon of globalisation.
Globalisation is the system of interaction among the countries of the world in order to develop the global economy. Globalisation refers to the integration of economics and societies all over the world. Globalisation involves technological, economic, political, and cultural exchanges made possible largely by advances in communication, transportation and infrastructure. [Internet site: http://hubpages.com/hub/Definition-of-Globalization. Accessed 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 3B
The following source is a diagrammatic representation of the different features of globalisation.
SOURCE 3C
The following article by the World Economic Forum Survey focuses on how people from 25 countries viewed globalisation.
People around the world increasingly favour globalisation but worry about jobs, poverty and environment The largest-ever public opinion poll on globalisation, covering countries with 67 per cent of the world’s population, shows that people increasingly favour economic globalisation, but they have high expectations in some areas that will be difficult to satisfy. Citizens also have concerns about what they see as the damaging impacts of globalisation.
The World Economic Forum poll involved 25 000 in-person or telephone interviews across mainly ‘Group of 20’ countries and was conducted between October and December 2001 ... Majorities of people in 19 of 25 countries surveyed expect that more economic globalisation will be positive for themselves and their families. While over six in ten citizens worldwide (62 per cent) see globalisation as positive ... The strongest supporters are found in northern Europe, North America, and poorer countries in Asia ... [Internet site: www.globescan.com/news_archives/press_inside.htm. Accessed 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 3D
The following article by Prabhakar Pillai is entitled ‘The Negative Effects of Globalisation’. It focuses on his views about globalisation.
In order to cut down costs, many firms in developed nations have outsourced their manufacturing and white-collar jobs to ‘Third-World’ countries like India and China, where the cost of labour is low. The most prominent among these have been jobs in the customer-service field as many developing nations have a large English-speaking population – ready to work at one-fifth of what someone in the developed world may call ‘low-pay’ ... [Internet site: http://www.buzzle.com/articles/negative-effects-of-globalization.html. Accessed 03 May 2013] |
SOURCE 3E
A photograph showing activists protesting against the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in Washington in 1999.
QUESTION 1
WHY DID SOUTH AFRICA BECOME INVOLVED IN THE ANGOLAN CIVIL WAR?
Study Sources 1A, 1B, 1C and 1D to answer the questions that follow.
1.1 Refer to Source 1A.
1.1.1 Which organisation did the apartheid government support during the Angolan civil war? (1 x 1) (1)
1.1.2 List FOUR Angolan economic installations that were targeted by the South African Defence Force. (4 x 1) (4)
1.1.3 Using the information in the source, explain THREE reasons why the apartheid government felt threatened by the MPLA leadership in Angola. (3 x 2) (6)
1.1.4 In the context of the Angolan civil war, explain why the MPLA requested assistance from Cuba and the USSR. (1 x 3) (3)
1.2 Study Source 1B.
1.2.1 What message does the cartoon convey regarding the Soviet Union’s support for the MPLA in Angola? Explain your answer using the visual clues in the cartoon. (2 x 2) (4)
1.2.2 Explain to what extent this cartoon may be regarded as biased. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3 Consult Source 1C.
1.3.1 According to Kaunda, which TWO communist countries supported the MPLA? (2 x 1) (2)
1.3.2 Define the term communism in your own words. (1 x 2) (2)
1.3.3 Explain why Prime Minister Vorster did not consider Angola as ‘an independent black African country’. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3.4 Comment on Prime Minister Vorster’s reference to the word ‘communists’ in the context of the Angolan civil war. (1 x 2) (2)
1.4 Use Source 1D.
1.4.1 Quote TWO negative words that were used to describe the South West Africa People’s Organisation (SWAPO) on the SABC news bulletin. (2 x 1) (2)
1.4.2 How did the SABC justify the deaths of the 15 SADF airmen and soldiers who were killed in Angola? (2 x 2) (4)
1.4.3 Explain to what extent the information in Source 1D would be useful for a historian researching the use of propaganda during South Africa’s participation in the Angolan civil war. Use relevant examples from the source to support your answer. (2 x 2) (4)
1.5 Use the information in the relevant sources and your own knowledge, to write a paragraph of about 8 lines (about 80 words) explaining why South Africa became involved in the Angolan civil war. (8)
[50]
QUESTION 2
HOW SUCCESSFUL WAS THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) IN HEALING OUR PAST?
Study Sources 2A, 2B, 2C and 2D to answer the questions that follow.
2.1 Study Source 2A.
2.1.1 When and where was South Africa’s first TRC hearing held? (2 x 1) (2)
2.1.2 Define the concept reconciliation in your own words. (1 x 2) (2)
2.1.3 Explain why the TRC chose to use the slogan ‘Healing Our Past’ during its hearings, as shown in the photograph. (1 x 2) (2)
2.1.4 Comment on why you think the TRC was considered to be a significant event in South Africa’s history. (1 x 3) (3)
2.2 Consult Source 2B.
2.2.1 Name the THREE apartheid operatives who were charged with the murder of Griffiths Mxenge. (3 x 1) (3)
2.2.2 How, according to Nofemela, was Griffiths Mxenge murdered? (2 x 2) (4)
2.2.3 Why, do you think, were the three apartheid operatives found guilty of the killing of Mxenge but not sentenced? Support your answer with relevant evidence. (2 x 2) (4)
2.3 Use Source 2C.
2.3.1 Explain why the THREE apartheid operatives were granted amnesty. (1 x 2) (2)
2.3.2 ‘It will not be necessary for the trial court to proceed with the question of sentence.’ Why, do you think, was this statement made? (1 x 2) (2)
2.4 Refer to Sources 2B and 2C. Explain to what extent an historian would consider the information in Sources 2B and 2C useful when writing about the granting of amnesty to those responsible for the death of Griffith’s Mxenge. (2 x 2) (4)
2.5 Read Source 2D.
2.5.1 How did Griffiths Mxenge’s family react to the application for amnesty of the three apartheid operatives? (1 x 2) (2)
2.5.2 Explain why the Mxenge family responded in this manner to the granting of amnesty to the three apartheid operatives. (2 x 2) (4)
2.6 Consult Source 2E.
2.6.1 How does Mamdani view the manner in which the TRC dealt with the victims of apartheid? (1 x 2) (2)
2.6.2 Mamdani suggests that the TRC process was flawed. What change did he propose that might have made the TRC more successful in its attempt to ‘heal’ the past? (1 x 2) (2)
2.6.3 Comment on the meaning of Mamdani’s statement: ‘The TRC was only interested in, ‘Did you give the orders in this case, that case?’ ‘ (2 x 2) (4)
2.7 Use the information in the relevant sources and your own knowledge, to write a paragraph of about 8 lines (about 80 words), explaining to what extent the TRC was successful in healing our past. (8)
[50]
QUESTION 3
WHAT IMPACT DID GLOBALISATION HAVE ON THE NEW WORLD ORDER?
Study sources 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D and 3E and answer the questions that follow.
3.1 Use Source 3A.
3.1.1 Define the term globalisation in your own words. (1 x 2) (2)
3.1.2 Quote the TWO types of integration mentioned in the source in the context of globalisation. (2 x 1) (2)
3.1.3 According to the information in the source, what might be the negative effects of removing tariffs on the economies of developing countries situated on the African continent? (2 x 2) (4)
3.2 Study Source 3B.
3.2.1 Using the information in the source, identify THREE features of globalisation. (3 x 1) (3)
3.2.2 Explain whether you think these changes (as identified in QUESTION 3.2.1) have had a positive or a negative impact on the various countries of the world. Support your answer with relevant evidence. (3 x 2) (6)
3.3 Refer to Source 3C.
3.3.1 According to the information in the source, why did an increasing number of people favour economic globalisation? (1 x 2) (2)
3.3.2 Quote any TWO positive aspects that the global survey revealed about globalisation. (2 x 1) (2)
3.3.3 As a historian, explain the limitations of using this source when researching the effects of globalisation. (1 x 3) (3)
3.4 Consult Source 3D.
3.4.1 Identify FOUR negative effects of globalisation. (4 x 1) (4)
3.4.2 Explain how globalisation contributed to the negative effects (as identified in QUESTION 3.4.1). Support your answer with a valid reason. (1 x 2) (2)
3.5 Refer to Sources 3C and 3D. Explain how the information in these sources would be useful to a historian studying globalisation. (2 x 2) (4)
3.6 Refer to Source 3E.
3.6.1 What TWO factors, do you think, prompted activists to embark on protest action? (2 x 1) (2)
3.6.2 Comment on the significance of the words, ‘Global Injustice’, as shown on the banner, in the context of globalisation. (1 x 2) (2)
3.7 Consult Source 3D and Source 3E and explain how the information in these sources support each other regarding the negative effects of globalisation. (2 x 2) (4)
3.8 Use the information from the relevant sources and your own knowledge, to write a paragraph of about 8 lines (about 80 words), explaining how globalisation has created a new world order from 1989 to the present. (8)
[50]
6. ASSESSMENT TASKS: ESSAY QUESTIONS
1. TOPIC 1: CHINA OR VIETNAM
QUESTION 1A: CHINA
Discuss to what extent Mao transformed China from an underdeveloped country to a super power between 1949 and 1976. [50]
QUESTION 1B: VIETNAM
‘ ... All the military might of a superpower could not defeat a small nation of peasants.’
Critically discuss this statement in the light of United States of America’s involvement in Vietnam between 1965 and 1975. Use relevant examples to support your answer. [50]
2. TOPIC 2: INDEPENDENT AFRICA
QUESTION 2: CONGO AND TANZANIA
Write a comparative essay on the political successes and challenges that post-colonial leaders of both the Congo and Tanzania faced between the 1960s and the 1980s. [50]
3. TOPIC 4: CIVIL RESISTANCE IN SOUTH AFRICA: 1970S TO 1980S
QUESTION: 4: THE CRISIS OF APARTHEID IN THE 1980S
Explain how internal mass civic resistance and international pressure contributed to the demise (fall) of the apartheid regime in the 1980s. [50]
4. TOPIC 5: THE COMING OF DEMOCRACY IN SOUTH AFRICA AND THE COMING TO TERMS WITH THE PAST
QUESTION: 5: THE NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT AND THE GOVERNMENT OF NATIONAL UNITY
Allister Sparks argues that the process of negotiation ‘was always a crisis-driven process’.
Critically assess Allister Spark’s statement with reference to the process of negotiation in South Africa between 1990 and 1994. [50]
5. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Visual sources and other historical evidence were taken from the following:
BOOKS:
Angier, K. (et al), Viva History Grade 12: Learner’s Book. (Johannesburg: Vivlia, 2013).
Frederikse, J. South Africa: A different kind of war. (London: James Currey, 1987).
Hanlon, J . Beggar your neighbours: Apartheid power in Southern Africa. (London: James Currey, 1986).
Pillay, G. (et al), New Generation History Grade 12: Learner’s book. (Durban: Interpak Printers, 2013).
INTERNET SITES:
http://www.cartoons.ac.uk/search/cartoon_item/angola.
http://www.sahistory.org.za/archive/interview-south-african-prime-minister-mr-b-j-vorster-mr-clarence-rhodes upitn-tv-13-february.
http://qu301southafrica.com/tag/recon.
www.justice.gov.za/trc/report/ .
www.info.gov.za/speeches/1997/08050w13297.html.
www.justice.gov.za/trc/media/1996/9611/s961105h.html.
http://hubpages.com/hub/Definition-of-Globalization.
http://globalisation.pen.io.
www.globescan.com/news_archives/press_inside.htm.
http://www.buzzle.com/articles/negative-effects-of-globalization.html.
http://content.lib.washington.edu/wtoweb/images/wto-protest.jpg.
HISTORY
SCHOOL BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS - CAPS
GRADE 12
TEACHER GUIDE
Guidelines for Learners and Teachers: Exemplar Responses
TABLE OF CONTENTS | PAGE | |
1 | Introduction | 3 |
2 | Aims and Objectives of School-based Assessment | 4 |
3 | Assessment Tasks as outlined in the CAPS | 5 |
4 | Programme of Assessment and Weighting of Tasks | 6 |
5 | Quality-assurance Process Followed | 7 |
6 | Assessment Tasks: Source-based Questions | 19 |
7 | Guidelines for learners and Teachers: Exempler Responses | 40 |
8 | Marking Guidelines and Rubric | 66 |
9 | Bibliography | 88 |
1. INTRODUCTION
Assessment is a continuous, planned process of identifying, gathering and interpreting information about the performance of learners, using various forms of assessment. It involves four steps: generating and collecting evidence of achievement; evaluating this evidence; recording the findings; and using this information to understand and assist with the learners’ academic development. Assessment should be both informal (assessment for learning) and formal (assessment of learning). In both cases regular feedback should be provided to learners to enhance the learning experience.
School-based assessment (SBA) is a purposive collection of learners’ work that tells the story of their efforts, progress or achievement in a given area. The quality of SBA tasks is integral to learners’ preparation for the final examinations. This booklet serves as a resource of exemplar SBA tasks to schools and subject teachers of History. SBA marks are formally recorded by the teacher, for progression and certification purposes. The SBA component is compulsory for all learners. Learners who cannot comply with the requirements specified according to the policy may not be eligible to enter for the subject in the final examination.
The formal assessment tasks provide you with a systematic way of evaluating how well learners are progressing. The booklet contains information on how to undertake research assignments, source-based tasks and essay questions. Formal assessment tasks form part of a year-long formal programme of assessment. These tasks should not be taken lightly and learners should be encouraged to submit their best possible efforts for final assessment.
The educators are expected to ensure that assessment tasks are relevant and suitable to the context in which learners are being taught. However, all SBA should be aligned to the requirements prescribed in the Curriculum and Assessment Policy Statement (CAPS) document.
This publication comprises four tasks that address the demands of the Grade 12 History curriculum. It is expected that these tasks will serve as a valuable resource for:
2. AIMS AND OBJECTIVES OF SCHOOL-BASED ASSESSMENT
The distinctive characteristics of SBA (and its strengths as one relatively small component of a coherent assessment system) have implications for its design and implementation, in particular the nature of the assessment tasks and role of the teachers’ standardisation procedures. These implications are summarised as follows:
Teachers should ensure that learners understand the assessment criteria and their relevance for self- and peer assessment. Teachers should also have used these criteria for informal assessment and teaching purposes before they conduct any formal assessment so that they are familiar with the criteria and the assessment process.
The project provides exemplar tasks that are aimed at:
3. ASSESSMENT TASKS AS OUTLINED IN CAPS
The final Grade 12 mark is calculated from the National Senior Certificate (NSC) examination that learners write (out of 300 marks) plus school-based assessment (out of 100 marks). The curriculum policy document stipulates SEVEN formal tasks that comprise school-based assessment in History.
4. PROGRAMME OF ASSESSMENT AND WEIGHTING OF TASKS
Term 1 | Term 2 | Term 3 | Term 4 |
3 tasks | 2 tasks | 2 tasks | |
|
|
|
|
25% of total year mark = 100 marks | 75% of total year mark = 300 marks |
5. QUALITY-ASSURANCE PROCESS FOLLOWED
To ensure that there is compliance with the requirements of SBA in History, an example of how to undertake research is given below.
Introduction
The research assignment in Grade 12 accounts for 20% of the total school-based assessment (SBA). It is, therefore, essential that this be a significant piece of work. This assignment offers learners the opportunity to demonstrate their skills, knowledge and understanding of History which they have acquired during the course of the FET phase.
The research assignment can be written on any section of the Grade 12 curriculum. There are, however, two sections in the curriculum, which are not formally examined in the final Grade 12 examination:
It is recommended that one of these topics be investigated as a research project.
Some points to consider when planning a research assignment:
Learners are expected to fulfil the following requirements in their research assignment:
Some suggestions of what can be done with the research assignments when they are completed:
TABLE SHOWING HOW TO STRUCTURE AND CARRY OUT RESEARCH
KEY QUESTION: How was the role of women in the struggle against apartheid different from that of men?
STRUCTURE OF A RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT | SUGGESTIOND ON HOW TO CARRY OUT YOUR RESEARCH |
Hint 1 Before you start your research |
|
Cover Page |
|
Introduction (Write approximately ½ - 1 page) |
|
Background (Write approximately 1 - 2 page) |
|
Hint 2 : During the research process |
|
Body of Essay (Write approximately 2-3 pages) |
|
Conclusion (Write approximately ½–page) |
|
Reflection (Write approximately ½–1 page) |
|
Bibliography |
|
Hint 3: Before you submit your research assignment |
|
SUGGESTED RUBRIC TO ASSESS A RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT
TOTAL MARKS: 100
CRITERIA | LEVEL DESCRIPTORS | |||
LEVEL 4 | LEVEL 3 | LEVEL 2 | LEVEL 1 | |
Criterion 1 | 8 – 10 | 5 - 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Planning (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of planning (clear research schedule provided). | Shows adequate understanding of planning. | Shows some evidence of planning. | Shows little or no evidence of planning. |
Criterion 2 | 16 – 20 | 10 - 15 | 5 – 9 | 0 – 4 |
Identify and access a variety of sources of information (20 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. | Shows adequate understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. | Shows some understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. | Shows little or no understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. |
Criterion 3 | 8 – 10 | 5 – 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Knowledge and understanding of the period (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent knowledge and understanding of the period | Shows adequate knowledge and understanding of the period. | Shows some knowledge and understanding of the period. | Shows little or no knowledge and understanding of the period. |
Criterion 4 | 24 – 30 | 14 – 23 | 7 – 13 | 0 – 6 |
Historical enquiry, interpretation & communication (Essay) (30 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. | Shows adequate understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. | Shows some understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. | Shows little or no understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. |
Criterion 5 | 8 – 10 | 5 – 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Presentation (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). | Shows adequate evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). | Shows some evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). | Shows little or no evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). |
Criterion 6 | 8 – 10 | 5 - 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Evaluation & reflection (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from undertaking research). | Shows adequate understanding of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from under taking research). | Shows some evidence of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from undertaking research). | Shows little or no evidence of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from undertaking research). |
Criterion 7 | 8 – 10 | 5 - 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Acknowledgement of sources (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). | Shows adequate understanding of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). | Shows some evidence of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). | Shows little or no evidence of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). |
ANNEXURE A: EXAMPLE OF A COVER PAGE FOR A RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT:
GRADE 12 RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT: HISTORY | |
NAME OF SCHOOL | |
NAME OF LEARNER | |
SUBJECT | |
RESEARCH TOPIC | |
KEY QUESTION |
STATEMENT OF AUTHENTICITY:
I hereby declare that ALL pieces of writing contained in this research assignment, are my own original work and that if I made use of any source, I have duly acknowledged it.
LEARNER’S SIGNATURE:____________________________________________
DATE:_____________________________________________________________
ANNEXURE B: AN EXAMPLE OF A MONITORING LOG
DATE | ACTIVITY | COMMENT |
January | Commencement | Learners are given the instructions, guidelines and key question for the research assignment. |
March | 1st DRAFT:
| |
April | 2nd DRAFT:
| |
May |
| |
July |
|
Teacher’s name:_______________________
Teacher’s signature:___________________
Learner’s signature:____________________
SCHOOL STAMP
|
ANNEXURE C: LIST OF SUGGESTED RESOURCES WITH A SYNOPSIS (IN ITALICS)
BOOKS:
Berger, I., Threads of solidarity: Women in South African industry, (Indiana University Press, 1991).
This book details women’s changing place in formal and casual work. It explores the relationship between women across the colour lines as workers and members of trade unions.
Bernstein, H., For their triumphs and for their tears. Women in Apartheid South Africa. (IDAF, 1985).
This booklet gives a great deal of very useful information about how women lived, worked, struggled and survived in apartheid South Africa.
Bozzoli, B. with Nkotsoe, M., Women of Phokeng (Ravan Press, 1991).
This book traces the life histories and experiences of 22 black women from the small town of Phokeng.
Cock, J., Colonels and cadres. War and gender in South Africa, (OUP, 1991).
This book contains interviews with women who served in both the SADF and MK and analyses their experiences.
Cock, J., Maids and madams. A study in the politics of exploitation, (Ravan Press, 1989).
An investigation into experiences of women domestic workers during apartheid.
Du Preez Bezdrob, A.M. Winnie Mandela a life. (Paarl: Paarl Printers. 2003).
Gordon, S., A talent for tomorrow. Life stories of South African servants (Ravan Press, 1985).
A book that contains the life stories of 23 people, most of whom are women, who worked as domestic labourers under apartheid.
Human, M.; Mutloatse, M. & Masiza, J. The Women’s Freedom March of 1956. (Pan McMillan (Pty Ltd), 2006).
Luthuli, A., Let my people go, The Autobiography of Albert Luthuli. (Paarl Printers, 2006).
Mashinini, E., Strikes have followed me all my life (The Women’s Press, 1989).
The autobiography of Emma Mashinini who was secretary of one of South Africa’s biggest black Trade Unions, the CCAWUSA (the Shop and Distributive Workers’ Union).
Naidoo, P., Footprints in Grey Street. (Ocean Jetty Publishing, 2002).
Platzky, L. & Walker, C., The surplus people. Forced removal in South Africa (Ravan Press, 1985).
The creation of racially separate areas was the cornerstone of apartheid policy. The majority of people who were forcibly removed in order to create this artificial separation were women and children. This book documents their experiences and their struggle to survive.
Vahed, G. & Waetjen,T., Gender modernity and Indian delights. The Women’s Cultural Group of Durban 1954- 2010 (HSRC, 2010).
Part social history part biography, this book shows how the women in the Durban Cultural Group creating an identity for themselves in the context of apartheid.
Walker, C., Women and gender in Southern Africa to 1945. (New Africa Books, 1990). Gives valuable background information about the experience of women in South Africa. It sets the scene for a discussion of the 1950s–1970s.
Walker, C., Women and resistance in South Africa. (Onyx Press, 1991).
This remains the most detailed historical account of women’s resistance during apartheid. Walker has chapters on the Federation of South African Women, Anti-Pass protests, the Women’s Charter of 1954, among others.
South African History Online, ‘For freedom and equality’, Celebrating women in South African history (DBE, no date).
This booklet contains information about women’s involvement in the liberation struggle. There are a number of biographical profiles of great South African women. It can be downloaded from the South African History Online website at: http://www.sahistory.org.za/aids-resources/freedom-and-equality-celebrating-women-south-african history-booklet
Malibongwe Igama Lamakhosikama. Praise be to women. Remembering the role of women in South Africa through dialogue (Nelson Mandela Foundation, 2007).
The text in this booklet is the edited version of the Malibingwe Dialogue which took place on 30 May 2007 at the Nelson Mandela Foundation.
It can be downloaded from the following website: http://www.nelsonmandela.org/uploads/files/Malibongwe_WEB.pdf
WEBSITES:
www.blacksash.org.za
Full digital texts of the Black Sash publication Sash is available from 1960-1990.
http://www.sahistory.org.za/topic/womens-struggle-1900-1994
South African History Online. This site has a wide range of information about women’s struggles in South Africa 1900-1994.
http://www.anc.org.za/themes.php?t=Women`s%20Struggles
This site, maintained by the ANC, has documents concerning women in the liberation struggle
ORAL INTERVIEWS
There is a saying in Mozambique that ‘our old people are our libraries’. If you are living in an area where it is difficult to access the Internet, or do not have a local library, then remember that the people living in your community have a wealth of information in their memories. You may consider conducting interviews with women and men in your community and recording their stories as evidence to answer your key question.
ANNEXURE D: EXAMPLE OF A TEMPLATE FOR NOTE-TAKING DURING RESEARCH
FULL REFERENCE OF RESOURCE | EVIDENCE (This could be used to support your argument) |
E.g.: | ‘During the 1980s hundreds of thousands of black women were forced to move and were dumped in remote rural areas called Bantustans or ‘homelands’: These forced removals mainly affected women’ (p 23). This extract could be used as evidence that women’s role in the struggle against apartheid was different to men’s role. |
ANNEXURE E: GUIDELINES ON HOW TO WRITE A BIBLIOGRAPHY
6. ASSESMENT TASKSSOURCE- BASED QUESTIONS
QUESTION 1
WHY DID SOUTH AFRICA BECOME INVOLVED IN THE ANGOLAN CIVIL WAR IN THE 1980s?
SOURCE 1A
The following extract was written by Joseph Hanlon, a journalist, in the mid-1980s. It describes why South Africa became involved in the Angolan civil war and eventually decided to retreat. [From: Beggar Your Neighbours: Apartheid Power in Southern Africa by J Hanlon] |
SOURCE 1B
The following is a cartoon by British cartoonist, Leslie Gilbert. It depicts the Soviet Union as Santa Claus on his sleigh, delivering presents in the form of weapons to the MPLA which were used in the civil war against UNITA and the FNLA. The cartoon was entitled ‘Slay Bells’. ‘Slay’ means to kill.
SOURCE 1C
This is part of an interview that was conducted with the former South African Prime Minister, BJ Vorster, by Clarence Rhodes of UPITN-TV (United Press International Television News) on 13 February 1976.
Rhodes: President Kaunda of Zambia described the Soviet and the Cuban intervention in Angola. I think the quote is ‘a plundering (thieving) tiger and its deadly cub’. … Would you say that this then poses a bigger threat than the emergence of yet another independent black African nation on South African borders? [Internet site: http://www.sahistory.org.za/archive/interview-south-african-prime-minister-mr-b-j-vorster-mr-clarence rhodes-upitn-tv-13-february. Accessed on 13 May 2013. |
SOURCE 1D
The following is a transcript of a news bulletin that was presented by the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) on 10 August 1982.
Good evening. Another 113 SWAPO terrorists have been killed in continuing Security Force operations aimed at SWAPO bases in southern Angola. The Prime Minister and Minister of Defence have expressed the gov ernment’s sympathy with families of the fifteen South African airmen and soldiers killed. They said events like this shook the people of South Africa, but comfort could be drawn from the fact that the deaths were incurred maintaining civilisation. They sacrificed their lives in the preservation of the norms and values of a Christian community. In the modern world, the barbarian* at the gates is the terrorist**… [From: South Africa: A Different Kind of War by J Frederikse] |
*Barbarian: a negative word used by the apartheid regime to refer to activists from the liberation movements which operated in exile.
** Terrorist: a word used by the apartheid regime to refer to freedom fighters.
QUESTION 2
HOW SUCCESSFUL WAS THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) IN HEALING OUR PAST?
SOURCE 2A
This is a photograph of the first Truth and Reconciliation Commission hearing that took place in East London on 15 April 1996.
[Internet site: http://qu301southafrica.com/tag/reconu. Accessed on 3 May 2013]
SOURCE 2B
The following extract focuses on the assassination of anti-apartheid activist and attorney, Griffiths Mxenge, on 20 November 1981.
On 20 November 1981, Mr Griffiths Mxenge was found dead in a cycling stadium at Umlazi. Three Vlakplaas operatives namely, Commander Dirk Coetzee and askaris (spy/sell-out) Almond Nofemela and David Tshikilange were charged and convicted of the killing. Coetzee, Nofemela and Tshikilange applied for amnesty for Mxenge’s killing. [Internet site: www.justice.gov.za/trc/report/. Accessed on 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 2C
The following statement was issued by the Amnesty Committee of the TRC. It focuses on the reasons for the granting of amnesty to Dirk Coetzee, Almond Nofemela and David Tshikilange for the murder of Griffiths Mxenge.
The Amnesty Committee of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission today granted amnesty to Dirk Coetzee, David Tshikalange and Butana Almond Nofomela in respect of the murder of Durban attorney, Mr Griffiths Mxenge, in November 1981. [Internet site: www.info.gov.za/speeches/1997/08050w13297.html. Accessed on 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 2D
The following report by the South African Press Association (SAPA) outlines the reasons for the Mxenge family’s opposition to the process of amnesty.
DURBAN 5 November 1996 — SAPA The family of slain human-rights lawyer, Griffiths Mxenge, on Tuesday said the granting of amnesty to former policeman Dirk Coetzee, who has confessed to ordering Mxenge’s murder, would be a travesty (mockery) of justice ... [Internet site: www.justice.gov.za/trc/media/1996/9611/s961105h.html. Accessed on 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 2E
The following is part of an interview that Shaun de Waal, reporter from the Mail and Guardian, conducted with Mahmood Mamdani about South Africa’s TRC process. Mamdani is an African academic and current director of the Makerere Institute of Social Research.
Shaun de Waal: So you’re saying the TRC was the performative extension of the settlement reached at Codesa and, for all that, it did help to produce a political solution ... Mamdani: … Yet the TRC defined victims as though no apartheid had ever existed – simply as individuals whose bodily integrity had been violated. That is to put apartheid on the same plane as any dictatorship anywhere in the world. But apartheid affected the entire society, not just isolated individuals. Its cutting edge was legislation that defined the whole population into groups it called races, then it passed laws that enabled a minority and disabled the majority ... [From: Mail and Guardian, 3–9 May 2013 |
QUESTION 3
WHAT IMPACT DID GLOBALISATION HAVE ON THE NEW WORLD ORDER?
SOURCE 3A
The following extract focuses on the phenomenon of globalisation.
Globalisation is the system of interaction among the countries of the world in order to develop the global economy. Globalisation refers to the integration of economics and societies all over the world. Globalisation involves technological, economic, political, and cultural exchanges made possible largely by advances in communication, transportation and infrastructure. [Internet site: http://hubpages.com/hub/Definition-of-Globalization. Accessed 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 3B
The following source is a diagrammatic representation of the different features of globalisation.
[Internet site: http://globalisation.pen.io. Accessed 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 3C
The following article by the World Economic Forum Survey focuses on how people from 25 countries viewed globalisation.
People around the world increasingly favour globalisation but worry about jobs, poverty and environment The largest-ever public opinion poll on globalisation, covering countries with 67 per cent of the world’s population, shows that people increasingly favour economic globalisation, but they have high expectations in some areas that will be difficult to satisfy. Citizens also have concerns about what they see as the damaging impacts of globalisation.
The World Economic Forum poll involved 25 000 in-person or telephone interviews across mainly ‘Group of 20’ countries and was conducted between October and December 2001 ... Majorities of people in 19 of 25 countries surveyed expect that more economic globalisation will be positive for themselves and their families. While over six in ten citizens worldwide (62 per cent) see globalisation as positive ... The strongest supporters are found in northern Europe, North America, and poorer countries in Asia ... [Internet site: www.globescan.com/news_archives/press_inside.htm. Accessed 3 May 2013] |
SOURCE 3D
The following article by Prabhakar Pillai is entitled ‘The Negative Effects of Globalisation’. It focuses on his views about globalisation.
In order to cut down costs, many firms in developed nations have outsourced their manufacturing and white-collar jobs to ‘Third-World’ countries like India and China, where the cost of labour is low. The most prominent among these have been jobs in the customer-service field as many developing nations have a large English-speaking population – ready to work at one-fifth of what someone in the developed world may call ‘low-pay’ ... [Internet site: http://www.buzzle.com/articles/negative-effects-of-globalization.html. Accessed 03 May 2013] |
SOURCE 3E
A photograph showing activists protesting against the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in Washington in 1999.
MARCH AGAINST WTO GLOBAL INJUSTICE
|
QUESTION 1
WHY DID SOUTH AFRICA BECOME INVOLVED IN THE ANGOLAN CIVIL WAR?
Study Sources 1A, 1B, 1C and 1D to answer the questions that follow.
1.1 Refer to Source 1A.
1.1.1 Which organisation did the apartheid government support during the Angolan civil war? (1 x 1) (1)
1.1.2 List FOUR Angolan economic installations that were targeted by the South African Defence Force. (4 x 1) (4)
1.1.3 Using the information in the source, explain THREE reasons why the apartheid government felt threatened by the MPLA leadership in Angola. (3 x 2) (6)
1.1.4 In the context of the Angolan civil war, explain why the MPLA requested assistance from Cuba and the USSR. (1 x 3) (3)
1.2 Study Source 1B.
1.2.1 What message does the cartoon convey regarding the Soviet Union’s support for the MPLA in Angola? Explain your answer using the visual clues in the cartoon. (2 x 2) (4)
1.2.2 Explain to what extent this cartoon may be regarded as biased. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3 Consult Source 1C.
1.3.1 According to Kaunda, which TWO communist countries supported the MPLA? (2 x 1) (2)
1.3.2 Define the term communism in your own words. (1 x 2) (2)
1.3.3 Explain why Prime Minister Vorster did not consider Angola as ‘an independent black African country’. (2 x 2) (4)
1.3.4 Comment on Prime Minister Vorster’s reference to the word ‘communists’ in the context of the Angolan civil war. (1 x 2) (2)
1.4 Use Source 1D.
1.4.1 Quote TWO negative words that were used to describe the South West Africa People’s Organisation (SWAPO) on the SABC news bulletin. (2 x 1) (2)
1.4.2 How did the SABC justify the deaths of the 15 SADF airmen and soldiers who were killed in Angola? (2 x 2) (4)
1.4.3 Explain to what extent the information in Source 1D would be useful for a historian researching the use of propaganda during South Africa’s participation in the Angolan civil war. Use relevant examples from the source to support your answer. (2 x 2) (4)
1.5 Use the information in the relevant sources and your own knowledge, to write a paragraph of about 8 lines (about 80 words) explaining why South Africa became involved in the Angolan civil war. (8)
[50]
QUESTION 2
HOW SUCCESSFUL WAS THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) IN HEALING OUR PAST?
Study Sources 2A, 2B, 2C and 2D to answer the questions that follow.
2.1 Study Source 2A.
2.1.1 When and where was South Africa’s first TRC hearing held? (2 x 1) (2)
2.1.2 Define the concept reconciliation in your own words. (1 x 2) (2)
2.1.3 Explain why the TRC chose to use the slogan ‘Healing Our Past’ during its hearings, as shown in the photograph. (1 x 2) (2)
2.1.4 Comment on why you think the TRC was considered to be a significant event in South Africa’s history. (1 x 3) (3)
2.2 Consult Source 2B.
2.2.1 Name the THREE apartheid operatives who were charged with the murder of Griffiths Mxenge. (3 x 1) (3)
2.2.2 How, according to Nofemela, was Griffiths Mxenge murdered? (2 x 2) (4)
2.2.3 Why, do you think, were the three apartheid operatives found guilty of the killing of Mxenge but not sentenced? Support your answer with relevant evidence. (2 x 2) (4)
2.3 Use Source 2C.
2.3.1 Explain why the THREE apartheid operatives were granted amnesty. (1 x 2) (2)
2.3.2 ‘It will not be necessary for the trial court to proceed with the question of sentence.’ Why, do you think, was this statement made? (1 x 2) (2)
2.4 Refer to Sources 2B and 2C. Explain to what extent an historian would consider the information in Sources 2B and 2C useful when writing about the granting of amnesty to those responsible for the death of Griffith’s Mxenge. (2 x 2) (4)
2.5 Read Source 2D.
2.5.1 How did Griffiths Mxenge’s family react to the application for amnesty of the three apartheid operatives? (1 x 2) (2)
2.5.2 Explain why the Mxenge family responded in this manner to the granting of amnesty to the three apartheid operatives. (2 x 2) (4)
2.6 Consult Source 2E.
2.6.1 How does Mamdani view the manner in which the TRC dealt with the victims of apartheid? (1 x 2) (2)
2.6.2 Mamdani suggests that the TRC process was flawed. What change did he propose that might have made the TRC more successful in its attempt to ‘heal’ the past? (1 x 2) (2)
2.6.3 Comment on the meaning of Mamdani’s statement: ‘The TRC was only interested in, ‘Did you give the orders in this case, that case?’ ‘ (2 x 2) (4)
2.7 Use the information in the relevant sources and your own knowledge, to write a paragraph of about 8 lines (about 80 words), explaining to what extent the TRC was successful in healing our past. (8)
[50]
QUESTION 3
WHAT IMPACT DID GLOBALISATION HAVE ON THE NEW WORLD ORDER?
Study sources 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D and 3E and answer the questions that follow.
3.1 Use Source 3A.
3.1.1 Define the term globalisation in your own words. (1 x 2) (2)
3.1.2 Quote the TWO types of integration mentioned in the source in the context of globalisation. (2 x 1) (2)
3.1.3 According to the information in the source, what might be the negative effects of removing tariffs on the economies of developing countries situated on the African continent? (2 x 2) (4)
3.2 Study Source 3B.
3.2.1 Using the information in the source, identify THREE features of globalisation. (3 x 1) (3)
3.2.2 Explain whether you think these changes (as identified in QUESTION 3.2.1) have had a positive or a negative impact on the various countries of the world. Support your answer with relevant evidence. (3 x 2) (6)
3.3 Refer to Source 3C.
3.3.1 According to the information in the source, why did an increasing number of people favour economic globalisation? (1 x 2) (2)
3.3.2 Quote any TWO positive aspects that the global survey revealed about globalisation. (2 x 1) (2)
3.3.3 As a historian, explain the limitations of using this source when researching the effects of globalisation. (1 x 3) (3)
3.4 Consult Source 3D.
3.4.1 Identify FOUR negative effects of globalisation. (4 x 1) (4)
3.4.2 Explain how globalisation contributed to the negative effects (as identified in QUESTION 3.4.1). Support your answer with a valid reason. (1 x 2) (2)
3.5 Refer to Sources 3C and 3D. Explain how the information in these sources would be useful to a historian studying globalisation. (2 x 2) (4)
3.6 Refer to Source 3E.
3.6.1 What TWO factors, do you think, prompted activists to embark on protest action? (2 x 1) (2)
3.6.2 Comment on the significance of the words, ‘Global Injustice’, as shown on the banner, in the context of globalisation. (1 x 2) (2)
3.7 Consult Source 3D and Source 3E and explain how the information in these sources support each other regarding the negative effects of globalisation. (2 x 2) (4)
3.8 Use the information from the relevant sources and your own knowledge, to write a paragraph of about 8 lines (about 80 words), explaining how globalisation has created a new world order from 1989 to the present. (8)
[50]
6. ASSESSMENT TASKS: ESSAY QUESTIONS
1. TOPIC 1: CHINA OR VIETNAM
QUESTION 1A: CHINA
Discuss to what extent Mao transformed China from an underdeveloped country to a super power between 1949 and 1976. [50]
QUESTION 1B: VIETNAM
‘ ... All the military might of a superpower could not defeat a small nation of peasants.’
Critically discuss this statement in the light of United States of America’s involvement in Vietnam between 1965 and 1975. Use relevant examples to support your answer. [50]
2. TOPIC 2: INDEPENDENT AFRICA
QUESTION 2: CONGO AND TANZANIA
Write a comparative essay on the political successes and challenges that post-colonial leaders of both the Congo and Tanzania faced between the 1960s and the 1980s. [50]
3. TOPIC 4: CIVIL RESISTANCE IN SOUTH AFRICA: 1970S TO 1980S
QUESTION: 4: THE CRISIS OF APARTHEID IN THE 1980S
Explain how internal mass civic resistance and international pressure contributed to the demise (fall) of the apartheid regime in the 1980s. [50]
4. TOPIC 5: THE COMING OF DEMOCRACY IN SOUTH AFRICA AND THE COMING TO TERMS WITH THE PAST
QUESTION: 5: THE NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT AND THE GOVERNMENT OF NATIONAL UNITY
Allister Sparks argues that the process of negotiation ‘was always a crisis-driven process’.
Critically assess Allister Spark’s statement with reference to the process of negotiation in South Africa between 1990 and 1994. [50]
7. GUIDELINES FOR LEARNERS AND TEACHERS:
EXEMPLAR RESPONSES:
RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT
GRADE 12: RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT
SCHOOL: | XYZ SECONDARY SCHOOL |
NAME OF LEARNER: | LA DUMA |
SUBJECT: | HISTORY |
QUESTION: ‘The women of South Africa have been leading the struggle hand in hand with the men. There has never been any difference except that the women’s side is more vulnerable to any oppression, the side of their home and the children.’ (Albertina Sisulu) |
STATEMENT OF AUTHENTICITY
I HEREBY DECLARE THAT ALL PIECES OF WRITING CONTAINED IN THIS RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT, ARE MY OWN ORIGINAL WORK AND THAT IF I MADE USE OF ANY SOURCE, I HAVE DULY ACKNOWLEDGED IT.
LEARNER’S SIGNATURE:________________________________________
DATE:______________________
A POEM PAYING TRIBUTE TO SOUTH AFRICAN WOMEN
Praise to our Mothers
If the moon were to shine tonight
To light up my face and show off my proud form
And a soft easy flowing dress with the colours of Africa
If I were to stand on top of a hill
And raise my voice in praise
Of the women of my country
Who have worked throughout their lives
Not for themselves, but for the very life of all Africans
Who would I sing my praises to?
I could quote all the names
Yes, but where do I begin?!
Do I begin with the ones
Who gave their lives
So that we others may live a better life
The Lilian Ngoyis, the Victoria Mxenges
The Ruth Firsts
Or the ones who have lost their men
To Robben Island and their children to exile
But carried on fighting
The MaMotsoaledis, the MaSisulus
The Winnie Mandelas?
Or maybe I would sing praises to
The ones who have had the resilience
And cunning of a desert cobra
Priscilla Jana, Fatima Meer, Beauty Mkhize
Or the ones who turned deserts into green vegetable gardens
From which our people can eat, Mamphela Ramphele, Ellen Khuzwayo
Or would the names of the women
Who marched, suffered solitary confinement
and house arrests
Helen Joseph, Amina Cachalia, Sonya Bunting, Dorothy Nyembe,
Thoko Mngoma, Florence Matomela, Bertha Mkhize,
How many more names come to mind
As I remember the Defiance Campaign
The fights against Beer Halls that suck the strength of our men
Building of alternative schools away from Bantu Education
And the fight against pass laws
Maybe, maybe, I would choose a name
Just one special name that spells out light
That of Mama Nokukhanya Luthuli
Maybe if I were to call out her name
From the top of the hill
While the moon is shining bright;
No — Ku — Kha — nya!
NO — KU — KHA — NYA!!!
To reach all the other women
Whose names are not often mentioned
The ones who sell oranges and potatoes
So their children can eat and learn
The ones who scrub floors and polish executive desktops in towering office blocks While the city sleeps
The ones who work in overcrowded hospitals
Saving lives, cleaning bullet wounds and delivering new babies
And the ones who have given up
Their places of comfort and the protection of their skin colour Marian Sparg,
Sheena Duncan,
Barbara Hogan, Jenny Schreiner.
And what of the women who are stranded in the homelands
With a baby in the belly and a baby on the back
While their men are sweating in the bowels of the earth?
May the lives of all these women
Be celebrated and made to shine
When I cry out Mama Nokukhanya’s name
NO — KU — KHA — NYA!!!
And we who are young, salute our mothers
Who have given us
The heritage of their Queendom!!!
Gcina Mhlophe
A FEDSAW poster commemorating the role of South African women in the struggle for freedom. Taken from Celebrating Women in South African History.
MONITORING LOG OF LA DUMA – GRADE 12C
DATE | ACTIVITY | COMMENT |
JANUARY 2014 | Commenced | Key question finalised |
FEBRUARY | FIRST DRAFT
| References in bibliography include a variety of sources: books, magazine articles, interviews, etc. |
APRIL | SECOND DRAFT
| Draft was submitted. Comments made by teacher and returned to learner for re-working. |
MAY | SUBMIT FINAL COPY | |
JULY | FEEDBACK | Project was moderated at three levels: School, cluster and district. |
AUGUST | Presentation of projects to school and community. |
TEACHER’S NAME: Mrs BA Starr
TEACHER’S SIGNATURE:___________________________________
LEARNER’S SIGNATURE:_____________________________________
SCHOOL STAMP:
|
INTRODUCTION
This research project examines the role played by women during the liberation struggle and attempts to answer the question of how different the role of women was to that of men during the struggle against apartheid. Albertina Sisulu, one of the most important leaders of the anti-apartheid resistance, has argued that women fought ‘side-by side’ with men; but she also suggested that they were particularly vulnerable to oppression because of their role as mothers and wives. This research assignment presents evidence which supports Albertina Sisulu’s statement. In answering this question, I have studied a variety of sources. These sources include books by historians, documents, oral sources, the Internet and other media. My approach is to look at the strategies employed by a selection of dedicated women who played a key role in the liberation struggle.
In The Women’s Federation March of 1956, Lilian Ngoyi, is singled out as one of the significant leaders who represented the struggle of millions of black South African women.
‘She found herself, as do millions of black women across the land, the victim of both race and sex discrimination. She demonstrated that it was possible not only to transcend the limits imposed on her in this way, but that the struggle in South Africa could not be successfully waged unless women and women’s issues constituted a central part of liberation strategy. Neither the state with all its might, nor morality could really silence these phenomenal women’
(Human, M., Mutloatse, M. & Masiza, J. 2006:62).
This statement is the starting point of my research assignment. It has been said that during apartheid millions of black South African women faced the triple oppression of being black, being women and being poor. This research assignment shows how some women challenged the social convention that women should look after the home, and men should be the authority figure and play a central role in politics. The women discussed in this assignment demonstrated that during the apartheid years, women not only played a key role as wives and mothers but also as political activists and anti-apartheid campaigners. In addition, although there was no feminist movement in South Africa in the apartheid period, sometimes black and white women did unite to fight against apartheid, for example, the anti-pass protest in 1956 organised by the non-racial Federation of South African Women (FEDSAW).
I seek to identify how South African women fought to overcome the many challenges and limitations imposed on them because of their gender as well as by the repressive policies of the National Party government.
BACKGROUND
The resistance by black women to racial inequality in South Africa began long before apartheid was officially introduced in 1948. As early as 1912, women were involved in a passive resistance campaign in support of the black and Indian miners who were striking for better wages and improved working conditions. Also, in 1913, in the Free State, black and Coloured women resisted the carrying of passes.
In 1918, Charlotte Maxeke established the Bantu Women’s League to resist the pass laws. The reason they joined the Bantu Women’s League and not the ANC was due to the fact that women were not allowed to be members of the ANC at that time. The resistance of women to the racially discriminating laws continued into the 1930s. The activism of women took on a new dimension when women were finally permitted to join the ANC in 1943. In addition, they formed the ANC’s Women’s League and Ida Mtwana became the first president.
In 1948, the National Party government came to power and introduced the policy of apartheid in South Africa. During the apartheid years (1948–1994), South Africa was a divided society where people’s status and rights were determined by their race. It was a country where the minority white government passed laws to segregate and discriminate against the majority black population. This policy included laws such as the Population Registration Act that classified all South Africans according to race and the Group Areas Act that forced people to live in racially segregated areas. There were many women who reacted with anger, frustration and outrage at these unfair and unjust laws. Many of these women became anti-apartheid activists and their resistance to apartheid cost them dearly.
During the 1950s, women became more militant and in 1952, the Defiance Campaign drew many women into civil disobedience and activism against the unjust apartheid laws. Partly in response to their experiences during the Defiance Campaign, a new women’s organisation was established in 1954. The Federation of South African Women (FEDSAW) united women of all racial groups, from various organisations, including the ANC, the SAIC (South African Indian Congress), the Non-European United Front, various trade unions and civic associations. This was a multi-racial women’s organisation which included teachers, nurses and factory workers as well as housewives. These women pledged to draw up a Women’s Charter to end inequality. This Women’s Freedom Charter began with the words:
‘We, the women of South Africa, wives and mothers, working women and housewives, African, Indian, European and Coloured, hereby declare our aims of striving for the removal of all laws, regulations, conventions and customs that discriminate against us as women and that deprive us in any way of our inherent right to the advantages, responsibilities and opportunities that society offers to any one section of the population.’
In 1956 FEDSAW jointly organised a 20 000 strong march to the Union Buildings in Pretoria to protest against the extension of the pass laws to African women. Although this campaign did not lead to a repeal of the pass laws, the show of strength and unity by women encouraged other women to continue the struggle. In the decades that followed women continued to persevere and pursue the dream of equality and a democratic South Africa.
BODY OF ESSAY
The men and women involved in the liberation struggle paid a heavy price for democracy and freedom:
‘These were people who sacrificed families, homes, communities and incomes. They weren’t home for bedtimes and quality time. They weren’t there to talk after a bad day. They missed their parents’ funerals and cousins’ weddings. Freedom was won by those that dreamt up a maybe, an element of uncertainty, a risk’ (Naidoo, P., 2002:12).
This research assignment focuses on ‘these people’. In particular, it focuses on the women who sacrificed time with their children and families to pursue the struggle against apartheid. I intend to show how these women stepped out of their conventional domestic roles to play an important part in the liberation movement in South Africa. Through their experiences we can better understand that political freedom in South Africa has come at a cost.
Women played many different roles in the struggle. They raised their own children and the children of others, held down jobs and maintained households. They also defended the oppressed, established new organisations, supported the families of political prisoners and those in detention. They helped to establish organisations, hospitals, colleges and institutes, assisted the unemployed, obtained scholarships for the underprivileged, organised protests, attended conferences, travelled abroad, lectured. They were banned, placed under house arrest, detained, imprisoned and in some cases were killed for demanding democracy and equal rights for all South Africans.
Albertina Sisulu, was one such woman. She was a nurse, a mother, a wife and became one of the most important anti-apartheid political activists, earning her the title ‘Mother of the Nation’ for her selfless dedication to the liberation struggle. She took on leadership positions in both the ANC Women’s League and the Federation of South African Women.
Albertina Sisulu became the first woman to be arrested under the General Laws Amendment Act and was jailed for two months, during which she was harassed and taunted psychologically. She was placed in solitary confinement in 1981 and 1985, banned and subjected to house arrest. The book, Winnie Mandela, A Life, recounts Albertina Sisulu’s support of Winnie Mandela in prison:
‘As a result of the appalling conditions and the shock of her situation, she started haemorrhaging. Terrified that she was having a miscarriage, Winnie sank to her knees and buried her head in her hands. Albertina Sisulu, a trained midwife, realised that something was terribly wrong, and pushed the women surrounding Winnie out of the way so that there was enough room for her to lie down. Albertina took off her own jacket and wrapped it around Winnie to keep her warm, and gave strict instructions that she was not to move. The simple, basic care paid off, and Winnie’s baby was saved’
(Du Preez Bezdrob, 2003:78)
This was an unwavering act of compassion. It also shows the vulnerability of women activists during their fight for freedom.
As a ‘negotiator’ in the political arena, Albertina Sisulu established international networks and support bases for the anti-apartheid movement. In the late 1980s she led a delegation of the United Democratic Front (UDF) leaders to Europe to meet British Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher, and to the USA to meet US President, George Bush Sr. to gain support for the liberation movement. In 1994, Albertina Sisulu served as a member of parliament in South Africa’s first democratic government. These examples from Sisulu’s life story illustrate the role that women played as activists, but also show that at times women experienced their oppression differently to men.
Another woman who played a key role in the liberation struggle was Fatima Meer. Born in Durban, Meer was the daughter of an ordinary shop assistant, journalist and editor of Indian Views. Durban is a multi-cultural city and Meer established the Durban and District Women’s League to promote good relations between Indians and Africans and through this organisation initiated a number of social-welfare projects.
In 1946 Fatima Meer participated in the passive resistance campaign organised by the South African Indian Congress against apartheid laws. In 1952 she took part in the Defiance Campaign which had been inspired by SAIC’s earlier campaign and four years later in the women’s anti-pass campaign.
Fatima Meer was also a close friend of Nelson and Winnie Mandela and served six months in detention with Winnie Mandela because of her involvement with the Black Women’s Federation. In her book, Higher than Hope, Fatima Meer recalled that Nelson Mandela did not even discuss some of his decisions with his family, but took it for granted that their support would be unconditional. Therefore, women also need to be acknowledged for the supporting role they played and the way they suffered as a result of their husbands’ and fathers’ involvement in resisting the apartheid government.
Like many of her male comrades, Fatima Meer was banned from 1952 to 1954 under the Suppression of Communism Act. Her banning orders restricted her movements and she could not publish or engage in any political activity.
During the 1960s Fatima Meer lectured in the sociology departments at the Universities of Natal and the Witwatersrand (this in itself was a noteworthy achievement for a woman at that time), and took a particular interest in education. In 1953 the Black Education Act was introduced by HF Verwoerd. This Act had a devastating impact on the South African black population as it delivered an unequal, inferior education system. Black children were educated to become unskilled labour and to remain inferior in apartheid society. Meer was aware that there was a high illiteracy rate among Africans, both in townships and rural schools where children had little access to formal education. In order to address the desperate need for education among the African population, she initiated school building programmes in Umlazi, Port Shepstone, Phambili and Inanda. She also established a craft centre in Phoenix and later founded the Khanyisa school project for African children and the Tembelihle Tutorial College to train African students in secretarial skills and established a craft centre for the unemployed to teach them sewing and knitting. Meer’s projects helped to empower black women by teaching them skills that allowed them to become self-sufficient and self-employed in order to better support their families.
It is clear that Meer channelled much of her human resources into trying to improve the quality of education amongst black South African children and saw that this was important to help realise the dream of a South African democracy.
Another great woman activist was Lilian Masediba Ngoyi. She was the daughter of a miner and a domestic worker. She played a significant role in the struggle as a teacher, an activist, a treason trialist, a trade unionist, a founding member of FEDSAW and later became president of the ANC Women’s League. Ezekiel Mphahlele described her as ‘the woman factory worker who is tough granite on the outside, but soft and compassionate deep down in her...’ (Human, M.; Mutloatse & Masiza,J., 2006:63).
Lilian Ngoyi also played a pivotal role during the Defiance Campaign when she was arrested for using a post office reserved for whites only. The prominent presence of women during this campaign, alongside their male counterparts, strengthened the unity that existed in the struggle against repression in South Africa.
As a founding member of the Federation of South African Women (FEDSAW), she played a key role in organising the anti-pass demonstration to Pretoria in 1956. The introduction of passes for women was an attack on women’s domestic roles, their ability to look after their children and their homes, which forced many into political activism. In a letter to government, FEDSAW stated the following:
‘At a Congress of Mothers held in Johannesburg in August 1955, the many women present unanimously passed a resolution that a mass deputation of women of all races should be sent to the Union Building … As women, we shall protest particularly against the proposed extension of the pass system to African women and against the housing conditions in which many thousands of African families must live.’
During the women’s march to the Union buildings on 9 August 1956, the women famously told the Prime Minister Strijdom:
‘WATHINT’ ABAFAZI, WATHINT’ IMBOKOTHO
YOU’VE TAMPERED WITH THE WOMEN
YOU’VE KNOCKED AGAINST A ROCK’
HISTORY SCHOOL-BASED ASSESSMENT EXEMPLARS – 47 CAPS GRADE 12 TEACHER GUIDE
Albert Luthuli, former president of the ANC, described the strength of women during the anti-pass march to Pretoria by saying:
‘Our women have played a major part in conferences and demonstrations. Furthermore, women of all races have had far less hesitation than men in making common cause about things basic to them’ (Luthuli, A., 2006:188).
This was an example where women of all races united to resist the repressive apartheid government. This point of view was reinforced by Albertina Sisulu when she said:
‘Well, the 9th of August to us was an eye-opener. In the sense, that we thought that men could really be the people to carry reference books. But when it turned to us, we felt it’s something else now. So, all we had to do was to rally the women against you, you know accepting the reference books for women. Because we said, you know, we have got our reference books, our children to look after we just had no business and did not have any business to carry passes like men. We have seen the problem, what the passes have done to our men – being arrested at work and you are waiting for him. Let us say no to the reference books’
(Human, M.; Mutloatse & Masiza, J., 2006:113).
Lillian Ngoyi was arrested in 1956 for high treason. She spent a significant amount of time in solitary confinement. An extract from her biography highlights the price that she paid for her activism against the apartheid regime:
‘The authorities were determined to silence Lillian and, in 1962 she was given further restrictions, confining her to her suburb of Orlando in Soweto. She survived as best she could, sewing from home. The Special Branch (Security Police) would try to scare away her customers by threatening them with prison, or accusing them of subversive activities …’
(Quoted in Bottaro, J.; Visser, P. & Worden, N., 2012:206).
For Ngoyi’s selfless struggle in fighting against the apartheid regime the ANC awarded her the prestigious Isitwalandwe/Seaparankoe Award.
One of the other leaders in the 1956 women’s march to Pretoria was Helen Joseph. Born in England, Joseph came to South Africa as a teacher in 1931. After leaving to serve in the Air Force in World War II, she returned and worked with the Garment Workers Union as a Social Welfare Officer. Here she met Solly Sachs, who was a communist hated by Afrikaner nationalists for organising young Afrikaans women into a multi-racial Garment Workers’ Union. Joseph also joined the South African Congress of Democrats (SACOD), an organisation that was affiliated to the ANC and encouraged white activism against apartheid.
Before moving to South Africa, Joseph had worked as a teacher in India and came to embrace the meaning behind the Hindu greeting ‘namaste’ (the God in me honours the God in you). If God is in everyone, how could we ever discriminate, or fail to help those who are harmed? This philosophy influenced her to act against the inequalities of apartheid.
Helen Joseph had the opportunity to read out the clauses of the Freedom Charter at the Congress of the People and played a key role in the formation of FEDSAW and the women’s march in 1956. Alongside other anti-apartheid activists, Joseph was arrested and charged with high treason and banned in 1957. While in prison she suffered great hardship and humiliation at the hands of the government officials, which she faced with courage, and single minded determination. The evidence below illustrates the strength and commitment of these women in the struggle for freedom.
From the police cells, the women were moved to the Fort, the prison in Braamfontein which was totally unprepared for the sudden influx of so many awaiting-trial prisoners. There were not enough blankets, sleeping mats, toilets or food for the women, who milled around in the main hall and on a second-floor balcony while waiting to be processed. They were lined up in groups, ordered to undress, and told to squat so that warders could conduct vaginal searches for contraband. Then the women were told to dress again and shown to the cells – filthy, stinking and lice-riddled. (Du Preez Bezdrob, 2003:77)
In the book, Winnie Mandela A Life, we come across the strength shown by Helen Joseph and others who endured difficult circumstances in their fight for liberation. She became a good friend of Winnie Mandela and was regarded as a mother figure. She provided advice and support for others. Therefore, we can appreciate her role as adviser and friend. Helen Joseph, together with the Anglican Church, arranged for those who could not be visited to be sent money by postal order from family members. Her role can be seen as a humanitarian reaching out to those in distress. Helen Joseph was awarded the ANC’s highest award Isitwalandwe/Seaparankoe medal to symbolise integrity and courage.
The youngest leader of the 1956 Woman’s march was Sophie Williams. Born in Port Elizabeth, she went to work in a textile factory as a young girl. She soon became known for her negotiating skills and was appointed as shop steward within the Textile Workers’ Union. She was identified as a leader while still a teenager and in 1955 was appointed as the full-time organiser for the Coloured People’s Congress in Johannesburg. In the 1960s Williams followed her husband, Benny de Bruyn, into exile where she worked for the ANC in Zambia and Tanzania. After years of activism in exile, Williams returned to South Africa in 1990 when opposition parties were unbanned. Her role in the struggle had taken a different path to that of those women who had remained in South Africa but she continued to play a role in the struggle for a democratic South Africa.
CONCLUSION
In answering the key question on how different the role of women was to that of men during the apartheid struggle, I have highlighted the roles played by some of the most significant South African women. In attempting to do this, I looked at the strategies they employed and the different forms of protest undertaken by women as compared to that of men. There were many other women who played an important role in the liberation struggle, for example Ray Alexander, Elizabeth Mafekeng, Frances Baard, Mabel Balfour, Mary Moodley, Liz Abrahams, Viola Hashe, Rita Ndzanga and Phylis Naidoo. Many other women, ordinary mothers, wives and workers who were not known outside their communities, the unsung heroines of the struggle, also played a very important role. Due to space constraints I have been unable to discuss more examples in this research project.
I have identified how various South African women challenged the National Party government and, in the end, succeeded. In his book, Let My People Go, Albert Luthuli portrays African women as ‘a formidable enemy of the oppression’ (Luthuli, A., 2006:187). In my research assignment, it is evident that the strength and determination shown by women, inspired and encouraged their husbands, brothers, sons and comrades who fought alongside them during the struggle for freedom and challenged the National Party government. Luthuli made the prophetic observation:
There will be enormous, peaceful change in South Africa before the end of this century. People of all races will eventually live together in harmony because no one, white, black or brown wants to destroy this beautiful land of ours. Women must play an increasingly important role in all areas of the life of the future. They were and remain the most loyal supporters in all our struggles. (Luthuli, A, 2006: p.xxii)
This quotation is from of one of our four South African Nobel Prize winners and acknowledges the significant role played by women in all spheres of life. During the apartheid years women undertook various multi-tasking roles – as wives, mothers, workers and activists. Their roles played in the liberation struggle must never be forgotten. South Africa salutes all women.
EVALUATION AND REFLECTION
I have learnt a lot from writing this assignment. I did not know that women had played such a large role in the struggle or that they had suffered so much. Writing this research project was very difficult and I had to organise my time very well. I used the local library and it took a long time to read and organise my notes. My teacher made useful comments on both my first and second drafts of this project which gave me direction and focus. I reorganised material and tried harder to use the life stories of the women I had chosen to study to answer the key question. I think I should have said more about these women’s family lives as well but it was quite difficult to find information and I ran out of space and time. I enjoyed researching and writing this assignment, although it took up a great deal of time.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Angier, K. (et al), Viva History Grade 12: Learner’s Book. (Johannesburg: Vivlia, 2013).
Bottaro, J.; Visser, P. & Worden, N., In Search of History. Grade 11. Learner’s Book. (Cape Town: Maskew Miller Longman (Pty) Ltd, 2012).
Du Preez Bezdrob, A.M., Winnie Mandela a life. (Paarl: Paarl Printers, 2003).
Friedman, M.; Saunders, C.; Jacobs, M.; Seleti, Y.; & Gordon, J., Looking into the Past. Grade 11 Learner’s Book. (Cape Town: CTP Printers, 2011).
Human, M.; Mutloatse, M.; Masiza, J., The Women’s Freedom March of 1956. (Johannesburg: Pan McMillan (Pty Ltd), 2006).
Light, J. & Johanneson, B., Celebrating Women in South African History (www.sahistory.org.za,) (DBE, 2012).
Luthuli, A., Let My People Go, The Autobiography of Albert Luthuli. (Paarl: Paarl Printers, 2006).
Naidoo, P., Footprints in Grey Street. (Durban: Ocean Jetty Publishing, 2002).
Pillay, G. (et al), New Generation History Grade 12: Learner’s Book. (Durban: Interpak Printers, 2013).
Shaw, G., Believe in miracles, South Africa from Malan to Mandela - and the Mbeki era. (Paarl: Paarl Printers, 2007).
Retrieved from: http://heritage. The times.co.za/memorials/gp/Lilian Ngoyi/article on 4 June 2013.
Retrieved from: http:// www.sahistory.org.za/people/professor Fatima Meer on 4 June 2013.
Retrieved from: http:// www.sahistory.org.za/people/lillian-masediba-ngoyi on 4 June 2013.
ASSESSMENT RUBRIC
CRITERIA | LEVEL DESCRIPTORS | |||
LEVEL 4 | LEVEL 3 | LEVEL 2 | LEVEL 1 | |
Criterion 1 | 8 – 10 | 5 - 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Planning (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of planning (clear research schedule provided). | Shows adequate understanding of planning. | Shows some evidence of planning. | Shows little or no evidence of planning. |
Criterion 2 | 16 – 20 | 10 - 15 | 5 – 9 | 0 – 4 |
Identify and access a variety of sources of information (20 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. | Shows adequate understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. | Shows some understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. | Shows little or no understanding of identifying and accessing sources of information. |
Criterion 3 | 8 – 10 | 5 – 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Knowledge and understanding of the period (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent knowledge and understanding of the period | Shows adequate knowledge and understanding of the period. | Shows some knowledge and understanding of the period. | Shows little or no knowledge and understanding of the period. |
Criterion 4 | 24 – 30 | 14 – 23 | 7 – 13 | 0 – 6 |
Historical enquiry, interpretation & communication (Essay) (30 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. | Shows adequate understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. | Shows some understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. | Shows little or no understanding of how to write a coherent argument from the evidence collected. |
Criterion 5 | 8 – 10 | 5 – 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Presentation (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). | Shows adequate evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). | Shows some evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). | Shows little or no evidence of how to present researched information in a structured manner (e.g. cover page, table of contents, research topic). |
Criterion 6 | 8 – 10 | 5 - 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Evaluation & reflection (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from undertaking research). | Shows adequate understanding of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from under taking research). | Shows some evidence of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from undertaking research). | Shows little or no evidence of evaluating and reflecting on the research assignment process (e.g. what the candidate has learnt from undertaking research). |
Criterion 7 | 8 – 10 | 5 - 7 | 3 – 4 | 0 – 2 |
Acknowledgement of sources (10 marks) | Shows thorough/ excellent understanding of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). | Shows adequate understanding of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). | Shows some evidence of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). | Shows little or no evidence of acknowledging sources (e.g. footnotes, references, plagiarism). |
TOTAL = 85/100
NAME OF LEARNER:_____________________________________
GRADE: ________________________
FINAL MARK ALLOCATION
Criteria | TOTAL MARKS | LEARNER’S MARKS |
Criterion 1 | 10 | 8 |
Criterion 2 | 20 | 18 |
Criterion 3 | 10 | 8 |
Criterion 4 | 30 | 25 |
Criterion 5 | 10 | 8 |
Criterion 6 | 10 | 8 |
Criterion 7 | 10 | 10 |
TOTAL | 100 | 85 |
COMMENTS:
This is a well-researched and well-written piece of research – excellent work. You made a very good attempt to formulate and sustain a line of argument with regard to the key question. You used a variety of sources to substantiate the line of argument, which is excellent.
However, this research assignment could have been strengthened if relevant visual sources were used, at the appropriate points, to supplement your historical narrative. Finally, although you link back to the key question in places, you tend to focus on the separate struggles of women and not when they fought ‘side-by-side’ with men as stated in the question. I am glad that you enjoyed this research project. Well done!
TEACHER’S SIGNATURE:____________________________________
DATE: ___________________________________________________
7. GUIDELINES FOR LEARNERS AND TEACHERS:
EXEMPLAR RESPONSES: SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS
QUESTION 1
1.1
1.1.1 The apartheid government supported UNITA (National Union for the Total Independence of Angola) during the Angolan Civil War. ✔
1.1.2 Angolan economic installations targeted by the SA Defence force were the oil and railway and port installations; iron mines and electricity lines and factories.✔ ✔✔✔
1.1.3 The apartheid government felt threatened by the MPLA because it was multi-racial, therefore undermined the social and racial policies of apartheid. ✔✔ Secondly, it supported ANC training bases openly, thereby supporting the SA liberation groups which sought to destroy the apartheid regime, i.e. supported the enemies of the SA apartheid government✔✔. Thirdly, the MPLA supported SWAPO, the Namibian liberation group which was fighting the SA forces in South West Africa and seeking political liberation from the domination of SA✔✔
1.1.4 During the Angolan Civil War, the SA army invaded Angola in support of the UNITA (Pro-capitalist) rebel group which sought to overthrow the governing MPLA government. The SA army reached an area close to the capital and UNITA forces followed behind them, capturing towns where the SA forces had overthrown and defeated the local MPLA ruling groups. Therefore, the country was in danger of a total coup by the SA backed pro-capitalist UNITA forces. In this context, the MPLA government had no choice but to seek aid from the Communist bloc in order to stop the invasion of SA troops and the defeat of the MPLA by UNITA. ✔✔✔
1.2
1.2.1 The message conveyed by the cartoon is that the USSR, portrayed as SANTA in his sleigh, is generously supplying arms to the MPLA as SANTA generously brings presents at Christmas time. ✔✔ These weapons will be used to destroy the UNITA and FNLA forces in the Angolan civil war - as there is a pun on the word ‘sleigh’-it is written as ‘slay’, i.e. to kill✔✔.
1.2.2 It may, to a large extent, be regarded as biased as it comes from the cartoon archives of Great Britain, who supported capitalism and democracy during the Cold War era when the Angolan civil war took place ✔✔. It therefore portrays the USSR in a negative light as an ‘evil SANTA’ bringing weapons to cause death and destruction in its bid to spread communism in Africa in its support of African political groups. ✔✔
1.3
1.3.1 The Soviet Union ✔and Cuba✔
1.3.2 It is an economic system whereby the government controls all the means of production, where free enterprise is forbidden and individual freedom is less important than the interests of the community. ✔✔
1.3.3 Vorster felt that black Angolans were being exploited by the desires of communist Cuba to spread communism in Angola ✔✔ and therefore were not being supported in their bid for independence as black Angolans. He felt the Cubans would be likely to stay in Angola in order to use Angola as a springboard or basis from which to spread communism to other African countries in the region and so continue to influence Angola’s policies. ✔✔
1.3.4 The Angolan Civil War took place during the Cold War when capitalist and Communist ideologies were in conflict in various parts of the world. In South Africa the government represented SWAPO and ANC as communists, and communism was portrayed as anti-Christian and undemocratic. Vorster uses the term ‘communist’ repeatedly in this interview to justify South African involvement in the Angolan civil war. ✔✔
1.4
1.4.1 ‘terrorists’ ✔; ‘barbarian’ ✔
1.4.2 The SABC justified their deaths by making it appear as though they had died fighting a ‘holy war’ in order to protect and maintain civilisation and preserve Christian values ✔✔ and prevent the take-over of SWA by the ‘barbarian’ SWAPO ‘terrorists’, bent on causing death and destruction. ✔✔
1.4.3 Source 1D would be very useful to a historian researching the use of propaganda, as the source shows the use of negative, emotive words such as ‘terrorist’ and ‘barbarian’ when describing SWAPO. ✔✔ It also shows how the SA defence force’s participation and invasion of Angola is justified as a ‘holy war’ fought to protect Christian values and maintain civilisation. It shows how the SA public was indoctrinated to support the actions of the SA defence forces as morally correct ✔✔ (rather than revealing their main aim to be defence of the white minority rule in South Africa and Namibia).
1.5 South Africa became involved in the Angolan Civil War in an attempt to remove the Marxist MPLA party which had established themselves as the government after the Portuguese colonists withdrew from Angola in 1974. SA wanted to create a pro-capitalist independent African country on its border as it would not be likely to support the ANC and SWAPO and allow their training bases on Angolan soil. Therefore, SA invaded Angola after independence, supporting UNITA in the civil war which had broken out before elections could be held. South Africa wanted to establish a pro-capitalist government in Angola which would support the capitalist apartheid government in SA. A conventional war was waged in Angola and its economic infrastructure was destroyed in order to weaken the MPLA government and allow the UNITA movement to take over. As the MPLA approached the communist Eastern bloc for help in this situation, SA promoted itself as the bastion of Christian values and civilisation and its invasion of Angola as a legitimate war to protect the Southern African region from ‘terrorists’ and ‘barbarians’, as the MPLA was openly supportive of ANC and SWAPO bases in Angola. ✔✔✔✔✔✔✔✔
Level 3
QUESTION 2
2.1
2.1.1 From 15 to 18 April 1996. √
In East London.√
2.1.2 It means to bring people of different races together after the atrocities of apartheid. √√
2.1.3 The TRC chose the slogan ‘healing the past’ because the gross human rights violations that many, especially, black South Africans had experienced could not be forgotten. It had to be investigated so that ‘victims’ and ‘perpetrators’ could face each other, which would ultimately bring about a process of healing. √√
2.1.4 It was significant because for the first time in post-apartheid South Africa a real effort was made to deal with South Africa’s painful past so that a united nation could be formed. √√√
2.2
2.2.1 Dirk Coetzee√, Almond Nofomela, √ David Tshikilange√
2.2.2 Griffiths Mxenge was beaten, stabbed and struck on the head with a wheel spanner. √√ He fell to the ground and died because of these serious wounds. √√
2.2.3 In terms of the law, the sentencing of the three apartheid operatives was postponed because the TRC had not made a final decision. √√
The TRC was waiting for the Amnesty Committee to tell it what to do regarding the three apartheid operatives. √√
2.3
2.3.1 The TRC was satisfied with the reasons given by the three apartheid operatives for committing heinous human rights violations because they were politically motivated. They were acting under direct orders from a few National Party leaders and further that they were engaged in the struggle against the ANC. √√
2.3.2 Amnesty was granted to all three policemen and it was therefore not necessary for the trial court to proceed with the question of sentencing. √√
2.4 The sources would be useful for the following reasons:
2.5
2.5.1 They opposed Coetzee’s application for amnesty, saying that it would be a travesty of justice. √√ 2.5.2 They felt that Coetzee and his co-accused did not meet the criteria for amnesty. √√
They also felt that there was no evidence to suggest that killing their political opponents fell within the course and scope of their duties as members of the security police. √√
2.6
2.6.1 Mamdani felt that the focus of the TRC was too narrow and it did not take the sufferings of the ‘victims’ seriously. √√
2.6.2 The TRC could have informed white South Africans that many of them had actually benefitted from apartheid. √√
2.6.3 For Mamdani, the TRC was not concerned about real reconciliation and nation building. It only focused on individual cases and therefore lost its relevancy for uniting South Africa. √√
He also felt that the emphasis of the TRC was on who gave the orders to kill apartheid activists rather that educating all white South Africans on how they had benefitted from apartheid. √√
2.7 The TRC was not entirely successful in healing South Africa’s past. It was set up by the government to hear testimonies from the perpetrators of human rights violations which had been committed during the apartheid era. This mandate was not fulfilled in its entirety. The TRC did not adequately heal South Africa from its divided past, for example the Mxenge family felt that the granting of amnesty to their brother’s killers was a travesty of justice. They felt that the act of killing Griffiths was reason enough to prosecute them in a court of law. The amnesty committee felt that the apartheid operatives were acting under instructions at the time. Finally, many families of victims were not satisfied with the TRC’s attempt to bring closure to their painful past, hence it was not successful. √√√√√√
Level 2 – Evidence is mostly relevant and largely relates to the topic. Uses evidence in a basic manner. Some gaps in knowledge. [47/50]
QUESTION 3
3.1
3.1.1 Globalisation refers to an integrated system whereby various countries of the world trade with each other to boost their economic and political ties. This is influenced largely by technological advancement.√√
3.1.2 Negative integration√
Positive integration√
3.1.3 This will lead to many developing African countries importing goods such as electronic car parts, clothes, etc. which can be imported at a cheaper price than would be paid for similar goods produced in Africa. √√
The importation of cheap goods would lead to increased unemployment in industries located in African countries. √√
3.2
3.2.1 Free trade√; communication√; outsourcing√
3.2.2 Free trade – For developing economies ‘free trade’ would have a negative impact because governments would not be able to protect the local industries from monopolisation, labour brokers and low wages. √√
Communication and the use of technology – positive effect. It has ensured that international sporting events such as the Soccer, Rugby or Cricket World Cup tournaments that were held in South Africa could be broadcast across various countries throughout the world. √√
Outsourcing - negative impact. Big companies in their quest to increase profits and cut expenditure usually employ non-permanent staff. This leads to the casualisation of labour with negative consequences for workers. √√
3.3
3.3.1 They felt that globalisation would deliver several positive benefits in a number of economic and non-economic areas. √√
3.3.2 Free trade√
Benefits in a number of economic and non-economic areas. √
3.3.3 This survey was only conducted in the mainly ‘Group of 20’ countries which are in Europe, North America and Asia. The views of people from many other countries have not been considered. √√√
3.4
3.4.1 Increase in child labour and slavery√; high pollution levels√;
the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer√;
fast food is making people unhealthy√
3.4.2 Globalisation has led to the creation of monopolies and this has resulted in an unfair distribution of wealth among developed and developing countries. √√
3.5 These sources would be useful to a historian studying globalisation for the following reasons:
Source 3C is an opinion poll on globalisation and it provides the views of people from a variety of countries. It provides insight into the views that people in developed and developing countries hold on globalisation. √√
Source 3D offers an insight into the negative aspects of globalisation. √√
3.6
3.6.1 The absence of trade unions in some countries, hence reference to ‘workers voices’ on banner. ‘free economies’ referring to the removal of trade barriers by the WTO which entrench poverty√; global injustice. √
3.6.2 ‘Global injustice’ refers to the injustices faced by people living mainly in developing countries in Africa and elsewhere which they say was caused by the WTO. √√
3.7 The sources 3D and 3E support each other in the following ways:
Source 3A – speaks of the negative impact of globalisation in all countries of the world √√ and Source 3D supports this point of view by showing a visual image of activists protesting against the WTO. √√
3.8 Globalisation involves a worldwide integration of the various economies using the advances made in technology. After the fall of communism in 1989, Russia joined the key developers like USA, Japan and Western Europe in the world of trade and economy. Globalisation has both positive and negative effects on the world. On the positive side, some, mainly developed countries, have benefitted from communication and trade. They have made advances in technology and infrastructure. However, not all countries have benefited from globalisation. Poor and developing countries have not really benefitted from globalisation. They face poverty, exploitation, child labour and under-development. There is a growing digital divide between countries with access to new technology and those without. Hence the new world order that globalisation has created has both positive and negative effects. √√√√√
Level 2 – Evidence is mostly relevant and mainly relates to the topic. Uses evidence in a basic manner. Some gaps in knowledge [47/50]
7. GUIDELINES FOR LEARNERS AND TEACHERS:
EXEMPLAR RESPONSES – ESSAY QUESTIONS
QUESTION: 1B: VIETNAM
‘ ... All the military might of a superpower could not defeat a small nation of peasants.’
Critically discuss this statement in the light of the United States of America’s involvement in Vietnam between 1965 and 1975. Use relevant examples to support your answer.
When the USA became involved in Vietnam, it was for all the right reasons in terms of the opinions America held about communists. Because of the USA’s superior resources and technology, they expected that it would be quick victory over North Vietnam. The outcome was very different from their expectations. This essay explains the reasons for the USA’s unexpected defeat.
America became involved in the war against North Vietnam to prevent the spread of communism. As a capitalist country, the USA was against anything communist. They had set it as one of their objectives to do what they could to protect smaller weaker countries from being infiltrated by the communist ideology. The USA feared the domino effect and believed they had a responsibility to protect capitalist South Vietnam from being overtaken by communist North Vietnam, which was being supported by China and the USSR.
The USA believed that it would be an easy war against North Vietnam. They had superior resources at their disposal, sophisticated weapons, and innovative technology. It was meant to be over and done with quickly. No one could have foreseen what awaited them. One reason for the USA’s defeat was that Vietnam is a dense, jungle country, which didn’t give the Americans much opportunity to use their highly advanced weapons, let alone move along smoothly. The North Vietnamese adopted tactics and warfare that used this to their advantage.
The North Vietnamese were fighting to maintain their independence. They wanted to unite North and South Vietnam into one communist country. Many people in South Vietnam supported the North Vietnamese – these were called the Viet Cong. The Vietnamese were seasoned veterans, having fought a successful war against French colonialism and Japanese occupation during World War II. They used guerrilla tactics against the US troops such as booby traps, hit-and-run, and their ability to blend with the civilians frustrated the US troops greatly and led to much loss of life for the US. In contrast, the US army had mostly inexperienced conscripted soldiers. The average age of a US soldier fighting in Vietnam was 19 years. The US troops soon lost hope and morale, because they were fighting a war for a country that didn’t belong to them and for a cause they did not believe in.
The great loss of life and the hopeless situation, also resulted in criticism and lack of support back home. There were protests to end the war and return the young men home. The Vietnam war was the first war to be televised. Images of burning villages and dying civilians were broadcast into ordinary Americans homes and they lost support for the war. Demonstrations and rallies were held across the USA, which criticised the war and the government.
The US, in their frustration, employed unorthodox measures to gain the upper hand. They used things like napalm on enemy soldiers. Civilians at home were also on the receiving end, as this napalm burned to cinders whatever it came into contact with. They used chemicals like Agent Orange which was a defoliant to clear the leaves off trees to prevent the Viet Cong from using them as cover. It was later proved that this Agent Orange was the cause of cancers and birth defects that became widespread in Vietnam. For all these things America received much criticism from the world and people lost respect for them as a country that stood for good, especially as a result of brutal scenes involving citizens.
America eventually lost the war and so their objective to curb the spread of communism was not realised. The war effort had cost a great deal, not only in material resources but also in lives lost. The war having been lost, many people were critical of America and its involvement. They saw the loss of lives and resources to have been part of the atrocities committed in Vietnam and many veterans regretted having fought in Vietnam.
The USA had expected to win a quick victory against North Vietnam, but despite superior weapons they lost to one of the smallest countries in the world. There were a number of reasons why the USA lost this war but the loss of support from the American population and the determination of the Vietnamese people to win their independence played a significant role.
Comments:
C | L7 |
P | L7 |
[50/50]
QUESTION 5A: THE NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT AND THE GOVERNMENT OF NATIONAL UNITY
Allister Sparks argues that the process of negotiation ‘was always a crisis-driven process’.
Critically assess Allister Sparks’ statement with reference to the process of negotiation in South Africa between 1990 and 1994.
Allister Sparks’ assertion that the process of negotiations was ‘crisis-driven’ is to a large extent accurate. The years 1990 to 1994 were a turbulent political journey. The release of Mandela and political prisoners (1990) in conjunction with other positive social reforms set the negotiating process in motion. However, for every achievement of the negotiating process, there was a violent event that jeopardised its foundation. Yet negotiations and settlement persevered and in just four short years the country moved from a policy of division to one of democracy. The ANC and the NP were the main role-players in the process but many other organisations were involved as well.
Talks began on 2 May 1990 between Mandela (ANC) and De Klerk (NP). The main aim of these talks was to outline the principles for the release of political prisoners and the granting of indemnity for those in exile. A working group was established and a broad agreement known as the Groote Schuur Minute was signed. Talks would continue later. However, violence occurred at Sebokeng when the Inkatha hostel dwellers planned a raid on ANC supporters. Thirty people were killed. The police were warned about the attack but did nothing to stop it. There was evidence of ‘third force’ involvement. This threatened to break down talks completely. However, the negotiating process forged ahead and the Pretoria Minute was subsequently signed. Mandela announced the suspension of the armed struggle and the NP would lift the state of emergency in South Africa. However, violence among the ANC, NP and Inkatha continued.
The Convention for a Democratic South Africa (CODESA) was established in 1991 and pertained to the principles of the new constitution. Talks were held at the World Trade Centre in Kempton Park (19 groups represented) and agreement was reached. The interim constitution would be drafted by a multi-party conference, and the final constitution by the first elected parliament. The Declaration of Intent was signed to pledge all parties’ commitment to the negotiating process.
CODESA 2 was held in 1992 but talks failed as parties could not agree to the interim government in terms of the new constitution. Another violent event occurred. The Boipatong massacre occurred when Inkatha hostel dwellers again attacked ANC supporters. Forty-nine people were killed and it was alleged that Inkatha members were helped by the police. The ANC decided to walk out of CODESA 2 and began a campaign of ‘rolling mass action’ in order to put pressure on the government to agree to its conditions. The fear of civil war now became a reality and it became clear to political role players that there was an urgent need to restart negotiations. This led to the Record of Understanding.
Secret talks were held between the NP and the ANC but violence again flared up, in Bhisho (Ciskei). Unarmed ANC protestors were attacked by the Ciskeian government’s soldiers. Twenty-eight people were killed, resulting in mass action against the NP government.
The deadlock between the NP and the ANC was broken, with the multi-party negotiating process being set up to pick up from where CODESA 2 had left off. This illustrates the level of commitment to reform with which Mandela led the ANC. It symbolised that the ANC was assertive and resolute in their will for positive change in South Africa.
Violence jeopardised the goodwill of the agreement once again. On 10 April 1993, the Chief of Umkhonto we Sizwe, Chris Hani, was murdered. The country was thrust into violent rampages and 70 people were killed in the resulting violence. Mandela was called to address and pacify the nation. This indicates Mandela’s power and presence for peace and stability in the country. Hani’s death created an urgency for negotiations to be finalised.
The negotiated settlement then occurred and resulted in democracy. It stated that parties who won more than 20% of the eligible votes could choose a deputy president and the president would be obliged to consult with the deputies. The election date was decided upon and the appropriate structures were put in place for the approaching general elections. However, not all South Africans accepted the transition to democracy. The Afrikaner weerstandsbeweging (AWB), a right-wing, conservative organisation stormed the World Trade Centre in armoured vehicles and threatened to break down the process of negotiations and demanded a volkstaat. The commitment of the key role players, in particular Nelson Mandela, was the backbone of the negotiations process. Despite violence and disruption, democracy was achieved.
On 27 April 1994, South Africa experienced its first democratic election. Over 20 million people voted. The ANC represented hope and change for the majority of South Africans. The ANC won the elections and Nelson Mandela was inaugurated as the president of South Africa. It is therefore evident that Mandela, being a man of peace and quiet strength, was able to change the country for the better and to embrace democracy. The final constitution was ready for implementation in 1996.
It can therefore be concluded that the years 1990 to 1994 were a mixture of negotiations (Pretoria Minute, CODESA, etc.) and violence (Sebokeng, Boipatong etc.). Yet the country was miraculously able to transcend obstacles and become a rainbow nation with an advanced constitution. While some of the role-players had tried to undermine the negotiations, others had worked hard throughout to bring about a new democratic South Africa.
Comment:
C | L7 |
P | L7 |
[44/50]
8. MARKING GUIDELINES AND RUBRIC
SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS
QUESTION 1
WHY DID SOUTH AFRICA BECOME INVOLVED IN THE ANGOLAN CIVIL WAR IN THE 1980s?
1.1
1.1.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1A – L1]
1.1.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1A – L1]
1.1.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1A - L2]
1.1.4 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1A – L2]
Yes, the MPLA was justified.
1.2
1.2.1 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1B – L2]
1.2.2 [Evaluation of bias in Source 1B – L3]
To a large extent because:
To a lesser extent because:
1.3
1.3.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1C – L1]
1.3.2 [Definition of concept from Source 1C – L1]
1.3.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1C – L2]
1.3.4 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1C – L2]
1.4
1.4.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1D – L1]
1.4.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1D – L1]
1.4.3 [Ascertaining the usefulness of Source 1D – L3]
Very useful because it shows that
1.5 [Interpret, analyse and evaluate information from Sources 1A-D - L3]
Learners need to include the following points in their answer:
Use the following rubric to allocate a mark:
LEVEL 1 |
| Marks: 0–2 |
LEVEL 2 |
| Marks: 3–6 |
LEVEL 3 |
| Marks: 7–8 |
(8)
[50]
QUESTION 2
HOW SUCCESSFUL WAS THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) IN HEALING OUR PAST?
2.1
2.1.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2A – L1]
2.1.2 [Definition of historical concept from Source 2A – L1]
2.1.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2A – L2]
2.1.4 [Interpretation and evaluation of evidence from Source 2A – L3]
2.2
2.2.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1]
2.2.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1]
2.2.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2B – L2]
2.3.1 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2C – L2]
2.3.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2C – L2]
2.4 [Ascertaining the usefulness of evidence from Sources 2B and 2C – L3]
Learners need to make reference to both Sources 2B and 2C in their responses:
2.5
2.5.1 Extraction of evidence from Source 2D – L1]
2.5.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2D – L2]
2.6
2.6.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2E – L1]
2.6.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2E – L2]
2.6.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2E – L2]
2.7 [Interpret, analyse and evaluate information from Sources 2A-D - L3]
Learners need to include the following points in their answer:
Use the following rubric to allocate a mark:
LEVEL 1 |
| Marks: 0–2 |
LEVEL 2 |
| Marks: 3–6 |
LEVEL 3 |
| Marks: 7–8 |
(8)
[50]
QUESTION 3
WHAT IMPACT DID GLOBALISATION HAVE ON THE NEW WORLD ORDER?
3.1
3.1.1 [Definition of concept from Source 3A – L1]
3.1.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3A – L1]
3.1.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3A – L2]
3.2
3.2.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3A – L1]
3.2.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3B – L2]
3.3.
3.3.1 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3C – L2]
3.3.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3C – L1]
3.3.3 [Ascertain the limitations of Source 3C – L3]
3.4
3.4.1 Extraction of evidence from Source 3D – L1]
3.4.2 [Interpretation of Source 3D – L2]
3.5 [Ascertain the usefulness of Sources 3C and 3D – L3]
3.6
3.6.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3E – L1]
3.6.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3E – L2]
3.7 [Compare evidence from Sources 3D and 3E – L2]
3.8 [Interpret, analyse and evaluate information from Sources 3A-E - L3]
Learners need to include the following points in their response:
Use the following rubric to allocate a mark:
LEVEL 1 |
| Marks: 0–2 |
LEVEL 2 |
| Marks: 3–6 |
LEVEL 3 |
| Marks: 7–8 |
(8)
[50]
ESSAY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 1A: CHINA
Discuss to what extent Mao transformed China from an underdeveloped country to a super power from 1949 to 1976.
SYNOPSIS
National strength and the status of nations are measured in economic capacity and military hardware – those countries with the greatest amount of both are considered to be ‘super powers’. Candidates should, therefore, determine to what extent Mao succeeded in developing these two areas between 1949 and 1976. Clear examples must be used to substantiate their argument.
MAIN ASPECTS
Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:
ELABORATION
Land Reform 1949–1976
The economic and industrial development 1949–1976
Foreign policy
Military power
QUESTION 1B: VIETNAM
‘... All the military might of a superpower could not defeat a small nation of peasants.’
Critically discuss this statement in the light of United States of America’s involvement in Vietnam between 1965 and 1975.
Use relevant examples to support your answer.
SYNOPSIS
Candidates must critically discuss the various reasons why the USA failed to win the war against Vietnam despite their superior military might. Clear examples must be used to substantiate their argument.
MAIN ASPECTS
Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:
ELABORATION
USA’s military tactics
Opposition to war in USA
Chinese and USSR support of Viet Cong
Unpopularity of South Vietnamese regime
Determination and skill of Viet Cong compared with US conscripts.
QUESTION 2: CONGO AND TANZANIA
Write a comparative essay on the political successes and challenges that post-colonial leaders of both the Congo and Tanzania faced between the 1960s and the 1980s.
SYNOPSIS
Candidates should undertake a comparative discussion of the political successes and challenges that faced the Congo and Tanzania.
MAIN ASPECTS
Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:
ELABORATION
Leadership in the Congo:
Leadership in Tanzania:
Legacy of Colonialism
Types of government
Political stability and instability
QUESTION: 4: THE CRISIS OF APARTHEID IN THE 1980S
Explain how both internal mass civic resistance and international pressure contributed to the demise of PW Botha’s apartheid regime in the 1980s.
SYNOPSIS
Candidates need to explain how both internal mass civic resistance and international pressure contributed to the demise of PW Botha’s regime in the 1980s. Relevant examples must be used to support their argument.
MAIN ASPECTS
Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:
ELABORATION
QUESTION 5: THE NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT AND THE GOVERNMENT OF NATIONAL UNITY
Allister Sparks argues that the process of negotiation ‘was always a crisis-driven process’.
Critically assess Allister Sparks’ statement with reference to the process of negotiation in South Africa between 1990 and 1994.
SYNOPSIS
Candidates should indicate whether they agree with Sparks’ statement. They should highlight the various challenges that South Africa’s political role players faced during the process of negotiation such as violence, opposing views and political intolerance between 1990 and 1994.
MAIN ASPECTS
Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:
Introduction: Candidates should explain the historical context and take a line of argument with regard to the statement that ‘the process of negotiation was always a crisis-driven process’.
ELABORATION
COGNITIVE LEVELS USED TO SET SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS
CAPS: GRADE 12 ANALYSIS GRID: SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS | |||
QUESTION 1 KEY QUESTION: WHY DID SOUTH AFRICA BECOME INVOLVED IN THE ANGOLAN CIVIL WAR IN THE 1980s? | |||
Question Number | Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 |
1.1.1 | 1 | ||
1.1.2 | 4 | ||
1.1.3 | 6 | ||
1.1.4 | 3 | ||
1.2.1 | 4 | ||
1.2.2 | 4 | ||
1.3.1 | 2 | ||
1.3.2 | 2 | ||
1.3.3 | 4 | ||
1.3.4 | 2 | ||
1.4.1 | 2 | ||
1.4.2 | 4 | ||
1.4.3 | 4 | ||
1.5 | 8 | ||
TOTAL: 50 | 15 | 19 | 16 |
CAPS Cognitive Levels: 100% | 15 (30%) | 20 (40%) | 15 (30%) |
QUESTION 2: KEY QUESTION: HOW SUCCESSFUL WAS THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) IN HEALING OUR PAST? | |||
2.1.1 | 2 | ||
2.1.2 | 2 | ||
2.1.3 | 2 | ||
2.1.4 | 3 | ||
2.2.1 | 3 | ||
2.2.2 | 4 | ||
2.2.3 | 4 | ||
2.3.1 | 2 | ||
2.3.2 | 2 | ||
2.4 | 4 | ||
2.5.1 | 2 | ||
2.5.2 | 4 | ||
2.6.1 | 2 | ||
2.6.2 | 2 | ||
2.6.3 | 4 | ||
2.7 | 8 | ||
TOTAL: 50 | 15 | 20 | 15 |
CAPS Cognitive Levels: 100% | 15 (30%) | 20 (40%) | 15 (30%) |
QUESTION 3 KEY QUESTION: WHAT IMPACT DID GLOBALISATION HAVE ON THE NEW WORLD ORDER? | |||
3.1.1 | 2 | ||
3.1.2 | 2 | ||
3.1.3 | 4 | ||
3.2.1 | 3 | ||
3.2.2 | 6 | ||
3.3.1 | 2 | ||
3.3.2 | 2 | ||
3.3.3 | 3 | ||
3.4.1 | 4 | ||
3.4.2 | 2 | ||
3.5 | 4 | ||
3.6.1 | 2 | ||
3.6.2 | 2 | ||
3.7 | 4 | ||
3.8 | 8 | ||
TOTAL: 50 | 15 | 20 | 15 |
CAPS Cognitive Levels: 100% | 15 (30%) | 20 (40%) | 15 (30%) |
9. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Visual sources and other historical evidence were taken from the following:
BOOKS:
Angier, K. (et al), Viva History Grade 12: Learner’s Book. (Johannesburg: Vivlia, 2013).
Frederikse, J. South Africa: A different kind of war. (London: James Currey, 1987).
Hanlon, J. Beggar your neighbours: Apartheid power in Southern Africa. (London: James Currey, 1986).
Pillay, G. (et al), New Generation History Grade 12: Learner’s book. (Durban: Interpak Printers, 2013).
INTERNET SITES:
http://www.cartoons.ac.uk/search/cartoon_item/angola.
http://www.sahistory.org.za/archive/interview-south-african-prime-minister-mr-b-j-vorster-mr-clarence-rhodesupitn-
tv-13-february.
http://qu301southafrica.com/tag/recon.
www.justice.gov.za/trc/report/ .
www.info.gov.za/speeches/1997/08050w13297.html.
www.justice.gov.za/trc/media/1996/9611/s961105h.html.
http://hubpages.com/hub/Definition-of-Globalization.
http://globalisation.pen.io.
www.globescan.com/news_archives/press_inside.htm.
http://www.buzzle.com/articles/negative-effects-of-globalization.html.
http://content.lib.washington.edu/wtoweb/images/wto-protest.jpg.
ENGLISH FIRST ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE
PAPER 1
GRADE 12
NSC PAST PAPERS AND MEMOS
NOVEMBER 2016
INSTRUCTIONS TO MARKERS
SECTION A: COMPREHENSION
QUESTION 1
1.1
South Africans believe that it is fine to eat fast foods. ✔
South Africans believe that too much attention/emphasis is placed on eating healthily. ✔
They think food that is good for you, cannot taste good. ✔
NOTE: Accept any TWO of the above answers. (2)
1.2
World Action on Salt and Health (WASH). ✔
Heart and Stroke Foundation (of South Africa). ✔ (2)
1.3 'international'✔ (1)
1.4
These are the established/popular brands✔ that sell/serve quick meals/junk food. ✔
OR
The companies/franchises/restaurants✔ that sell the most prepared/ processed meals.✔ (2)
1.5 The studies found that South Africa's popular fast food outlets produce meals for children that have among the highest salt content in the world. Salt contributes to diseases like high blood pressure, strokes, heart attacks and kidney failure. Therefore, South Africans must take the survey seriously so action can be taken in this regard.
NOTE: Accept other suitable responses provided that they are grounded in the text. A candidate can score 1or 2 marks for an answer that is not well-substantiated. (3)
1.6
KFC✔
McDonald's✔
Burger King✔
Subway ✔
NOTE: Accept any TWO of the above answers. (2)
1.7 The salt content✔of the chicken nugget meal sold in South Africa is considerably higher than the same meal sold in the United Kingdom.✔ (2)
1.8
The Department of Health asked fast food outlets to use less salt in their meals. ✔
Regulations were put in place to reduce salt content in fast food meals. ✔ Legislation to reduce salt in fast foods was signed. ✔
They took the matter to parliament. ✔
NOTE: Accept any TWO of the above answers. (2)
1.9 Fast foods in the UK and the USA are lower in salt content.✔Their legislation regulating salt content in meals was enforced earlier. ✔ (2)
1.10 B/ compulsory✔ (1)
1.11 Open-ended. Accept a suitable response, e.g.
Yes. Readers are made aware of the dangers of too much salt intake especially at fast food outlets. The information in the passage will prompt them to become more health conscious.
AND/OR
No. Readers have become accustomed to unhealthy habits and it will be difficult for them to change their ways. There is little evidence in the passage which will persuade readers to stop eating fast food.
NOTE: Accept other suitable responses provided that they are grounded in the text. A candidate can score 1 or 2 marks for an answer that is not well-substantiated. (3)
1.12 Open-ended. Accept a suitable response, e.g.
The word pinch refers to a small amount of salt which is what the passage is about; we should therefore reduce our salt intake.
AND/OR
'Pinch' suggests a little salt. The passage is all about excessive salt intake.
NOTE: Accept other suitable responses provided that they are grounded in the text. A candidate can score 1 mark for an answer that is not well substantiated. Accept answers that relate the passage to the idiom 'a pinch of salt'. (2)
1.13 A weather / meteorological/climatic report / a weather forecast /a long term weather forecast/expected weather for a week (for Mbombela). (1)
1.14
It will be cloudier on Saturday.✔The picture of the clouds is larger for Saturday than for Friday/The picture of the sun is smaller for Saturday.✔
OR
It will be brighter on Friday than on Saturday.✔ The picture of the clouds is smaller for Friday/The picture of the sun is bigger for Friday.✔ (2)
1.15 Monday (1)
1.16 Open-ended. Accept a suitable response, e.g.
The visuals convey clearly what the weather will be on each day. /The reader can easily see each day's weather. Thus the message of the text is accurate.
OR
The temperatures and the visuals do not correspond for each day. For example, a low temperature of 21 and the high temperature of 28 both have the same visual without any variations. In contrast, the two days with the same temperature of 23 degrees have visuals that vary. This can be misleading and so, does not convey the message of the text accurately.
NOTE: Accept other suitable responses provided that they are grounded in the text. A candidate can score 1 mark for an answer that is not well substantiated. (2)
TOTAL SECTION A: 30
SECTION B: SUMMARY
QUESTION 2
The following points form the answer to the question:
QUOTATIONS | FACTS | ||
1. | 'It is important to repair or replace damaged water connections and washers to stop all leaks.' | 1. | Fix leaking pipes / replace damaged washers. |
2. | 'Filling a tub to take a bath uses double the amount of water than when one uses a shower.' | 2. | Take a shower instead of a bath. |
3. | 'A dual flush toilet system needs far less water than the tank system.' | 3. | Use a dual flush toilet system rather than a tank system. |
4. | 'Water harvesting involves the collection of rainwater from gutters into a tank. This water can replace or supplement the main source of water when necessary.' | 4. | Collect rainwater to substitute or complement your regular source of water. |
5. | 'The grey water system entails diverting water mainly from the bathroom into a tank. This water can be utilised in the garden.' | 5. | Recycle water from the bathroom for use in the garden. |
6. | 'Pay attention to the kinds of trees and plants that you have in your garden as some consume more water than others, especially those that are not indigenous.' | 6. | Choose trees and plants that do not require much water for your garden./ Indigenous plants need less water than exotic ones. |
7. | 'When you have to make a cup of tea or coffee, boil only the required amount of water.' | 7. | Boil only the quantity of water you need (when making a hot beverage). |
8. | 'We waste water when we leave the tap running while brushing our teeth or washing dishes. However, using a jug or dish will help conserve water.' | 8. | Use a container when brushing your teeth or washing dishes./ Do not wash dishes or brush your teeth under running water. |
MARKING THE SUMMARY
The summary should be marked as follows:
NOTE:
TOTAL SECTION B: 10
SECTION C: LANGUAGE
NOTE:
QUESTION 3: ANALYSING AN ADVERTISEMENT
3.1 People who suffer from allergies or hay fever./Parents whose children suffer from allergies. ✔ (1)
3.2 One can ask one's pharmacist/chemist about a product that will keep allergies away./ Buy/Use products from Dr Reddy’s/the brand that keeps allergies away. ✔ (1)
3.3
Visual: The picture of a film strip./The scary font resembling that which is used to advertise horror movies./The scary pictures of the cat/pollen.✔
Verbal: The suspenseful language: 'It lurks…', 'It hides…and waits …', 'Get the tissues ready for …' /'Starts 1 September' resembles the opening date of a movie.✔ (2)
3.4 To create suspense for what is to follow./To show that the sentence above the picture will continue below the picture.✔ (1)
3.5 Laboratory✔
NOTE: Do not penalise for the omission of the initial capital letter. (1)
3.6 The onset/start of spring/ the date on which the products will be available✔ when allergies/hay fever begin(s)/pollen is released. ✔ (2)
3.7 Open-ended. Accept a suitable response, e.g.
It is effective because the advertiser makes use of horror movie techniques to show that allergies might be serious for some people.
AND/OR
It is not effective because the product is not clearly mentioned./ It is not effective because not everyone would associate a cat with allergies, thus the message of the advertisement will be lost.
NOTE: The above are merely examples. A candidate can score 1 mark for an answer that is not well-substantiated. (2) [10]
QUESTION 4: ANALYSING A CARTOON
4.1
4.1.1 In the garden/outside/ along the fence between the two houses. ✔ (1)
4.1.2 Blondie stares at the lawnmower/ leans forward/ with her hands on her hips/. The lawnmower is not being operated by anyone. ✔
NOTE: Accept any ONE of the above answers. (1)
4.1.3 Power switch/starter of the lawnmower.✔
The husband/Dagwood/the man. ✔ (2)
4.2 isn't it/ is it not (1)
4.3 C/hammock (1)
4.4
His mouth is wide open.✔
The letter 'Z' (is written in large, bold font).✔
His arm is hanging down limply.✔
NOTE: Accept any TWO of the above answers. (2)
4.5 Open-ended. Accept a suitable response, e.g.
Yes. She does not get angry. She probably knows her husband and that he will attend to the lawn later.
AND/OR
No. Dagwood shirks his duty to mow the lawn. She should have been angry.
NOTE: The above are merely examples. A candidate can score 1 mark for an answer that is not well-substantiated. (2) [10]
QUESTION 5: LANGUAGE AND EDITING SKILLS
5.1
5.1.1
5.1.2 collection/pile/set/stack ✔ (1)
5.1.3 Are you right to hesitate?✔ (1)
5.1.4 B/alliteration✔ (1)
5.1.5 She said that the next day/following day✔ she✔ would spend✔ the day at the beach.
OR
She said that she✔would spend✔ the next day/following day✔at the beach.
NOTE: Award ONE mark for each underlined change and ONE mark for correct punctuation. (4)
5.1.6 Serious damage can be caused by heat. ✔ (1)
5.1.7 Accept a suitable response e.g. He presented his case in court. ✔ (1)
5.1.8 dangers/hazards/threats/risks✔ (1)
5.2
5.2.1 I ✔ (1)
5.2.2 unimportant/insignificant/trivial/minor/immaterial✔ (1)
5.2.3 National Eye Care Awareness Month will take place until 18 October. ✔ (1)
5.2.4 It is (worth making the time to take proper care of your eyes.)✔ (1)
5.2.5 Make your eye health a priority.✔ (1)
5.2.6 healthier✔ (1)
TOTAL SECTION C: 40
GRAND TOTAL: 80